5 ms·
Am I the only one that thinks "Ugh, not making money yet"? Yes yes, I know about burning cash (err, growing) as fast as possible to lock down winner-take-all m
by stickfigure 14y ago
Am I the only one that thinks "Ugh, not making money yet"?
Yes yes, I know about burning cash (err, growing) as fast as possible to lock down winner-take-all markets, but travel booking doesn't seem like one of those. There doesn't seem to be any switching cost other than typing a different url in the browser. I don't see any network effects. Am I missing something?
This is a business with revenue streams and cash flow. They've been around for two years. They've already raised more than $5mm. When I hear "we raised another venture round" my gut reaction is concern, not congratulations.
As far as the product goes: The UX is nice. But every time I tried hipmonk, the prices were higher than what I found elsewhere, so I stopped using it.
- patrickaljord 14y ago> But every time I tried hipmonk, the prices were higher than what I found elsewhere, so I stopped using it. Same here, love the UX but when I first tried it a couple of years ago, prices were higher. I tried it again only a couple of weeks ago and prices were still much higher. It looks like hipmunk is an engineer driven company focused on technical stuff (great UX, no ads) but what's important here is getting the best deals with flights providers and they're still not there yet, even two years after the launch.
- veyron 14y agoThe problem is twofold: 1) for customers price is more important than UX 2) price is a relationship, not discovery, game You can't get access to the really deep deals without relationships, and if you are not the primary you have to undercut competition. IMHO the best play is to build the UX and then flip it to a company like Kayak.
- suking 14y agoKayak could copy this UX in a day if they wanted. I don't think even $15mm (even if it was all spent on marketing) is going to see much of an uptick for hipmunk. I bet priceline, kayak, etc. spend close to that a month.
- tedivm 14y agoAre they actually higher though? I found the same thing you did, except when I tried checking out of the other places I found they would place fees on top of things. Turns out Hipmonk just adds those fees in from the start. In my experience they end up coming out the same.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ketralnis 14y ago> every time I tried hipmonk, the prices were higher than what I found elsewhere Can you be more specific? We (Hipmunk) get our data from the same places that most everyone does, fares aren't really something that's variable from site-to-site (Southwest aside) The only thing I can think of is that we list fares after taxes and fees, and many other sites list fares before them
- didip 14y agoYou have many different types of customers, don't worry... I booked last minute flight to SFO 2 days before Fluent Conf through Hipmunk. I was glad to get the perfect flight schedule and the whole experience took less than 15 minutes. Loved the UI, didn't matter even if I ended up paying more.
- mikeryan 14y agoI think I'm in the minority but I can't stand Hipmunk's UI. With Kayak I just put in when I'm going, time of day I want to leave and hit the nonstop button. Then I get a nice ordered list by price boom done. Maybe I'm spoiled I live near two major airports (Oakland and SFO) and tend to travel to large cities. But I've not found hipmunk's UI innovation to be anything but excess nonsense I don't need.
- joshwa 14y agoYou're right that the hipmunk UI may be overkill for your use-case of simple point-to-point flights, but I wonder how much of the market that represents? That said, reducing the complexity of the UI for that usecase might be a way to increase adoption. NB I do a lot of complicated travel, and hipmunk found me a fare that saved me $1800! I use ITA matrix, KVSTool, etc, and oddly enough it didn't show up there.
- potatolicious 14y agoI'm the opposite, I absolutely despise Kayak's UI and how it explodes for anything but the simplest itineraries (and even then it's a pain). For one thing, Kayak doesn't let you pick your departure and return legs separately, and instead displays every possible permutation of flights that fit your search criteria. I remember seeing over a thousand "results" for SFO-JFK. How a user is expected to make a decision there... your guess is as good as mine. The number of "results" explode even further for any flight with possible connections. Also, the arbitrary filters that one needs to chop the result set down to something mentally digestible are also highly flawed. When I fly is important to me, but if I say, restrict the results to "departs before 11am", it will filter out something that leaves at 11:05am. The more "analog" view of Hipmunk is greatly preferable. All that said, I'm cautiously hopeful for Hipmunk. I love their UX, but building a business around something that has infamously low margins (like, incredibly, razor thin margins) seems like a questionable strategy. I can see why Hipmunk has expanded into hotel bookings (though IMO it's not very good), but one has to wonder about the viability of its core product.
- LokiSnake 14y agoAre you sure? I originally thought the same thing but Hipmunk simply includes all the taxes and fees in the price they display, so it almost always ends up the same for me when checking out.