3 ms·

Hold on, does Android not require the application to include something in its manifest in order to be granted APK installation permission? Like how for every ot

Hold on, does Android not require the application to include something in its manifest in order to be granted APK installation permission? Like how for every other permission request an app has to declare upfront that it requires/may request that permission?

vel0city 2y ago
It's not really Telegram that's installing the APK. It's just trying to open the file with your default APK file handler. Which is the system, and by default doesn't allow arbitrary APK installation. Think using a browser to download an installer. You download the installer, then open the installer file, it's not the browser that's installing the software it's you opening the installer file. Telegram shouldn't assume it's a video file because that makes it confusing for the user, but tbh if I want to send a friend an APK and they want to install it shouldn't that be allowed? Software freedom, control over your own device and all?
- daghamm 2y ago
  Telegram should not be tricked into downloading an apk as a video. I assume you can send a normal apk to your friends and Telegram correctly warns the recipient when that happens. But when it's a "video"...
- idle_zealot 2y ago
  So the way it works is: an app initiates an Open intent with the apk, the system handles this as an install, then the installer checks to see if the app initiating the intent has the "install unknown applications" permission. The problem is that the user can grant any application that special permission. It shouldn't work like that; an app should have to list that permission as one it accepts, which would avoid scenarios like this without interfering with user freedom (you can download the apk sent on Telegram, then open it in your file browser or something which allows itself to be given app installation permission).

3 ms·

Hold on, does Android not require the application to include something in its manifest in order to be granted APK installation permission? Like how for every ot

by idle_zealot 2y ago

vel0city 2y ago
It's not really Telegram that's installing the APK. It's just trying to open the file with your default APK file handler. Which is the system, and by default doesn't allow arbitrary APK installation. Think using a browser to download an installer. You download the installer, then open the installer file, it's not the browser that's installing the software it's you opening the installer file. Telegram shouldn't assume it's a video file because that makes it confusing for the user, but tbh if I want to send a friend an APK and they want to install it shouldn't that be allowed? Software freedom, control over your own device and all?
- daghamm 2y ago
  Telegram should not be tricked into downloading an apk as a video. I assume you can send a normal apk to your friends and Telegram correctly warns the recipient when that happens. But when it's a "video"...
- idle_zealot 2y ago
  So the way it works is: an app initiates an Open intent with the apk, the system handles this as an install, then the installer checks to see if the app initiating the intent has the "install unknown applications" permission. The problem is that the user can grant any application that special permission. It shouldn't work like that; an app should have to list that permission as one it accepts, which would avoid scenarios like this without interfering with user freedom (you can download the apk sent on Telegram, then open it in your file browser or something which allows itself to be given app installation permission).