6 ms·
Intelligence is overrated as a metric, from the get-go. Being smart doesn't mean anything - accomplishing something, whether that be writing a book, founding a
by keiferski 14y ago
Intelligence is overrated as a metric, from the get-go. Being smart doesn't mean anything - accomplishing something, whether that be writing a book, founding a company, making a new scientific discovery, sculpting a masterpiece, etc., is a much better metric.
Unfortunately everyone seems to be hung up on the "idea" of being smart, as if having a high IQ somehow constitutes an accomplishment.
- beersigns 14y agoI'm on the same page. IQ is property of the genetic dice roll, not something that a person earns. Tangible results based measurements seem more appropriate. Pure intellect is the raw material & needs to be refined/applied to be useful. edit: grammar
- upquark 14y agoThe rest of your personality traits that allow you to accomplish great things (diligence, perseverance, focus, empathy, etc), as well as external factors such as being born at the right place and the right time, are also arguably a genetic / environmental dice roll.
- beersigns 14y agoI'd argue all of those areas you list are far more likely to be improved over the course of a lifetime than sheer intelligence. Pure intellect is pretty much set at birth, or at the least the ability to improve it isn't statistically significant. I'd argue that genetic dice roll and environmental dice roll are quite different things as well. You have FAR more ability to change your environmental situation than your genetic one. Does everyone have an equal chance to alter their environment? No, but who said life is fair?
- rstevenson542 14y agoThe human brain has enormous capacity to develop in a wide variety of areas. Most of these areas are not measured in tests like the IQ tests. IQ tests mainly measure those brain functions we find beneficial in modern western society. IQ tests, SATs, ACTs and other standardized test like them are improperly named. They should be called "Tests That Predict Success or Failure in the School System From Which the Questions Have Been Derived."
- RobAtticus 14y agoSAT originally stood for Scholastic Aptitude Test...so it seems properly named, even by your own standards. Similarly, ACT stands for American College Testing which doesn't have anything to do with intelligence. You seem to have a pretty serious ax to grind with standardized testing.
- rstevenson542 14y agoThe SAT was created in 1928 with the intentions of measuring a student's aptitude. meaning that the test measured an innate ability, rather than knowledge acquired through schooling. Today, the test administered by the College Board is still called SAT, but the name is just an acronym, with the letters no longer standing for anything. According to the College Board, the SAT now does not measure any innate ability. the SAT and ACT simply provides a common yardstick for comparing grades at different high schools. Educators use them as way to judge an A at this school or this teacher versus an A at this school or this teacher. Nothing more. At best the SAT is said to predict freshman year grades in college (somewhat).
- RobAtticus 14y agoI'm not debating what they do or where their name comes from. You suggested they needed to be renamed (presumably because they imply they test intelligence). They are (or were) named appropriately.
- cheatercheater 14y agoIf I'm born into a millionaire family, I have more purchasing power than someone born into a poor family in Ukraine. This is a result of the genetic dice roll. Following your logic, does this mean Armani should start pricing their clothes adjusting for parental affluence and/or by how many rungs of the social ladder a person has climbed in their life?
- beersigns 14y agoThat is the result of a environmental/social dice roll. Not even close to the same thing.
- keithpeter 14y agoI think there is a 'situational intelligence' or a set of schemas you develop for dealing with things within a certain activity; e.g. an old school photographer may not need to use a light meter at all to get well exposed negatives; a Unix administrator will know where to look when a system starts to behave oddly; a nursery nurse will know when a child needs attention and when they can be left. I wonder what the results would look like if you wrote 'bias check questions' within a knowledge domain and some outside the domain and compared the scores of a group of practitioners and a group of non-practitioners, sort of a four way table.
- roguecoder 14y agoIt does mean something. Specifically it means you learn differently than other people, because you store and process information differently. It is neither accurate to be expected to function the same as other people nor to expect other people to function the same way you do if you are a significant outlier. Particularly during schooling it can be lonely, isolating and incredibly boring. It is easy, under those circumstances, to either build yourself up as better than people around you or come to hate and hide your intelligence so you can pass as one of them. Both are a loss to society. It is not an accomplishment, any more than having diabetes is an accomplishment, but it is a fact of life and trying to pretend it doesn't matter is futile.
- keiferski 14y agoThe point I was trying to make was that intelligence itself is a bad goal - it's a means to an end. Being smart makes things easier, sure, but it's not really something to be proud of by itself. 'Metric' was probably a bad word choice.
- Produce 14y agoNo idea why you're being downvoted for your opinion. For the record, I agree - intelligence is vastly overrated. I've been called intelligent my whole life yet there are people who are apparently dumber than me who have achieved a lot more. Intelligence as an end is nothing more than mental masturbation.
- 3pt14159 14y agoThen why does it correlate so high with income, even after being adjusted by the economic background of the measured person's parents?
- cheatercheater 14y agoSays tau/2.
- 3pt14159 14y agohttp://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2323884 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2323884 :)
- cheatercheater 14y agoLoved it, A+++++++++ would read again.
- pessimizer 14y agoProbably because the thing it correlates the most with is reading for pleasure, and that's easily done in a household that could afford lots of extracurricular books. The myth that IQ tests measure any tangible internal capacity (or that they were even designed to do so rather than to justify the exclusion of eastern european immigrants and racism against blacks) will stay as the dominant view because the people who set the dominant view are people who get good scores on IQ tests.
- 3pt14159 14y ago> and that's easily done in a household that could afford lots of extracurricular books. But that is already adjusted for. IQ tests highly correlate to a number of factors. More likely to read, less likely to get divorced, more likely to go to university, more likely to eat healthily, etc. But at the end of the day, when you keep trying to control for each of these factors you end up at the null hypothesis simply because there is nothing left to measure. Just because something is politically incorrect doesn't mean it is wrong.