3 ms·
> “Back in the day, people used to sort of get around LinkedIn stuff by just dropping a link in the comments and saying, ‘Hey, check out the comments,’” Jung ex
by simonw 2y ago
> “Back in the day, people used to sort of get around LinkedIn stuff by just dropping a link in the comments and saying, ‘Hey, check out the comments,’” Jung explains. “Problem is, LinkedIn actually parses if you're the first person to comment in your post, if you're the first person to add a link, even if you actually write, like, the website, but remove the .com and say ‘dot com,’ this algorithm is on to you. It's immediately going to take your post and downrank it.”
Is that really true? It sounds like the kind of superstition that shows up in opaque systems like LinkedIn and TikTok all the time. But maybe it IS true?
I'd love to see experimental confirmation of this, but it's hard to design transparent experiments like that without the risk of burning a valuable LinkedIn account.
- meowtimemania 2y agoSounds spam detection
- scarface_74 2y agoAs if most of the people who post prolifically on LinkedIn trying to be seen as “thought leaders” aren’t spamming the site regardless of whether it has a link.
- hyperpape 2y agoHillel Wayne asked this on LinkedIn, and people came out of the woodwork to suggest they'd personally measured it. It does sound like something that could be a superstition, but it seems to be real.
- apwheele 2y agoSo I am tiny fish, https://www.linkedin.com/company/crime-de-coder/ https://www.linkedin.com/company/crime-de-coder/, so not quite sure what typical impressions look like for the big influencers (currently my company webpage has 2700 followers). LinkedIn lets you grab your stats for posts over the past year -- have only recently heard the thing about urls, I pretty much always shared posts with URLs. (My company webpage for along time was not indexed at all on Bing, but my LinkedIn posts did come up.) Here are my stats aggregated to domain for impressions for all domains I posted 2+ over the past year. I suspected youtube links are not promoted, and this confirms this. Also the local Raleigh newspaper is not doing so hot. But otherwise my NO URL posts don't do any better offhand than the linked ones. | domain | count | mean | std | min | 25% | 50% | 75% | max | |:--------------------------------------|--------:|-------:|------:|------:|------:|------:|------:|------:| | crimede-coder.com | 61 | 1304 | 1261 | 345 | 625 | 854 | 1380 | 7179 | | andrewpwheeler.com | 53 | 1309 | 820 | 481 | 813 | 1074 | 1501 | 4463 | | NO URL | 13 | 937 | 489 | 453 | 692 | 850 | 909 | 2413 | | www.tandfonline.com | 6 | 1655 | 682 | 967 | 1119 | 1572 | 1960 | 2764 | | journals.sagepub.com | 6 | 1613 | 983 | 669 | 839 | 1363 | 2207 | 3134 | | link.springer.com | 5 | 3029 | 2810 | 1478 | 1722 | 1753 | 2154 | 8038 | | github.com | 5 | 873 | 170 | 658 | 838 | 864 | 874 | 1134 | | www.newsobserver.com | 5 | 496 | 144 | 363 | 365 | 459 | 626 | 670 | | www.crimrxiv.com | 4 | 1990 | 1678 | 489 | 585 | 1871 | 3275 | 3730 | | onlinelibrary.wiley.com | 4 | 1851 | 1258 | 817 | 1276 | 1452 | 2028 | 3684 | | www.carolinascrimeanalysis.org | 4 | 988 | 198 | 799 | 850 | 956 | 1094 | 1241 | | www.youtube.com | 3 | 457 | 160 | 281 | 388 | 496 | 545 | 595 | | theconversation.com | 2 | 2308 | 1151 | 1494 | 1901 | 2308 | 2715 | 3123 | | crimesciencejournal.biomedcentral.com | 2 | 2158 | 987 | 1460 | 1809 | 2158 | 2507 | 2856 | | papers.ssrn.com | 2 | 1719 | 387 | 1445 | 1582 | 1719 | 1856 | 1993 | | alexchohlaswood.com | 2 | 1505 | 585 | 1091 | 1298 | 1505 | 1712 | 1919 | | www.jratcliffe.net | 2 | 1349 | 552 | 958 | 1153 | 1349 | 1544 | 1740 | | osf.io | 2 | 1138 | 465 | 809 | 973 | 1138 | 1303 | 1468 | | academic.oup.com | 2 | 874 | 379 | 606 | 740 | 874 | 1008 | 1143 | | asc41.org | 2 | 841 | 665 | 371 | 606 | 841 | 1076 | 1312 | | www.amazon.com | 2 | 803 | 151 | 696 | 749 | 803 | 856 | 910 | | americansebp.org | 2 | 798 | 627 | 354 | 576 | 798 | 1020 | 1242 | So no experiment, but some hard numbers at least!