5 ms·
Switzerland now requires all government software to be open source
- rasengan 2y agoThis is really smart, and I hope this becomes the norm across all governments. Governments not knowing what their software is doing is a recipe for chaos. Hopefully this also leads to more audits of said code.
- stairlane 2y agoHopefully this also introduces standardized auditing of open sourced packages. Just because something is open sourced, doesn’t mean it’s altruistic and not susceptible to malicious actors submitting seemingly innocuous code that gives bad actors a back door. The xz fiasco earlier this year should encourage every organization to conduct such audits. A code smell could and should be enough for packages to not be supported.
- Log_out_ 2y agoObvious strategy to reduce legaö risks like the postmaster debacle.
- highcountess 2y agoFor anyone who has not heard of the “postmaster debacle”, as I; it is a stunning atrocity of government that appears to have affected 3,650 people who were hounded and persecuted and prosecuted for various types of theft and malfeasance even though it was a glitch in the Fujitsu software that caused whatever appeared to have been thefts or irregularities in the accounting that was the basis for the government tyrannical terror descending on these people. It also cause at least four (4) suicides. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Post_Office_scandal https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/British_Post_Office_scandal I suspect this also has its roots in the European legal tendency to presume guilt and the accused having to prove their innocence, far more than the system has also been poisoned with in the USA. It’s not perfect and getting worse in the USA, but in the past, it would have been incumbent upon the prosecution to prove you actually stole, not just that the system used indicated irregularities. For example there would have to be evidence of money transfers, exceptional lifestyles, video surveillance of stealing money, or at least witness testimony of some kind validating that money was stolen, etc. If something was stolen, it essentially has to be shown what happened to it, i.e., it was in the possession/control of the accused.
- Gormo 2y ago> I suspect this also has its roots in the European legal tendency to presume guilt and the accused having to prove their innocence This scandal took place in the UK, though, not in a European civil code jurisdiction. The concept of "presumption of innocence" originates in English common law.
- M2Ys4U 2y agoUnder British law, however, courts presume that a computer system is working flawlessly unless proven otherwise, so if computer says guilty it'll be tough to convince a jury that you're not. And that was made even harder by the massive and continuous perjury by the Post Office when it came to the robustness of the system
- trollied 2y agoSee also, gov.uk: https://github.com/alphagov https://github.com/alphagov https://www.gov.uk/guidance/be-open-and-use-open-source https://www.gov.uk/guidance/be-open-and-use-open-source
- austin-cheney 2y agoThe US government, especially the military, is largely allergic to software. This is slowly starting to change, but only in small pockets. I am aware of three software teams in the military but they are highly specialized with small dedicated customers. I have tried several times to get Node.js into the military on approved software lists for internal development and its a huge struggle. I suspect the main culprits are due to valid security concerns regarding package managers like NPM and old ignorant thinking about open source being either immature or open software being a wide open exploitation vector. That is really tough because there aren't official binaries of Node without NPM and ignorant thinking about open source is really persistent.
- SV_BubbleTime 2y agoI mean… open source IS suffering insecurity issues. A lot of the supply chain failures I can think of, were open source projects. I’m not saying node or OSS has no place, but there is more than something to do t being a security issue. How many years was heartbleed exploitable despite “all the eyes on it”? The good part about OSS is all the people that can review it, the bad part is all the people that can review it. Now… which one is more incentivized today ignoring a future military use? It only works when assets are put into hardening existing code.
- recursivedoubts 2y agoi can think of no act more deviously effective in bringing down the american empire than introducing the NPM ecosystem into its vital bloodstream, well played comrade!
- rawgabbit 2y agoIf you had to select a single programming language, for US government agencies to use, which one would you pick?
- recursivedoubts 2y agogo or java, in that order
- mr90210 2y agoFor the untested in this subject you’ve got to research about Brazil’s effort to use as much open source as they can at the state level. They’ve been doing so for nearly 20 years. https://opensource.com/government/12/8/brazil-forefront-open-source-initiatives https://opensource.com/government/12/8/brazil-forefront-open...
- fmobus 2y agoYet the Brazilian government releases little of its own code publicly. I'm still waiting for the ballot machine code. Brazilian government's relation with open technology is such a weird thing. Lula and Dilma government were huge sponsors of free software conferences like FISL, with several ministries and agencies with huge booths and whatnot - but most of their actual technical side was just "we use libre office or Zimbra or whatever". All talk, no action. One thing that specially made me angry was the lack of commitment with open data. The post office was eager to sponsor conferences, but kept zip code data under lock and key, only allowing a CAPTCHAd query tool for people, and selling API access to companies for huge prices. This was actually only fixed... during the right wing governments that followed (can't remember if Temer or Bolsonaro).
- bauruine 2y agoThere was a talk about this at this years FOSDEM [0] Regarding the "Several European countries are betting on open-source software for their technology. In the United States, eh, not so much." I thought software developed by the US govt is public domain? At least that's how I remember sqlite got it's license because it was developed for the US Navy. [0] https://fosdem.org/2024/schedule/event/fosdem-2024-3401-the-new-swiss-open-source-law-public-money-public-code-by-default/ https://fosdem.org/2024/schedule/event/fosdem-2024-3401-the-...
- ohples 2y agoAh yes. Except most software the US Government uses was developed by contractors .
- dgb23 2y agoThis forward thinking makes me proud.
- netsharc 2y agoReading the sourced link, it's currently only for federal government institutions, a lot of things, like the "DMV", or social services, are still the domain of the Kantons (equivalent to a US state). So it's "all" but in a different context to what you might understand as "all". ;)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ChrisArchitect 2y ago[dupe] Some more discussion earlier this month: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40852084 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40852084
- dwheeler 2y agoThis doesn't require all software used by Switzerland to be open source. Per the article: > This new law requires all public bodies to disclose the source code of software developed by or for them unless third-party rights or security concerns prevent it. This "public money, public code" approach aims to enhance government operations' transparency, security, and efficiency.
- filipheremans 2y agoSounds great. Except that as a company, you can now only deliver services to this government. No products, since you will lose your competitive advantage. This is a big disadvantage for for instance startups that target this market.
- dgb23 2y agoIt’s a disadvantage if you require proprietary licenses, but an advantage if you leverage open source licenses.
- Brian_K_White 2y agoI don't hear anything I care about, or that anyone should care about, under the "except" column. Don't target that market if you don't like the terms. Someone else will. I will.
- rdsubhas 2y agoGood ideas finally need government backing and adoption to scale and sustain. OSS has been facing tough times since cloud providers like AWS came in. Moves like this will help keep the open source spirit alive. Really proud to see this and hope more governments go this way.