4 ms·
this seems like the second or third test file any qa person would have tried, after an empty file and maybe a minimal valid file. the level of pervasive incomp
by kragen 2y ago
this seems like the second or third test file any qa person would have tried, after an empty file and maybe a minimal valid file. the level of pervasive incompetence implied here is staggering
in a market where companies compete by impressing nontechnical upper management with presentations, it should be no surprise that technically competent companies have no advantage over incompetent ones
i recently read through the craig wright decision https://www.judiciary.uk/judgments/copa-v-wright/ https://www.judiciary.uk/judgments/copa-v-wright/ (the guy who fraudulently claimed to be satoshi nakamoto) and he lacked even the most basic technical competence in the fields where he was supposedly a world-class specialist (decompiling malware to c); he didn't know what 'unsigned' meant when questioned on the witness stand. he'd been doing infosec work for big companies going back to the 90s. he'd apparently been tricking people with technobabble and rigged demos and forged documents for his entire career
george kurtz, ceo and founder of crowdstrike, was the cto of mcafee when they did the exact same thing 14 years ago: https://old.reddit.com/r/sysadmin/comments/1e78l0g/can_crowdstrike_survive_this_impact/ldz4n6h/?share_id=rafKW0OThY1VGL08GtbWb https://old.reddit.com/r/sysadmin/comments/1e78l0g/can_crowd... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Kurtz https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Kurtz
crowdstrike itself caused the same problem on debian stable three months ago: https://old.reddit.com/r/debian/comments/1c8db7l/linuximage61020_killed_all_my_debian_vms/ https://old.reddit.com/r/debian/comments/1c8db7l/linuximage6...
it's horrifying that pci compliance regulations have injected crowdstrike (and antivirus) into virtually every aspect of today's it infrastructure
- GardenLetter27 2y agoAlso ironic that the compliance ended up introducing the biggest vulnerability as a massive single point of failure. But that's government regulation for you.
- kragen 2y agopci-dss is not a government agency but it might as well be; it's a collusion between visa, mastercard, american express, discover, and jcb to prevent them from having different data security standards (and therefore being able to compete on security)
- derefr 2y agoYou mean “and therefore requiring businesses that take credit cards to enforce the union of all the restrictions imposed by all six companies (which might not even be possible—the restrictions might be contradictory) in order to accept all six types of cards”
- kragen 2y agoyou could imagine that if visa and mastercard had incompatible restrictions, such that merchants had to choose which one to accept, people would gradually shift to the card that got their money stolen less often, or whose (merchants') websites worked more reliably since, instead, every business that uses credit cards at all is required to use the same set of counterproductive 'security' policies that make them more vulnerable than before, there is no way for market reality to ground these 'security' policies in real-world security. that's exactly the same problem that happens with government regulation
- jfyi 2y agoI've seen several merchants stop using amex because of restrictions. Admittedly those restrictions were very much in the form of excessive fees and nobody would have cared about their customer's stolen money. Anyway, there isn't total solidarity within the credit card cartel.
- derefr 2y agoThe thing is that even today, where it's "easy", still nearly nobody is writing code to directly support the six different credit card types. Instead, businesses mostly rely on payment processors. In a world where it's impossible to support all six card types directly with one codebase, one of the key dimensions on which payment processors would compete for mindshare, would be abstracting away those difficulties in supporting all six card types, enabling the business that uses them to accept more cards, more easily, than if the business went with some rival payment-processor. This would be a headline feature, however hard it is for them to accomplish internally. The only difference from today, would be that now, due to those potentially-conflicting requirements, the payment processors would have to build six entirely-distinct payment backends that don't share a data model. (Basically treating each credit card platform's cards as different "payment rails", as distinctive from one-another as credit card payment rails today are from debit card payment rails.) And then, of course, the payment processors themselves would come up with guidelines for handling those six different data warehouses and associated infrastructure, separate/downstream from the guidelines enforced upon each data warehouse by the associated credit platform... and those payment-processor-produced guidelines, might look again quite a lot like PCI-DSS :P
- acdha 2y ago> But that's government regulation for you. You misspelled “private sector”. Use of endpoint monitoring software is coming out of private auditing companies driven by things like PCI or insurers’ requirements – almost nobody wants to pay for highly-skilled security people so they’re outsourcing it to the big auditing companies and checklists so that if they get sued they can say they were following industry practices and the audit firms okayed it.
- babypuncher 2y agothis had nothing to do with government regulation, thank private sector insurance companies.
- czbond 2y agoPci-dss is a method for card companies to allay the risk onto the merchant and away from the card companies - just like insurance.
- moandcompany 2y agoIt's definitely ironic, and compatible with the security engineering world joke that the most secure system is one that cannot be accessed or used at all. I suppose one way to "stop breaches" is to shut down every host entirely. In the military world, there is a concept of an "Alpha Strike" which generally relates to a fast-enough and strong-enough first-strike that is sufficient to disable the adversary's ability to respond or fight back (e.g. taking down an entire fleet at once). Perhaps people that have been burned by this event will start calling it a Crowdstrike.
- phatfish 2y agoIt seems government IT systems in general faired pretty well the last 12 hrs, but loads of large private companies were effectively taken offline, so there's that.
- bandyaboot 2y agoWhat’s frustrating is that after falsely attributing pci to government regulation and being corrected, you’re probably not going to re-examine the thought process that led you to that false belief.
