15 ms·
How fast can a human possibly run 100 meters?
- log101 2y agoPlease don’t do it, this will surely limit out potential!
- tiffanyh 2y agoHeight I'm surprised height was never mentioned in the article. Usain Bolt is 6'5" (1.98m).
- LorenzoGood 2y agoSo you want Su-Bingtan acceleration, combined with Usain Bolts top speed.
- amai 2y agoWith or without doping? https://enhanced.org/ https://enhanced.org/
- fuzzfactor 2y ago>How fast can a human possibly run 100 meters? From what I've seen, it depends on how soon the train or plane is going to be leaving the gate . . .
- tfhfj 2y ago[flagged]
- nsjolj 2y ago[flagged]
- boringg 2y agoBetter question why do we spend so many global resources on such a useless metric for humanity in its current life? When would you ever need to be so fast at 100m that you over train your body for one specific task?
- bglazer 2y agoHow many people and resources (dollars) would you estimate are involved in professional track and field? Bonus points if you express this as a proportion of total human population and economic activity
- SketchySeaBeast 2y agoMight I introduce you to the concept of sports in general? We build giant coliseums costing hundreds of millions of dollars devoted to keeping ice cold in the middle of summer just so people can answer the question of who is best at stick puck.
- bluefirebrand 2y agoSports serve a social purpose, and contribute positively to society's overall fitness since most people playing sports aren't pro athletes A 100m sprint, as fast as humanly possible is super impressive, but the person you're replying to does have a point: this is an extremely specific and narrow activity with no purpose other than competition. You don't socialize with sprinting, and most people wouldn't use 100m sprinting as an activity to improve their fitness At best, it's designed to test fitness, but it even fails at that really
- tatersolid 2y agoI’d wager that sprinting races, like most sport, have their origins in warfare. Being able to move from point of cover A to point B as quickly as possible is very useful in avoiding projectile weapons.
- SketchySeaBeast 2y agoThat seems too complicated. Racing from one point to the other it's really one of the simplest things two people can do and it's one of those purest expressions of athletic ability. Even animals do it.
- SketchySeaBeast 2y ago
- Jarmsy 2y agoAren't the numbers at the start of the article mixed up? It starts by saying "Other than Bolt, no human has ever run 100 meters in under 9.73 seconds" Then just below there's a table of records showing 3 other runners with sub 9.73 times.
- Grifnag 2y agoThey might have changed the article. It now says "Other than Bolt, no human has ever run 100 meters in under 9.69 seconds". The table then shows Tyson Gay and Yohan Blake have matched that time, but not beaten it.
- ry4nolson 2y agoright before that line it says bolt ran it in 9.58, no one else has ever ran UNDER 9.69
- Jarmsy 2y agoAh indeed, they've edited it now.
- klooney 2y agoThe countries that stack medals in running- Jamaica, Kenya, the USA- all have serious problems with PEDs.
- chakintosh 2y ago> Tyson Gay Shouldn't even be considered due to his history with doping.
- noarchy 2y ago>Shouldn't even be considered due to his history with doping. People are naive about how much sports are riddled with PEDs. It certainly isn't just Tyson Gay. You only know about the ones who get caught. But there is enough info out there to suggest that getting caught is just a matter of slipping up.
- tcfunk 2y agoI've never seen Usain Bolt's speed in terms of mph before this article. A top speed of 27.8 mph is seriously incredible. Granted I'm no professional sprinter, but when I try to go much beyond 14-15 my balance can't keep up with the cadence and I start to trip over myself.
- bluefirebrand 2y agoI'm betting there are people who can barely go 27.8 mph on a bike at their top speed That's unbelievable to imagine honestly, someone on a bike going as fast as they can and this guy sprinting past them But it's reality
- amalcon 2y agoA class 3 ebike (the kind legal on most streets but illegal on most rec paths due to their speed) has a top speed of 28mph, so I would say so. Barring a steep decline of course.
