5 ms·
There are many beach cleaning machines. A medium-sized robotic one.[1] A large one that Virginia Beach uses to clean up after spring break.[2] As with agricultu
by Animats 2y ago
There are many beach cleaning machines. A medium-sized robotic one.[1] A large one that Virginia Beach uses to clean up after spring break.[2] As with agricultural equipment, self-contained robots tend to lose out to wide implements towed behind tractors.
Nobody vacuums sand to clean it. Sand is scooped up, screened, and returned to the ground.
[1] https://searial-cleaners.com/bebot/ https://searial-cleaners.com/bebot/
[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z8yaGaCGqeM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z8yaGaCGqeM
- BSDobelix 2y agoHey but that highly efficient thing in your links has no legs...not cool *irony off Sometimes I really think these inventors are just being stupid for the sake of being cool.
- Animats 2y agoUm. It's certainly not removing much stuff. Here's a video of a wide variety of beach cleaning machines.[1] Some of those have big messes to clean up, with rocks, seaweed, and storm debris. Dump trucks are sent out to service the larger beach cleaners, like a harvesting operation. If you need beach cleaning machines, it's usually because you have a lot of stuff to remove. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nll28HBeAg8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nll28HBeAg8
- BSDobelix 2y ago>Um. It's certainly not removing much stuff. I was talking that many machines...sorry robots don't need legs and your links show that. To make a legged robot that can "suck" one piece (specialized in Cigarette butts) with it's legs is incredible stupid.
- hansvm 2y ago> tractors + wide implements vs robots In theory there exists a crossover point, right? Tractors scale somewhere like O(x^2) to O(x^3) in costs as the implements get wider by a factor of x, depending on exact design decisions, and swarms of robots scale out somewhere like O(x). Tractors have been getting bigger (trying to get more work done for the same amount of human labor), and if that trend continues you'd expect some sort of smaller, swarm solution to be viable (be it on the larger end, small automated tractors, or smaller still where you can take advantage of local sensors and automate something like weeding instead of paying for herbicides and that particular flavor of special seeds).
- hedora 2y agoThe optimal size for tractors is more a function of the topology of the land and the soil type than $/acre spent on the equipment. In theory, the minimum feasible unit of equipment should be a lot smaller for sand than dirt (less weight is required to break up the sand), and beaches tend to be curved and bumpy, so that favors a swarm of small robots. However, the cost of maintaining the swarm is linear in swarm size, but the cost of maintaining one tractor is sublinear in tractor size. I'd guess it's roughly as difficult (within a factor of 2-10x) to unclog up the sand sifter on a beach combing tractor as it is to unclog the analogous component on a single swarm robot. At 10x, that suggests a swarm of over ~ ten robots is infeasible (unless they are self-repairing and self-maintaining). The article mentions places where wheeled devices can't reach (stairs, steep beaches). I'm guessing that'll be the main use case for these things. As for precision herbicides + planting, I suspect that's better done with special tractor attachments that have fine grained control over each row's implement. Most stuff is grown in large fields and GPS guided tractors are getting more common.
- Animats 2y agoThere are small beach cleaning machines, down to push-broom sized devices used for cleaning beach volleyball courts. The beaches that need regular cleaning are usually big, heavily used public beaches, where a large machine is effective.
- hansvm 2y agoAs far as I can tell, your position is something like: (1) People only use bigger tractors for worse soil, not to reduce their own human workloads. This caps the natural progression of machine sizes I'm describing, thus stopping things before a size where swarms matter (not refuting a crossover point (kindly consider the O(x^2) or greater vs O(x) cost idea), but suggesting we'll never reach it). (2) The human cost of maintenance dwarfs all other costs, and the status quo of small vs large machines suggests large machines will be cheaper to repair, so a swarm of 1-2 big machines will be much cheaper to repair than 100-200 small machines. (*) some addendum addressing my less important side-benefits Does that sound like a correct characterization?
- 2y ago
- ec109685 2y agoThe video shows this working on stairs and other places that tractors dragging sand wouldn’t be appropriate.