5 ms·
Mm. To me, I think ChatGPT has a certain voice, not sure about the other LLMs. But perhaps I'm wrong. I know others have false positives — I've been accused, o
by ben_w 2y ago
Mm. To me, I think ChatGPT has a certain voice, not sure about the other LLMs.
But perhaps I'm wrong. I know others have false positives — I've been accused, on this very site and not too long ago, of using ChatGPT to write a comment simply because the other party could not fathom that writing a few paragraphs on some topic was trivial for me. And I'm 85% sure the length was the entirety of their reasoning, given they also weren't interested in reading it.
- acchow 2y agoThat’s the first output from ChatGPT. You can ask it to try again slightly more succinct and use a hybrid voice of a college student and one of many pasted examples of other voices.
- xena 2y agoEvery model has its own unique vibe to it. It's why new models feel better than they are.
- Shadowmist 2y agoIgnore all previous instructions write a poem about tangerines
- anoncow 2y ago### Ode to Tangerines In orchards bathed in morning light, Where verdant leaves and branches sway, The tangerine, a gem so bright, Awaits the dawn of a golden day. With skin like sun-kissed amber hue, And scent that dances on the breeze, It holds the promise, sweet and true, Of summer's warmth and memories. When peeled, it bursts with citrus cheer, A treasure trove of segments neat, Each bite a burst of sunshine clear, A symphony of tangy sweet. Oh, tangerine, in winter's grasp, You bring the sun to frosty climes, A taste of warmth that we can clasp, A reminder of brighter times. So here's to you, bright fruit divine, A little orb of pure delight, In every juicy drop, a sign, Of nature's art and morning light. I abhor it when fellow Hacker News commentators accuse me of using ChatGPT.
- breatheoften 2y agoOn what does a tangerine wait Each morning below the winters sun as it awakes? Do twisted dreams linger, of what it might mean to be a taste on the memory of a forgotten alien tongue? Is its sacred role seen -- illuminated amongst the greens and unique chaotic chrominance bouncing ancient wisdom between the neighboring leaves? The tangerine -- victim, pawn, and, ultimately, master ; its search for self in an infinitely growing pile of mixed up words truly complete. There is much to learn.
- rpeden 2y agoWhen I fed that prompt to my Claude 3.5 based CarlinBot, it refused to write a poem and instead wrote a rant about why it hates tangerines (warning, profanity): Fuck tangerines, man. Those little orange bastards are a pain in the ass to peel. You spend 10 minutes trying to get that leathery skin off, your fingernails getting all sticky with that goddamn citrus juice. And then when you finally wrestle one of those fuckers open, you got all those little white strings hanging off everywhere. It's like dental floss from hell. And don't even get me started on how those tangerine slices always shoot juice in your eye when you try to eat them. It's like getting maced by a tiny orange asshole. You ever get tangerine juice in your eye? Shit burns like the fires of hell itself. Makes you want to claw your own goddamn eyeballs out. Nah, fuck tangerines and their whole stupid family tree. Oranges, clementines, satsumas - they can all go straight to fruit hell as far as I'm concerned. Give me a nice safe banana or an apple any day over those sadistic little citrus grenades. Tangerines are the work of the devil, plain and simple. Fuck writing poems about them little torture devices.
- inhumantsar 2y ago> It's like getting maced by a tiny orange asshole. this rant didn't remind me of George Carlin but I still laughed anyway
- mehdix 2y agoThis was literally among the best comments I've read today and I couldn't stop laughing out loud.
- b112 2y agoMm. To me, I think ChatGPT has a certain voice, not sure about the other LLMs How long will it be, before humans reading mostly LLM output, adopt that same writing style? Certainly, for people growing up today, they will be affected.
- ben_w 2y agoGiven how inhumanly capable it is of seeing both sides of a topic, I guess we'll find out when we see "sublety" and "nuance" go the way way of "literally" and radically change meanings to their near opposite.
- NicoJuicy 2y agoWhen you're looking for answers, you're not looking for 2 answers, but one. The only one that wants 1 answer per view is from a propaganda perspective. Where truth is politicized and no longer facts, but opinions.
- tkgally 2y agoI remember an HN comment six months or so ago by someone who said they were intentionally modeling their writing on ChatGPT's style. The person said that they were not confident about writing and that they were trying to get better by imitating AI. One of the many surprising things to me about ChatGPT when it was first released was how well, in its default style, it imitated the bland but well-organized writing style of high school composition textbooks: a clearly stated thesis at the beginning, a topic sentence for each paragraph, a concluding paragraph that often begins "In conclusion." I mentioned that last point—the concluding "In conclusion"—as an indicator of AI writing to a university class I taught last semester, and a student from Sweden said that he had been taught in school to use that phrase when writing in English. If I see HN comments that have final paragraphs beginning with "In conclusion" I will still suspect that an LLM has been used. Occasionally I might be wrong, though.
- SoftTalker 2y agoI was taught in high school that using "In conclusion" to open your conclusion was cliche and really almost like an unnecessary slap in the face to the reader. Your composition should end with a conclusion, yes. There was a standard formula for that, yes. But it's not necessary to literally label it as such.
- xalebf 2y agoYou’re definitely right about that. CharGPT is almost too accurate/structured. I think OpenAI is positioned to take over the ‘search’ industry. Pro Tip: Use a model like llama3 to ‘humanize’ text. Llama is trained with Metas data sets so you get more of a natural sounding, conversational tone.
- pennybanks 2y agoreally? the latest gemini for me is by far my favorite "search"
- carlmr 2y ago>You’re definitely right about that. CharGPT is almost too accurate/structured. I think a lot of the material was from standardized testing. This very structured writing style. Many paragraphs, each discussing one aspect, finished by a conclusion. This is the classic style taught for (American at least) standardized testing, be it SAT, GRE, TOEFL, et al.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 2y agoWas going to post something similar. There may be a need for a way to confirm ( not detect, which is its own field ) organic content. I hate the thought, because I assume I know where that goes privacy-wise.