- martopix 2y agoI would say the _majority_ of people would not reach that speed on a bike in normal situations
- bluGill 2y agoA downhill where a road bike can reach that speed is pretty normal. I reach those nearly every day on my to work commute and I live in Iowa - there is a reason we are known for being flat so if I can find a hill to reach those speed surely anyone else can too. Of course I am riding a road bike, kids and mountain bikes may have limitations (tires?) that slow them down. Reaching those speeds on level ground doesn't seem possible for a normal human, but level ground is rare.
- PaulDavisThe1st 2y agoI'm not sure what you might mean by a "normal human". I used to be a back-of-the-front-of-the-pack triathlete, with a previous history as an ultramarathon and touring cyclist. In my best shape (probably aged around 46), I was training on a flat loop course with some younger very strong but not professional cyclists where we would generally pull the group at 28mph for about between 20-60 seconds at a time. I appreciate that there's a distance between that sort of thing and an "average person", but it's not a whole lot larger than the distance between the people who were in the group and, say, professional tour cyclists.
- jccalhoun 2y agoI've always said they need to have a non-athlete run next to the athletes so we can tell just how fast these runners are.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kazinator 2y agoElite race walkers embarrass recreational runners with sub-40 10 km times. There you are, running your heart out, and some guy walks right past you.
- rowanG077 2y agoIt's hardly "walking". It's basically just a silly way to run.
- ketzo 2y ago“Race walking” is distinguished from “running” based on technique. In this case, “walking” is defined very strictly as “never having both feet off the ground.” Yes, obviously it’s just a silly way to run, if “run” is “move fast on foot”. It’s just that “race walking” is fewer words than “a silly way to run where you have to keep one foot on the ground always.”
- inglor_cz 2y agoThis isn't strictly enforced, though.
- swores 2y agoIt's not that it isn't enforced, it's that the rule is very specifically that it must appear that one foot is always touching the ground when watched in real time with human eyes, the rule isn't that one foot must technically always be touching the ground.
- cb321 2y agoStatisticians think it can be gotten down to 9.51 seconds ( https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/08/090806080343.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/08/090806080343.h... ), though, as with most things statistical, knowledge of the underlying sampling process (biology/physiology & physics in this case) may shed more light. { Similarly, knowledge (& tweaking!) of OS schedulers may be able to reduce measurement noise more than pure statistics in a project to time software like https://github.com/c-blake/bu/blob/main/doc/tim.md https://github.com/c-blake/bu/blob/main/doc/tim.md .}
- herendin2 2y agoThat research was published before Bolt hacked another 0.1 seconds off the record, when he cut it down in one event from 9.69 to 9.58 I don’t think the research stands up.
- goatlover 2y agoHow do you know Bolt isn't close to the maximum? He is definitely an outlier.
- cb321 2y agoThey would certainly have to add that new data point to their analysis. :-) I expect it moves the estimate down by less than the 100 ms record beat, though. That's how converging to a true minimum tends to work (at least, like I said before, in the purely statistical modeling sense which is never quite as strong as a detailed micro-model).
- philipwhiuk 2y agoThe problem is, the stats ignores the evolving surfaces and shoe tech.
- cb321 2y agoUnsure how either of my comments could be read as disagreeing with your point - both mention physics/micro-models being stronger than pure stats, but maybe in spite of your "The problem is" phrasing you only meant to amplify or only read quickly. That said, I can perhaps respond with something amplifying & clarifying of our shared skepticism of the pure statistics approach relative to something "more detailed" that might someday somehow help someone. There are probably a half dozen micro-model effects even non-experts could rattle off that have "trended" over the decades from your shoes & surfaces to various aspects of population diet, young-in-life identification / more-optimized-maturation conditions and on & on. Statisticians call this a "non-stationary sampling process" meaning the independent & identically distributed (IID) assumption is at best a weak approximation and at worst totally misleading. Ways to measure how much evidence there is that IID / other distributional assumptions are failing do exist { such as some of the ones here: https://github.com/c-blake/fitl/blob/main/fitl/gof.nim https://github.com/c-blake/fitl/blob/main/fitl/gof.nim and referenced at the bottom of https://github.com/c-blake/bu/blob/main/doc/edplot.md https://github.com/c-blake/bu/blob/main/doc/edplot.md (at the stage where one "plots / pools together multiple data points into some kind of "sample" with a "distribution") }. Sadly, few test such assumptions (which are rarely truly comprehensive anyway) and even small departures from modeling assumptions may lead to relatively large errors in estimates. E.g., the linked to Einmahl 2009/2010 research states this as an assumption to apply the ideas, but then shows no test of that assumption on the used data.
