6 ms·
Apple’s Ping to End With a Thud in Next Release of iTunes
- mikek 14y agoPing is one of the few Steve Jobs-approved product failures. Even MobileMe eventually morphed into iCloud. Ping was DOA.
- dmix 14y agoIt was built with music studios in mind, not music fans. Plus it didn't improve over time and was rarely marketed.
- steve8918 14y agoActually, Steve Jobs' track record is closer to 50-50 in terms of successes vs failures. The difference is that his failures were usually not very significant, and his successes were monstrous.
- sneak 14y agoAre you counting the totally unprofitable development of NeXTStep as a success or failure (considering that NeXT would very likely have died had Apple not bought them)? (Those same APIs and objective paradigms became the basis for the entire iOS app ecosystem, via MacOS...)
- david_shaw 14y agoIt's actually really interesting that this product took so long to get axed. Even Google+ had an initial surge of users that loved it (and some still do), but I've never met anyone that was a Ping lover (or, as far as I know, even a willing Ping user).
- jpxxx 14y agoI work primarily with Hardcore Apple Partisans. When they'd ask what Ping was, I'd say "It's this thing where you can buy a song and then talk about it with your friends." Their eyes would be fluttering away by the end of the sentence. Nobody, not a one ever, cared at all. There are a thousand other venues to discuss music with friends, most of them involving alcohol. I personally feel Ping could have been amazing were it a rewards shop that rewarded you with extras for buying tracks. You buy a top single - a free remix of that song is offered on the side. Nothing obligatory, just extra. You buy an album - Ping provides that album's music videos and a writeup from the band. You buy a pop song from a hot entertainer - you're entered into a raffle for show tickets. You buy a karaoke standard - Ping asks for your best Photo Booth karaoke version that gets uploaded, shared, and voted on next to that standard. If it was value-adding what you were buying, I think that would be interesting. But hearing your Address Book chime in on a trashy single you bought? No thank you.
- Alex3917 14y agoIt would be cool if it worked like a prediction market as well, so that if you were one of the first people to buy a song that later became very popular you could actually make money.
- CrazedGeek 14y agoA bit like Amie Street? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amie_Street http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amie_Street
- whichdan 14y agoI buy a decent amount of albums, and I do 90% Amazon MP3 and 10% iTunes - Amazon MP3 is consistently $1+ cheaper, which amounts to a free album every 7 or 8, in comparison. iTunes would need some serious deals to beat that.
- chrisdroukas 14y agoRolling iTunes Originals into Ping somehow could've partially solved that problem. Using Ping (?) would give users exclusive access to original content. Honestly, a Last.fm acquisition would've been their best bet.
- leothekim 14y agoThese things happen. Next.
- 51Cards 14y ago"At this point, years into the social networking phenomenon, why not leave the social stuff to the social people who are good at it?" While I acknowledge that Ping was a huge failure the above statement strikes me as odd. If that's so obvious then... Why not leave Maps to people who are good at it? Why not leave voice recognition to people who are good at it? Why not leave... etc. Apple hasn't been shy about diving into competitor's markets... which I don't always agree with fully. But on the flip side, you don't know if you don't try I guess.
- chj 14y agoThat explains why iOS is not a good platform. The owner of this platform loses his focus (building a good platform, giving developers more power), instead it starts to duplicate developers' effort in the name of user experience. Surely they have a chance of doing it better, but it is just because they can use their private APIs.
- ryannielsen 14y agoAre you very familiar with iOS development? I ask because those people I know who are were very happy with the improvements and APIs added in past iOS releases and seem to be delighted with what's being released with iOS 6. Perhaps you've found yourself hampered by the lack of certain APIs that Apple has yet to add or yet to promote from SPI. I know some devs in that boat. But I don't think you can accuse Apple of having lost focus on the iOS platform, or that they aren't feverishly working to give devs more power.
- chj 14y agoA very important missing feature is external keyboard event support. I don't want to go too far into the details, just let me tell you this: ESC, Function Keys,CTRL, ALT are all dead. I submitted a feature request among other developers like the month iPad came out. So far, no any sign of adding it. Yet we continue to see Apple adding this message that reminder.
- deleted 14y ago
- makecheck 14y agoI think Ping was too specific. When we've already built up 99% of the infrastructure required to share anything we want (e.g. messages, photos, videos, links, entire pages on Facebook), it's very hard to see the point of a service that specializes in sharing exactly one thing. The timing was also horrible. Some of the technologies currently available for sharing are 5 or 10 years old or more, so what the heck was supposed to be revolutionary about Ping? It needed to arrive before there was Facebook or Twitter.
- bodyfour 14y agoI actually thought the timing could have been good. When it was announced, MySpace was clearly in death-spiral mode but still a lot of bands were using it as their primary online presence. I thought Ping had at least a shot at being the place they moved to. Obviously it didn't work out that way. My hunch is that Apple's feelings on the project were "lets throw this out there and see if it sticks". It clearly didn't, and now they'll move on. When you're making $1500 in profit a second you can experiment a little.
- r00fus 14y ago> My hunch is that Apple's feelings on the project were "lets throw this out there and see if it sticks" Which is somewhat uncharacteristic of Apple and what some folks blame Google for doing repeatedly. I hope Ping's failure resulted in a lot of lessons learned about the social space.
- michaelhoffman 14y agoAnd nothing of value was lost.
- ethank 14y agoPing was a concession to the labels who asked for an alternative to MySpace with a revenue model. It was never given much attention by Apple internally, nor was it a source of "pride" for anyone really. I remember when it was first introduced, a good number of us at labels were thinking, "great, another marketing platform to update for a bit, then have go stale." Plus it was supposed to have Facebook integration, which was pulled quickly after launch.
- Groxx 14y ago>“We tried Ping, and I think the customer voted and said ‘This isn’t something that I want to put a lot of energy into,’” Cook said. Good. That is exactly the kind of decision they should be making. Thank you, Cook, for rather quickly killing something that deserved to die.
- kittxkat 14y agoI always wondered why Apple never aquired Last.fm, it's such a simple service and would've perfectly fitted within iTunes.
- bnr 14y agoLast.fm was sold to CBS in 2007. It also has lots of legacy client apps on many different platforms to support - I doubt that's something Apple would want to do.
- ToesByNoon 14y agoIf a tree falls in the woods, and there's nobody there to hear it, does it make a sound?
- smackfu 14y agoI remember one of the big selling points was basically artist blogs, like Lady Gaga. Were those ever updated?