3 ms·
Well, it's not as bad as Q1. But way down from last year. It's amusing to see what Tesla puts in a filing in which material mis-statements are felonies. It's q
by Animats 2y ago
Well, it's not as bad as Q1. But way down from last year.
It's amusing to see what Tesla puts in a filing in which material mis-statements are felonies.
It's quite different from what Musk says when he can get away with it.
The phrase "full self driving" is never written out. They do use "FSD (Supervised)" twice, both with the footnote in tiny type "Active driver supervision required; does not make the vehicle autonomous." The closest thing to a mention of real autonomous driving is "Looking ahead to future
autonomous driving and robotaxi service, we continued progress on software and hardware
development." Remember that Tesla announced the reveal of their robo-taxi for August 8, 2024, but that's been cancelled.[1]
On the battery front, Tesla is having a bad year.[2] Tesla is trying to make their own cells, rather than buying them from Panasonic or CATL. It's not working well at all. Also, note the total absence of any mention of solid-state batteries. That's clearly the coming technology, and Tesla is nowhere in that space. (Yes, solid state batteries are real. On sale at Home Depot now.[3])
This is a big car company having a so-so year. Ford and GM have years like this. Ford's P/E ratio is around 15. GM's is around 6. Tesla's is around 68. Nothing in this report justifies that.
[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-07-11/tesla-plans-to-delay-robotaxi-unveiling-to-october-from-august https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024-07-11/tesla-pla...
[2] https://electrek.co/2024/07/17/elon-musk-might-give-up-tesla-4680-battery-cell-end-of-the-year/ https://electrek.co/2024/07/17/elon-musk-might-give-up-tesla...
[3] https://www.homedepot.com/p/YOSHINO-Solid-State-Portable-Power-Station-4-000W-6-000W-Peak-Push-Button-Start-Battery-Generator-for-Home-Camping-RV-B4000-SST/327262379 https://www.homedepot.com/p/YOSHINO-Solid-State-Portable-Pow...
- grecy 2y ago> This is a big car company having a so-so year. Ford and GM have years like this. Ford's P/E ratio is around 15. GM's is around 6. Tesla's is around 68. Nothing in this report justifies that. Telsa is not a car company, any anyone that thinks that way is completely missing the point
- aynyc 2y agoAre they a software company? Maybe energy company? Not sure what they are.
- paulryanrogers 2y agoThen what? Meme stock? Super charger network? Vibes company?
- Animats 2y agoTesla is a car company. Anyone who thinks otherwise hasn't read the financials. Tesla is over 20 years old. This is not a startup company any more.
- grecy 2y agoTesla currently makes most of it's revenue from cars, but that is not going to remain true for long. Energy storage, Optimus and self-driving cars are predicted to generate much, much more. Of course, I'm not saying it's a certainty, but it's clearly the goal. Elon bets everything on his visions, so it's either going to come true or Tesla will fail. Either way, Tesla won't be a "car company" much longer.
- TheAlchemist 2y agoIf Tesla is really betting its future on those other projects, like Optimus or Dojo, could you explain why they are not mentionning them almost at all in regulatory fillings ? They are only mentionned is some very broad way, without any specifics - mostly on Twitter, through Musk or other non legally binding communications. I will give you a hint. The chances of going to prison for lying to investors are very low. The chances of going to prison for lying in regulatory fillings are very different.
- grecy 2y ago> could you explain why they are not mentionning them almost at all in regulatory fillings ? I don't understand the legalities around regulatory filings, or why a company would be required to file details about their future plans and goals. If they're planning to make a ton of money from some future product, what regulatory filings are they required to make about that? In the last two investor calls Elon has said repeatedly he expects Optimus and self-driving to value tesla at well over $5B. Again, I'm not saying for one second I think it will come true, just that Elon is being extremely clear that is the plan. I firmly believe it will either come true or Tesla will fail.
- 2y ago