- farceSpherule 2y agoHow fast? Is this with or without performance enhancing drugs?
- Mistletoe 2y agoI can read all these technical extrapolations of physics but I don’t think humans can run much faster than Usain or they would currently do so. Without more performance enhancing drugs and I’m assuming we don’t want that. We are going to live in a weird world in the future when we realize things can’t just continue forever up and to the right on all charts. We may just live at the plateau for eons. I believe we are all very lucky to have lived at a very special time in human history. https://www.cold-takes.com/this-cant-go-on/ https://www.cold-takes.com/this-cant-go-on/ And I think it is smart to prepare yourself for when the world realizes that stuffing money into stocks can’t give 10% every year forever. And all hell will break loose because that is what our whole world is currently built upon. I don’t know when that will happen, but mathematically we can prove that it must happen eventually.
- willsmith72 2y agoI was reading this carefully looking for the reason of "why this can't go on", and seemingly this is the reason > if the economy were 3*1070 times as big as today's, and could only make use of 1070 (or fewer) atoms, we'd need to be sustaining multiple economies as big as today's entire world economy per atom What kind of argument is that? Sounds like someone had an idea and went looking for evidence to support it. > mathematically we can prove that it must happen eventually Please explain, and not using a reasoning comparing dollars to atoms
- Mistletoe 2y agoThe math for increasing 10% per year over any long length of time gets so crazy that you have to use how many atoms exist as an absurd placeholder. Dollars don't work anymore. The rule of 72 says at 10% per year (historical returns in the stock market for the past 100 years) means you are doubling the value of the stock market every 7.2 years. Things like economies can't grow like that and if you are questioning why it's because you and I grew up in this era where they could for a brief blinking in time. Human reproduction is slowing, we've harvested all the low hanging fruit, "free" land is all taken. I feel like we are probably at the part of the 100m dash curve talked about here. https://condellpark.com/kd/sprintlogistic.htm https://condellpark.com/kd/sprintlogistic.htm At our current rate, the record of 9.48s will be reached in 500 years if you plot it. But I don't think people are going to maintain interest for 500 years to get there from 9.58 seconds.
- b450 2y agoI guess this is just a silly little thought experiment, but the final estimate (6.97s 100m) is quite ridiculous on its face. The heavy lifting seems to be done by the study linked in the "anatomical studies suggest peak speeds up to 15.6-17.9 m/s (35-40 mph) are achievable" line. I'm not sure where those exact numbers were pulled from - I can't find them with a cmd+f. One line in the study uses some nearby numbers: > If, for simplicity, we assume no change in contact lengths or the minimum aerial times needed to reposition the swing limbs at top speed, the average and greatest individual top speed hopping forces (Favg) of 2.71 and 3.35 Wb would allow top running speeds of 14.0 and 19.3 m/s and of 50 and 69 km/h, respectively But the study concludes that, even though our leg extensor muscles can produce much higher maximum forces than those generated during sprinting, the "contact length" imposes a constraint on these "hopping forces": > Because humans have limbs of moderate length and cannot gallop, they lack similar options for prolonging periods of foot-ground force application to attain faster sprinting speeds at existing contact time minimums. Consequently, human running speeds in excess of 50 km/h are likely to be limited to the realms of science fiction and, not inconceivably, gene doping. So the craziness of the original estimate seems to follow from on a misreading of that study.
