3 ms·
> And if you read this article carefully, you see that while it uses these two CRT questions as examples of tricky questions, when it discusses the results abou
by gwern 14y ago
> And if you read this article carefully, you see that while it uses these two CRT questions as examples of tricky questions, when it discusses the results about awareness-of-bias not helping alleviate bias, it isn't necessarily saying smart people do worse on those two CRT questions. It's a bit muddled in what it's saying, and reviewing the linked abstract doesn't help much either. The paper is evaluating some very specific things under the umbrella term 'cognitive sophistication', which might not map to what we usually call 'smart' or even 'test-smart'.
Fulltext: http://dl.dropbox.com/u/5317066/2012-west.pdf http://dl.dropbox.com/u/5317066/2012-west.pdf
No, the smart people essentially never perform worse on the CRT or bias questions than their stupider confreres. What the headline is boasting about is that when asked to guess whether they will do better on the biases than their cohort, the smarter people tend to think they will do much better than their cohort, but actually do only a tiny bit better or identical.
But as the authors admit at the very end, this may be a reasonable generalization from their lives, in which they observe smart people outperforming stupid people at just about everything and these biases were selected from the big heuristics & biases literature for being resistance to raw smarts...