4 ms·
I don't think it's that strange. Let's compare the cost of the same MacBook Air in the US and France. 1. MacBook Air 11-inch : 64GB in US is $999. 2. MacBook
by jgrahamc 14y ago
I don't think it's that strange. Let's compare the cost of the same MacBook Air in the US and France.
1. MacBook Air 11-inch : 64GB in US is $999.
2. MacBook Air 11-inch : 64GB in France is €1,049
3. $1 = €0.80 at the current time.
So you might think the MacBook Air should be €800 (999 * 0.80). So why it is €249 more? France levies 19.6% TVA (sales tax) on goods and the tax is included in the display price; the US levies sales taxes by state and these are not shown in the displayed prices (sales tax calculated based on destination).
So, what you need to compare is the pre-tax price on both machine. The pre-tax price of the MacBook Air in France is €877. Thus Apple is charging €77 more for the MacBook Air in France than in the US.
The issue is tax rates not Apple.
If you look at the UK you'll find that
4. MacBook Air 11-inch : 64GB is £849
5. $1 = £0.65
So, the £ equivalent of the $999 machine is £650. UK VAT (sales tax) is 20% and thus the pre-tax price of the machine is £707. So Apple is charging £57 more in the UK than in the US.
- davidw 14y ago> US levies sales taxes by state Or, in the cases of Oregon and New Hampshire, does not levy it at at all.
- toyg 14y agoAlthough not as massive as it looks in the first place, there is still a discrepancy. The new MBP-Retina top config is 2799 USD -> 1805 GBP. In the UK store, it's 2299 GBP, less 20% vat -> 1916 GBP. So they're taking more than a 100 quid extra from each UK customer, "just because".
- kolinko 14y agoWell, don't forget our lovely European regulations. The costs of hiring employees and handling business in Europe is higher than in US if I'm not mistaken. Finally, I'd guess that Apple pays its contractors in USD. So if today 1 USD = 0.8 EUR, Apple needs to consider the fact that tomorrow it may be 1 USD = 0.9 EUR, and the price needs to reflect this scenario as well (they cannot change the price every single month to reflect the current USD/EUR conversion ratios). These are details, but add them together, and you'll arrive at that 10% price difference (I guess)
- ralfn 14y agoThe european regulations are cheap compared to the legal risks of operating in the states. So, thats not it. Exchange rate? You keep assuming prices are based on costs. They are not. They are based on profit. So, when the population in a country has more money to spent, or better but, there where the median, rather than the average, income is the highest, the prices will be too. So, its cheap in the US because americans are generally more poor, except for a few that throw the average. Off course, "poor" is a very relative concept in this regard. Income inequality leads to lower prices, and lower margins.
- davidw 14y agoThe data don't really seem to support that view of things: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Median_household_income http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Median_household_income
- jessriedel 14y ago>The european regulations are cheap compared to the legal risks of operating in the states. Cite?
- drone 14y agoAgreed - it seems once a week or so, someone says this on HN, but I don't see any references to a source. It presents an odd, and totally unscientific, conundrum: I see people on HN claiming it's very legally risky to do business in the US, and many of the people I work with and socialize with who are in leadership positions here see doing business in the EU as overly regulated and difficult to make a profit at. I suspect both of them have missed the mark. Largely, I suspect that both groups have built their opinions out of news articles or other fractional views - which tend to focus on the most sensational, rather than the most common. That being said, there are some interesting contrasts to be made, and at least some scholars have indicated a growing convergence between the nature of the two legal systems, at least in some regards.[1] [1] http://www.law.columbia.edu/center_program/legal_theory/papers/spring06?exclusive=filemgr.download&file_id=941783&rtcontentdisposition=filename%3DRAKonati10-30-05.pdf http://www.law.columbia.edu/center_program/legal_theory/pape...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- fulafel 14y agoThe euro is doing really poorly vs the dollar now, it was the same difference when 1 eur got you 1.4-1.5 USD.
- dagw 14y agoThe other thing is that the price they set at launch doesn't change when the exchange rate changes. So Apple doesn't set the price relative to current exchange rates, but relative to whatever rate they're hedging against. So don't look at the current rates, look at the long term futures rates.
- al_james 14y agoYes, its likely the Euro will reduce further against the dollar (given the current situation in Europe), so Apple needs to build in a buffer to account for this.
- danieldk 14y agoMaybe, but did it need to do that since the Euro was introduced? The crazy USD-Euro price differences have persisted since the Euro was introduced. Apple is not the only offender, by the way.
- Isofarro 14y agoApple garnered £6 billion in sales in the UK in 2010, and paid only £10 million in tax. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/mediatechnologyandtelecoms/9193334/Apple-faces-tax-scrutiny-in-the-UK.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/mediatechnol...
- jessriedel 14y agoThat's corporation tax, not VAT. Completely different.
- retube 14y agoI have a feeling there might be some costs associated with revenues of $6bn.
- sycren 14y agoI believe the UK also has better consumer protection laws than the US like being able to return a product within 28 days of purchase to get a full refund. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consumer_protection_in_the_United_Kingdom http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consumer_protection_in_the_Unit...
- rmc 14y agoMost of those laws are European law, that would apply to all EU countries.
- sbuk 14y agoThere are various levies and duties, as well as storage and transportation that will go into the price differential too.
- aristidesfl 14y agoApple products sold in Europe have a base warranty of 2 years. In the US, only 1 year.