- buildbot 2y agoHumans can’t gallop? https://www.discovermagazine.com/planet-earth/why-humans-prefer-not-to-gallop https://www.discovermagazine.com/planet-earth/why-humans-pre... https://journals.biologists.com/jeb/article/216/7/1338/12063/Biomechanics-of-human-bipedal-gallop-asymmetry https://journals.biologists.com/jeb/article/216/7/1338/12063...
- jamiek88 2y agoWe don’t do it efficiently or effectively would be better than saying we cannot do it. It’s only useful for going downhill quickly which we’ve all subconsciously or perhaps even mindfully done. From your link: > Gallopers exerted that effort unevenly, with the front leg doing more work than the back leg. And the galloping stride, researchers saw, demanded more from the hips than running did. This tired people out quickly. Out of 12 treadmill gallopers in the study, 4 gave up before the end of their 4-minute session, complaining of fatigue and stress in their hips and thighs. (An intended 13th galloper couldn't figure out how to gallop on the treadmill belt in the first place.) When researchers calculated their subjects' metabolic rates, they found that galloping was about 24% more costly than running at the same speed. In other words, galloping burns up more energy, takes more effort, and is less comfortable than running. It's no wonder we don't usually opt for it
- kawsper 2y agoThat guy Usain Bolt and his 9.58 seconds is nothing compared to my local Strava runners, all the segments are full of faster "runners".
- DrBazza 2y agoI can't remember - did the aboriginal man one get debunked? Stride length, and on mud, was longer than Bolt - implying faster than the 100m WR on an awful surface? https://www.scotsman.com/news/world/prehistoric-man-faster-than-a-speeding-bolt-2471569 https://www.scotsman.com/news/world/prehistoric-man-faster-t...
- Noumenon72 2y ago> Elite sprinters can apply peak forces of 800-1000 pounds (3560-4450 Newtons) to each limb. Beyond ~1300 pounds, ideal human leg bones would surely break[1]. I followed the link and it just said > If you're looking for the specifics to snap a piece of your skeleton, it takes about 4,000 newtons of force to break the typical human femur. So the sprinters are already producing that much force (900 pounds) and the 1300 notion seems unsupported. Not to mention that applying the force with different amounts of torque might not break the bone, since bones are 10x stronger in compression so can withstand a lot more force longitudinally. 1: https://www.discovery.com/science/force-to-break-bone https://www.discovery.com/science/force-to-break-bone
- test1235 2y agoI think we should be considering the weakest link in the chain here, the femur arguably being the strongest.
- monsieurbanana 2y agoI can't access the discovery link from europe. From your quotes, there seems to be an important difference: in the first quote they talk about "ideal human leg bones" and in the second one about a "typical human femur". I'm certain that an elite sprinter blessed in genetics has leg bones significantly stronger than the average human. Bones also get stronger from repetitive exercise.
- Someone 2y agoI would guess there also may be a difference between the two cases in that the force needed to break a leg wasn’t measured by compressing it, but by exerting force perpendicular to its length. Even if it isn’t, there are so many ways to measure breaking strength that it’s unlikely the two cases are perfectly comparable.
- silisili 2y agoThis was my assumption. The original article implies parallel force, which I imagine has far higher limit than perpendicular. Eg trying to chop a 1x4 in half long ways probably takes quite a bit of force(and a touch of stupidity).
- MisterBastahrd 2y agoWhat I want to see is an olympic sprinting event where the first 20 meters are dry land and the last 80 are a non-newtonian fluid.
- bregma 2y agoThat would also be great for gymnastics. And swimming. And especially tower diving.
- SketchySeaBeast 2y agoYou had me in the first half.
- hanniabu 2y agoSounds like a great way to break an ankle
- nothrowaways 2y ago> However, anatomical studies suggest peak speeds up to 15.6-17.9 m/s (35-40 mph) are achievable.
