6 ms·
If this was indeed developed by NSA, wouldn't this sort of attack be easier for them since NSA gets access to Microsoft's source code for Windows?
by mtgx 14y ago
If this was indeed developed by NSA, wouldn't this sort of attack be easier for them since NSA gets access to Microsoft's source code for Windows?
- Tuna-Fish 14y agoThe access to source code is mostly irrelevant. Access to signing keys is very relevant, and I think there is a very real chance (p>0.2) that the huge oversight MS did with the terminal server keys happened because they were ordered to do it.
- tptacek 14y agoThat's an awfully baroque government backdoor --- a misconfigured X.509 attribute on a certificate that turns out to be signed with a hash for which controlled collisions turn out to be feasible.
- serialx 14y agoNo. The key to this malware being NOT lame is that it uses a new cryptographic attack. Which is, not helped by looking at Microsoft's source code.
- slig 14y agoHow come do they get access to MS code?
- celticninja 14y agoI imagine it goes something like this: US Govt: we want source code access MS: That is propiatory information US Govt: give us access or we wont allow MS products to be used by govt. departments MS: how quick do you want that access?
- jjguy 14y agoRef Microsoft's Shared Source Initiative: http://www.microsoft.com/en-us/sharedsource/default.aspx http://www.microsoft.com/en-us/sharedsource/default.aspx Enterprises w/ 10k+ seats, OEMs, MVPs and governments can get access to Windows source these days. Microsoft launched the program in 2006 or so to dampen the "Linux is more secure because we can see the source!!" FUD.
- dchest 14y agohttp://www.microsoft.com/government/en-gb/initiatives/Pages/government-engagement-programs.aspx http://www.microsoft.com/government/en-gb/initiatives/Pages/... Government Security Program: Addressing the unique security requirements of governments worldwide by helping government actively participate in ensuring the security of their critical systems. We help enhance system security by providing access to Microsoft Windows and Office source code, prescriptive and authoritative security guidance, technical training, security information, and Microsoft security experts.
- parktheredcar 14y agohttps://www.microsoft.com/en-us/sharedsource/default.aspx https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/sharedsource/default.aspx
- einhverfr 14y agoI don't think so. I won't go on record with what I know but I do know that Microsoft has consented to allow governments audit, review, and sometimes even modify their source code. I suspect a polite request (perhaps backed by a threat including the L-word) will get them far further than a virus. Edit: Others have pointed to public documentation of this program. I believe the two cases I was aware of at the time were the governments of China and Germany.
- tptacek 14y agoThe source code to Windows doesn't matter. In 2012, even teenagers find vulnerabilities in Windows by reading the assembly code in IDA Pro. It's one of the most comprehensively reverse-engineered pieces of code on the planet.
- PostOnce 14y agomtgx theorized it would be easier with access to the Windows source, and it would, and you know it would, and you're purposely being obtuse; arguing for the sake of arguing. There is a reason we have programming languages, and we don't all write directly in machine code. Just because it's techincally possible to do things in a more difficult way doesn't mean they would be done that way with a faster, easier option readily available. Stop being silly. :P
- tptacek 14y agoHow well do you understand the Windows Update MITM issue? Take a stab at explaining exactly what part of it would have been easier with Windows source code?
- lmm 14y agoSure, it'd be "easier" in a strictly literal sense. Just as it'd be easier to write these exploits on a system a 60" monitor. The point is there's not a /significant/ difference; understanding code at a high level doesn't really help to attack it (it can make it harder, since the edges that you look for to exploit are precisely those parts you try and abstract away in a higher-level language), and the windows codebase is well-understood with lots of publicly available information describing in, even without the source code.