2 ms·
I liked James Carville's idea of picking maybe eight contenders and having town hall type events to choose the most popular. Game show element to take publicity
by tim333 2y ago
I liked James Carville's idea of picking maybe eight contenders and having town hall type events to choose the most popular. Game show element to take publicity from Trump and also kind of democratic rather than anointing a connected insider, which of course Trump would then go on about endlessly.
- jjtheblunt 2y agodemocratic is the famous intended design, over promotion of insiders, right? seems like a great idea from Carville.
- shadowgovt 2y agoNot really, no. At least not in the US. The tension in the US system is between founders who believed in the virtue of the commoner and founders who feared mobocracy. At various levels of the system, the system is designed to be elitist. And the parties are fundamentally private institutions and can be as populist or elitist as they want (worth noting: in practice, the GOP constitution is more populist than the Democrat constitution, which is one of the reasons they nominated Trump; there weren't backstops in the GOP like superdelegates to push him off the ticket).
- keybored 2y agoThe fear of “mob rule” seems to only be about losing power in practice.
- Terr_ 2y ago> backstops [...] like superdelegates The Electoral College is often cited as serving a similar purpose... I think recent events show despite paying the consistent premium it extracts in elitist gatekeeping, when it finally mattered it failed to provide the promised protection against unethical demagogues.
- mattnewton 2y ago1) contested convention after the incumbent steps down 2) republican candidate considered a crook 3) it's in Chicago Whatever they do, don't do what the DNC did in 1968 again, lets try to at least make new mistakes this time I guess?
- PopAlongKid 2y agoWhat mistakes did the DNC make in 1968? Chicago Mayor Daley and his police force made the mistakes with the protestors, much of the media coverage of the police riots falsely made it look like it was happening right outside the convention site.
- mattnewton 2y agoWell, anointing the VP Humphrey as the new candidate, in a process that alienated a lot of the dem's base was a big mistake in retrospect. I won't pretend to know the history well enough to know if there was any workable approach then, but the convention process in 1968 definitely didn't work to produce a candidate Dems were excited about at the end of it, the turnout was low and Humphrey lost in a landslide. Also, I think some of it was happening right outside the convention site - Dan Rather was famously manhandled on national television by security guards while trying to interview someone leaving the convention.
- dylan604 2y agoI keep imaging being in a Sorkin-esque West Wing timeline
- ScottBurson 2y agoNot a bad idea, but it remains to be seen how many people are up for starting a run at this late date. Also, I just read that Harris has money pouring in. The donors may effectively decide this before anyone else can get traction.
- kagakuninja 2y agoAnything a washed up hack like Carville suggests should be viewed with suspicion. At this point, it has to be Harris. She is also the only person who can use the money from Joe Biden's campaign fund.