- worstspotgain 2y agoI don't mean to sound conspiratorial, but it's a little early to rule out malfeasance just because of Hanlon's Razor just yet. Most fuckups are not on a ridonkulous global scale. This is looking like the biggest one to date, the Y2K that wasn't.
- martin-t 2y agoWe as a society need to start punishing incompetence the same way we punish malice. Of course, we also need to first start punishing individuals for intentionally causing harm through their decisions even if the harm was caused indirectly through other people. Power allows people to distance themselves from the act. Distance should not affect the punishment.
- worik 2y ago> We as a society need to start punishing incompetence the same way we punish malice. Yes But competence is marketed The trade names like "Crowdstrike" and "Microsoft "
- yourapostasy 2y ago> Of course, we also need to first start punishing individuals for intentionally causing harm through their decisions even if the harm was caused indirectly through other people. Legal teams are way ahead of you here, by design. They’ve learned to factor out responsibility in such a diffuse manner the “indirectly” term loses nearly all its power the closer one gets to executive ranks and is a fig leaf when you reach C-levels and BoD levels. We couldn’t feasibly operate behemoth corporations otherwise in litigious environments. I personally suspect we cannot enshrine earnestness and character as metrics and KPI’s, even indirectly. From personal experience selling into many client organizations and being able to watch them make some sausage, this is where leadership over managing becomes a key distinction, and organizational culture over a long period measured in generations of decisions and actions implemented by a group with mean workforce tenure measured in decades becomes one of the few reliable signals. Would love to hear others’ experiences and observations.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- chuckadams 2y agoSo which individual engineer are you locking up and telling their kids that they don't get to see their mommy or daddy again? > intentionally causing harm Maybe we need to criminalize groundless accusations too.
- worik 2y ago> george kurtz, ceo and founder of crowdstrike, was the cto of mcafee when they did the exact same thing 14 years ago: https://old.reddit.com/r/sysadmin/comments/1e78l0g/can_crowd https://old.reddit.com/r/sysadmin/comments/1e78l0g/can_crowd... I find it amusing that the people commenting on that link are offended this called a "Microsoft " outage, when it is "Crowdstrike's fault". This is just as much a Microsoft failure. This is even more, another industry failure How many times does this have to happen before we get some industry reform that lets us do our jobs and build the secure reliable systems we have spent seven decades researching? 1988 all over again again again
- TeMPOraL 2y agoIt's simple: the failure is not specific to the OS. Crowdstrike runs on MacOS and Linux workstations too. And it's just as dangerous there; the big thread has stories of Crowdstrike breaking Linux systems in the past months. Crowdstrike isn't needed by/for Windows, it's mandated by corporate and government bureaucracies, where it serves as a tool of employee control and a compliance checkbox to check. That's why it makes no sense to blame Microsoft. If the world run on Linux, ceteris paribus, Crowdstrike would be on those machines too, and would fuck them up just as bad globally.
- BHSPitMonkey 2y ago> That's why it makes no sense to blame Microsoft. If the world run on Linux, ceteris paribus, Crowdstrike would be on those machines too, and would fuck them up just as bad globally. CrowdStrike _is_ running on a massive number of Linux servers/endpoints, with the same kind of auto-update policies.
- machine_coffee 2y ago>Crowdstrike runs on MacOS and Linux workstations too. This is what chills me to the bone, there's loads of these installations worldwide on heterogeneous OSs but with very little oversight of the code. Companies have basically rolled over and stated, 'OK, we trust you' I'm not usually a fan of strident calls to open source everything, but the source code at least for the channel file parser on all OSs should now be made public so that we can have an oversight of what so many have placed their trust in.
- baxtr 2y agoI think the worst part of the incident is that state actors now have a clear blueprint for a large scale infrastructure attack.
- IAmNotACellist 2y agoI can think of a lot better things to put in a kernel-level driver installed on every critical computer ever than a bunch of 0s.
- Guthur 2y agoYou're assuming it wasn't an attack. Just the same week Kaspersky gets kicked from the us market...
- jfyi 2y agoThey are assuming that crowdstrike is telling them the truth, but yeah I keep thinking about Kaspersky too. That's a whole other pile of assumptions though.
- emporas 2y ago> he lacked even the most basic technical competence in the fields where he was supposedly a world-class specialist Pretty ironic Craig also suggests to put digital certificates on the blockchain instead of them issued by a computer or a cluster of computers, in one place, which makes them a target. A peer to peer network is much more resilient to attacks. Was the problem, or a part of the problem, that the root certificate of all computers was replaced by CrowdStrike? I didn't follow that part closely. If it was, then certificates registered on the blockchain might be a solution. I'm totally not an expert in cryptography, but that seems plausible. As a side note, it is only when i heard Craig's Wright explanation of the blockchain that the bitcoin whitepaper started making a lot of sense. He may not be the greatest of coders, but are mathematicians useless in security?
- kragen 2y agonone of your comment makes any sense. possibly it was generated by a large language model with no understanding of what is being talked about
- emporas 2y agois it not the problem, that CrowdStrike takes hold of the root certificate authority of a computer? There is an update, and after that what is causing the problem? If it is the certificate, that could be solved in the future by putting the certificates on the blockchain. If it is just incompetent management, then i don't see a great deal of technical solutions. Craig Wright, claims to be a mathematician not a stellar coder.
- kragen 2y agothat comment does make some sense, but it is still wrong from beginning to end; everything it says is close to the opposite of the truth