4 ms·

The older “cross compiling Go with Zig” post might give a good start if you want to figure it out

by zellyn 2y ago

brabel 2y ago
I had a look at the post. It only shows how to tell the Go compiler how to use Zig as the C Compiler. In our case, what we need is to tell Zig to link the object files created by D. I've had a look and saw that Zig is still implementing the `ld` command, but there's already a `ld.ldd` command which might work if you know what magical options to use. I've tried to link my D object file but it can't find a whole lot of generated symbols, and a quick search online does not tell me where do I get those symbols from. That's always what happens when I try to do stuff with D that's not well documented. I tried this (used the dmd -v option to get the linker command): zig ld.lld -L/Users/me/dlang/dmd-2.109.1/osx/bin/../lib app.o Output: ``` ld.lld: error: undefined symbol: _d_assert_msg >>> referenced by myd/source/app.d >>> app.o:(_D4core8internal5newaa__T6makeAATAyaTiZQoFNaNeHQoiZSQByQBwQBq7AAShell) >>> referenced by myd/source/app.d >>> app.o:(_D3std6format5write__T14formattedWriteTSQBm5stdio4File17LockingTextWriterTaTS3app__T9StringMapTiZQnZQDaFNfKQCqMxAaQBmZk) >>> referenced by myd/source/app.d >>> app.o:(_D3std6format5write__T14formattedWriteTSQBm5stdio4File17LockingTextWriterTaTS3app__T9StringMapTiZQnZQDaFNfKQCqMxAaQBmZk) >>> referenced 27 more times ld.lld: error: undefined symbol: _aaLen >>> referenced by myd/source/app.d >>> app.o:(_D4core8internal5newaa__T6makeAATAyaTiZQoFNaNeHQoiZSQByQBwQBq7AAShell) >>> referenced by myd/source/app.d >>> app.o:(_D3std6format8internal5write__T15formatValueImplTSQBw5stdio4File17LockingTextWriterTHiHAyaiTaZQClFNfKQCaQuMKxSQEeQEd4spec__T10FormatSpecTaZQpZv) >>> referenced by myd/source/app.d >>> app.o:(_D3std6format8internal5write__T15formatValueImplTSQBw5stdio4File17LockingTextWriterTHAyaiTaZQCjFNfKQByQsMKxSQEcQEb4spec__T10FormatSpecTaZQpZv) ld.lld: error: too many errors emitted, stopping now (use --error-limit=0 to see all errors) ``` Do you know how to get past that?
- WalterBright 2y ago
  Looks like the D runtime library isn't being linked in.
- zellyn 2y ago
  I have to confess to mostly just lurking Zig with interest, but not _actually_ knowing what I'm talking about. I do know their linker game has improved a _lot_ since that old Go article, so it's quite likely that Zig can do what you want. You might want to try their IRC or Discord.

The older “cross compiling Go with Zig” post might give a good start if you want to figure it out

by zellyn 2y ago

The older “cross compiling Go with Zig” post might give a good start if you want to figure it out

I had a look at the post. It only shows how to tell the Go compiler how to use Zig as the C Compiler. In our case, what we need is to tell Zig to link the object files created by D. I've had a look and saw that Zig is still implementing the `ld` command, but there's already a `ld.ldd` command which might work if you know what magical options to use. I've tried to link my D object file but it can't find a whole lot of generated symbols, and a quick search online does not tell me where do I get those symbols from. That's always what happens when I try to do stuff with D that's not well documented. I tried this (used the dmd -v option to get the linker command): zig ld.lld -L/Users/me/dlang/dmd-2.109.1/osx/bin/../lib app.o Output: ``` ld.lld: error: undefined symbol: _d_assert_msg >>> referenced by myd/source/app.d >>> app.o:(_D4core8internal5newaa__T6makeAATAyaTiZQoFNaNeHQoiZSQByQBwQBq7AAShell) >>> referenced by myd/source/app.d >>> app.o:(_D3std6format5write__T14formattedWriteTSQBm5stdio4File17LockingTextWriterTaTS3app__T9StringMapTiZQnZQDaFNfKQCqMxAaQBmZk) >>> referenced by myd/source/app.d >>> app.o:(_D3std6format5write__T14formattedWriteTSQBm5stdio4File17LockingTextWriterTaTS3app__T9StringMapTiZQnZQDaFNfKQCqMxAaQBmZk) >>> referenced 27 more times ld.lld: error: undefined symbol: _aaLen >>> referenced by myd/source/app.d >>> app.o:(_D4core8internal5newaa__T6makeAATAyaTiZQoFNaNeHQoiZSQByQBwQBq7AAShell) >>> referenced by myd/source/app.d >>> app.o:(_D3std6format8internal5write__T15formatValueImplTSQBw5stdio4File17LockingTextWriterTHiHAyaiTaZQClFNfKQCaQuMKxSQEeQEd4spec__T10FormatSpecTaZQpZv) >>> referenced by myd/source/app.d >>> app.o:(_D3std6format8internal5write__T15formatValueImplTSQBw5stdio4File17LockingTextWriterTHAyaiTaZQCjFNfKQByQsMKxSQEcQEb4spec__T10FormatSpecTaZQpZv) ld.lld: error: too many errors emitted, stopping now (use --error-limit=0 to see all errors) ``` Do you know how to get past that?

WalterBright 2y ago
Looks like the D runtime library isn't being linked in.
zellyn 2y ago
I have to confess to mostly just lurking Zig with interest, but not _actually_ knowing what I'm talking about. I do know their linker game has improved a _lot_ since that old Go article, so it's quite likely that Zig can do what you want. You might want to try their IRC or Discord.