3 ms·
> We do not incentivize companies to operate secure, redundant, reliable computer systems. Except in the gambling industry. As part of a long-standing traditio
by Animats 2y ago
> We do not incentivize companies to operate secure, redundant, reliable computer systems.
Except in the gambling industry. As part of a long-standing tradition, companies in the gambling industry are usually contractually required to take financial responsibility for errors.
GTECH's annual report, before they were acquired by an Italian company, says "We paid or incurred liquidated damages with respect to our contracts in an amount equal to 0.61%, 0.18%, 0.50%, 0.47% and 0.14% of our annual revenues in fiscal 2006, 2005, 2004, 2003 and 2002, respectively."[1]
So, forcing a transaction process service to take full responsibility for errors cost, at worst, 0.61% of revenue. This is sufficient to force gambling companies to use unusually good security technologies.
The Nevada Gambling Commission has technical rules.[2]
* "On-line slot systems may only communicate with equipment or programs external to the system
through a secure interface. This interface will specifically not allow any external connection to directly access the alterable data of the system." Which means no privileged "security" systems such as Crowdstrike.
* "Gaming device application
access to the system based game must be logged automatically on the system component of the
game and on a computer or other logging device that resides outside the secure area and is not
accessible to the individual(s) accessing the secure area." Which means the really important info must not only be logged, the logs have to be kept where the people who run the systems can't get at them. There are more logging requirements. Most things require two logs, one used for normal operation and a remote backup with tamper resistance and secure hashes.
* "Conditions for changing active software on a conventional gaming device or client
station that is part of a system supported or system based game:
(a) Be in the idle mode with no errors or tilts, no play and no credits on the machine for at least
two (2) minutes;
(b) Not be participating in an in-house or inter-casino linked payoff schedule..." There's more, but the general idea is that to change anything, you have to take the component being changed down to the idle, fully backed up state. Only then can changes be applied. All of which are logged.
The gaming industry has faced hostile actors for decades. They have reasonably strong defenses. Yet they're still very profitable.
[1] https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/857323/000095012306004899/y19841e10vk.htm#103 https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/857323/0000950123060...
[2] https://gaming.nv.gov/uploadedFiles/gamingnvgov/content/Home/Features/TechnicalStandard3.pdf https://gaming.nv.gov/uploadedFiles/gamingnvgov/content/Home...