- moate 2y agoSo we have 2 different theses being posited by this article. The headline (how fast for 100 meters) and the whole rest of the article (how fast for 100 meters under racing rules). Just saying, these are different things.
- awahab92 2y ago[flagged]
- gadders 2y agoObligatory link to article discussing whether Usain was on PEDs or not: “When people ask me about Bolt, I say he could be the greatest athlete of all time. But for someone to run 10.03 one year and 9.69 the next, if you don’t question that in a sport that has the reputation it has right now, you’re a fool. Period.” Carl Lewis https://archive.ph/R6DOs#selection-553.0-553.255 https://archive.ph/R6DOs#selection-553.0-553.255
- soperj 2y agoDude would never believe that anyone could do what he couldn't without PEDs. Bolt ran a under 21s 200 meter at age 15. His 10.03 time was literally his debut time with the 100 meter.
- gadders 2y agoRTFA, not just the quote.
- philipwhiuk 2y agoCarl Lewis has tested positive for banned stimulants..
- gadders 2y agoThey all do it. I'm just saying Usain probably did as well.
- htrp 2y ago> One Australian physiologist calculated in 2014 that a sprinter with Bolt’s force could maintain it while also cutting contact time with the ground to just 70 milliseconds (down from 80 or so). This would result in a top speed of 12.75 meters per second, or 28.53mph – and a new world record of 9.27 seconds. https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2016/oct/03/how-fast-can-we-go-the-science-of-sprinting https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2016/oct/03/how-fas... ------------------------------- A more realistic assessment
- EA 2y agoBTW: if you are looking for something to latch onto with the Olympics starting this week, the USA vs Jamaica rivalry in the short distance trace events is a great David vs. Goliath story. The two countries have been battling back and forth with each other for the top spots for the last decade or longer. The runners have flamboyant personalities and these are some of the fastest sprinters we have ever seen; both men and women. There is a documentary on Netflix called 'Sprint' that sets the stage for this Olympics.
- ericmcer 2y agoI wish that show had focused a bit more on technique/training and less on personality, but it was super entertaining regardless.
- aantix 2y agoThere's a famous trainer, Ryan Flaherty. He gets guys ready for the NFL combine. He utilizes the hex-bar deadlift. He has his football athletes complete the concentric phase (picking up from the ground) as fast as possible. They just drop the weight when they reach full extension at the top. He claims that the eccentric phase (lowering) is when all of the micro-muscle tears occur. These tears cause muscle growth. By dropping the hex-bar deadlift weight at the top, instead of lowering, you get most of the strength gain, without the muscle size growth. This is an effort to increase leg strength (for speed) without adding additional body weight. Getting faster by getting stronger but staying lighter.
- pstorm 2y agoI've recently come to believe the differences in hypertrophy are negligible between eccentric and concentric focused movements, but can't find any recent, compelling research that says so. There was a 2017 meta analysis by Brad Schoenfeld (basically THE hypertrophy researcher) that showed a pretty significant different in hypertrophy: an average of 10% vs 6.8%. I know Greg Nuckols from StrongerByScience believes this is mostly caused by lifters, especially untrained lifters which most of the research is on, having spent less time in eccentric phases so there is more opportunity for growth there, but it will eventually plateau.
- klohto 2y agoI’m genuinely sorry for this, but what the fuck. * Can the misconception that micro-muscle tears cause growth just die? We already know since 90s that it’s the myonuclei addition driven by muscle tension. * There is no strength gain without muscle gain. There is not a single mechanism recorded that would drive this behavior. * This post made me angry on so many fucking levels. Hex-bar deadlift is at least a good choice for legs due to its lower load on lumbar. * Finally, it’s the concentric that drives most of the hypertrophy. Not eccentric. It’s why you see gym bros and most IFBB pros (gear aside) disregard eccentric control and hammer the concentric. Because that’s the movement that drives the growth. * Eccentric cause most fatigue (many types) and lowering slower on purpose would hinder recovery times (and growth as well since the relationship between the two exists)