3 ms·
Important subject, so-so article. One decline in democracy: do you belong to any organization where the members regularly vote, make binding decisions, and occ
by Animats 2y ago
Important subject, so-so article.
One decline in democracy: do you belong to any organization where the members regularly vote, make binding decisions, and occasionally fire the leader? A co-op? A union? A club? A homeowner's association? Anything? Most non-profits and voluntary organizations used to be organized that way, but in the US today, they tend to have self-perpetuating boards, ones which choose their successors.
This is a problem for democracy, because Americans don't regularly do democracy any more.
It takes practice. You need to see the process work. If people are not familiar with the process,
it won't get used.
Democracy is a consensus-forcing process. There's argument, then a vote. Then a decision, which is carried out.
The expectation, and this is a tough one, is that after a decision is made, the opposition mostly accepts it,
whether they like it or not. That's tough. Countries currently struggling hard with that include the US, France,
and Israel.
If voting can't force a decision and action, democracy stalls. This leads for calls for a "strong leader" and some form of autocracy. Countries which failed at democratic consensus and ended up as authoritarian states in recent years include post-USSR Russia, and Iraq.
Then you get a coup or conquest, sometimes you get a revolution, and once in a while, a stable democracy emerges.
You have to have people who know how to do democracy to make that work.
- poslathian 2y agoIt seems this muscle has atrophied in nearly every niche it once thrived: neighborhood kids self organizing play, multigenerational households and family run businesses, boarding houses where personal spaces are shared with strangers, participation in civic clubs and churches (which was as much about business networking and social prestige as anything but still organized collective effort to worthy causes), self organized physical markets (like the grove in LA in the 30s), chambers of commerce, local business (cartels) parceling up their markets, barn raising, “culture scenes” like the west village in the 60s… perhaps most saliently to me personally, the end of faculty led university management.