3 ms·
It's different in that analog circuits aren't just a physical representation of a wiring diagram - they are something I know I could manipulate if needed. Cut o
by TeMPOraL 2y ago
It's different in that analog circuits aren't just a physical representation of a wiring diagram - they are something I know I could manipulate if needed. Cut out a part there and replace it with a substitute, splice some wires in and add more parts to add extra functionality, etc. Digital electronics? The chips are magic black boxes. And when they communicate using digital protocols, like SPI, I2C, UART, etc., then the physical properties of connections between the chips become irrelevant too - the connection is either present or missing, you can't manipulate the behavior by messing with the wire from outside. No soldering in a cap to change delays, or a 555 to add timed behavior. Almost all of the circuit is therefore hidden in magic black boxes, and whatever remains either works or it doesn't.
Now sure, I know now I can do digital electronics with the right tools. But the tools I can use, that most hobbyists and professionals can access, allow only limited control. You can't just fab yourself an alternate chip to do something, you have to buy the very specific one that happens to do what you want, or a more general one that can be reprogrammed. And you rarely can reprogram existing chips on a board you modify, because the vendors don't want to see the magic.
Yes, I too, as a kid, was pissed off about digital electronics, and regularly remarked to a friend that soon we'll have light switches and fridges implemented using microcontrollers. If I only knew how true that prediction would turn out...
Now the irony is, at that same time I was making those complains, I was also studying X86 assembly and C++, trying to learn how to make video games. Turns out, the common thread that connects programming computers and analog electronics is accessibility. I could do both for almost free, while gradually learning through experimentation. I couldn't do that with digital electronics - the cost and educational barrier was just too great.