7 ms·
SSH has become our universal (Unix) external access protocol
- j_m_b 2y agoSSH port forwarding is one amazing aspect of this software. For one example, you can develop on a remote system by forwarding your local port 3000 to the remote 3000, using something like `ssh -nFL 3000:localhost:3000 user@remote`, all while going through SSH! It's an indispensable tool for modern development.
- bloopernova 2y agoAhh, good times. SSH tunnels and FoxyProxy to run X11 applications on remote servers.
- Sebb767 2y agoYou can also simply use `ssh -X`/`ssh -Y` and use your local X/Xwayland server for the remote app. This way you can start remote GUI apps like local ones from your shell.
- juujian 2y agoHow is the latency on that?
- pxc 2y agoFine if you're on the LAN, but for WAN connections you generally want xpra or NX.
- pizlonator 2y agoSurprisingly good. I was running emacs on a machine in the cloud on the east coast, tunneling to my X server on my laptop on the west coast. No visible keystroke latency. Only noticeable latencies were copy/paste and initial startup but those were only bad enough to be noticeable, not bad enough to annoy me.
- thrillgore 2y agoYou can do all sorts of things with SSH. My favorite is SSHFS, which is couplings for SFTP that treat it like a proper filesystem, and it works on everything that uses SSH. Quicker to setup than a VPN and SMB, and about as secure (you could also theoretically use PAM to authenticate with LDAP or newer MFA protocols)
- rwmj 2y agoqemu lets you boot VMs over ssh: $ qemu-kvm -hda ssh://example.com/var/tmp/fedora-39.img -m 2048 The magic here is done by https://www.libssh.org// https://www.libssh.org// which we also use in https://libguestfs.org/nbdkit-ssh-plugin.1.html https://libguestfs.org/nbdkit-ssh-plugin.1.html
- jacobgkau 2y agoI use SSHFS daily with my NAS on my home network. It's far faster and simpler to administer than SMB or NFS, with way less config overhead and AAA complications than the other two. Unfortunately, it is currently semi-abandonware: https://github.com/libfuse/sshfs/blob/eadf7f104a479f0313ecd4c7371090126261dedd/README.md#development-status https://github.com/libfuse/sshfs/blob/eadf7f104a479f0313ecd4... It works well enough for me, but there are certain issues to be aware of. For example, listening for file changes via inotify doesn't work-- and it's a double-whammy of neither SFTP nor FUSE supporting that, so it's unlikely to be fixed any time soon.
- fbn79 2y agoIf you have SSH access you can use it as door to setup a simple VPN https://github.com/sshuttle/sshuttle https://github.com/sshuttle/sshuttle
- whalesalad 2y agoNeed to get a file from one box to another? Have SSH? `scp` is your friend: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SSH_File_Transfer_Protocol https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SSH_File_Transfer_Protocol scp remote.host:path.txt local scp local remote.host:path Need a fast proxy to browse the internet securely and bypass restrictions without a VPN? SSH SOCKS proxy! Supported by most operating systems, but I tend to use it directly via Firefox so that it is isolated to one browser. This starts a socks proxy on the desired port: ssh -D $port $host Firefox has network settings, simply choose SOCKS, 127.0.0.1 as the IP and the specified port as the port. Then you're off to the races. Until we had proper VPN infrastructure to enter our VPC at AWS I would utilize this to view private vpc-only RMQ dashboards. Love SSH!
- alargemoose 2y agoIf you use container tabs in Firefox, you can also configure proxies on a per-container basis! In case that’s useful to other people besides me.
- knowaveragejoe 2y agoIn case anyone besides me had never heard of this feature: https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/how-use-firefox-containers https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/how-use-firefox-contain...
- Gud 2y agoWow, how come this is not a default feature.
- mikepurvis 2y agoMy company's VPN had some weird quirks with routing and DNS that were preventing me getting to certain web frontends, and being able to do a quick SOCKS proxy to get my Firefox accessing the corp network as if it was doing so from a machine in the office was a lifesaver.
- Retr0id 2y ago
- cm2187 2y agoWhat about an IP whitelist managed on some other website (say in AWS). If you need remote access while you are travelling, you login to that website, which will add your current IP to the whitelist. The server refreshes its firewall with the new whitelist every 5 minutes. So within 5 minutes you get access. That creates another layer of protection (authentication to the website). I would assume a linux firewall is very hard to bypass so almost as good as not exposing the server to the WAN. And doesn't have all the problems and complexity associated with VPNs, works on any device from anywhere.
- themoonisachees 2y agoApart from the complexities added by having to build this in the first place, this works, but requires a desktop environment, which is not true of ssh. You could make the argument that this could be an off-the-shelf product you simply install, but then the default port for it because as big of a target as port 22 as soon as it becomes commonplace enough, except you don't have 20+ years of open-source security research in it, and now you're relying on AWS not being now in your region to connect to your servers.
- cm2187 2y agoAgree but even if you compromise the white list, you still need to get over ssh's own security, so I see that as adding another lock rather than substituting it, and mostly as a protection against someone scanning the IP address space when a new unpatched zero day surfaces. As for the desktop environment, you can add an API to the website.
- rsync 2y agoThere is no reason to bother with any of this when you can just hide behind port knocking.
- cm2187 2y agoI didn't know that existed. Seems like a good alternative, thanks. I prefer the whitelist for my own personal usage as it applies to all my servers/VM in one go for all ports. But agree that's a simpler solution if you have a single port+machine to protect.
- otts_boris 2y agoI don't think that requiring a VPN to use SSH is good advice for big organizations, at least in terms of usability. My uni's (Leeds) comp sci department had this and it was extremely unpleasant to use. While it is "better" from a technical standpoint, I had peers who paid for private compute time instead of using the uni's free clusters. The reality is that even undergraduate comp sci students often don't know enough IT/sysadmin stuff to be able to figure out setting these things up and there's often a benefit to making the barrier to entry lower.
- politelemon 2y agoAn alternative I am seeing mentioned with some frequency is Tailscale, which doesn't need port 22 open to the internet, since it's using its own network's connectivity to facilitate your "tailscale SSH" connectivity. From what I read it's very similar to Amazon's SSM Agent. The usefulness here is that you're closing off ports and reducing your exposure, the downside is that you need proprietary agents installed on the remote devices, and clients (tailscale itself or the SSM extension to AWS CLI) on proprietary networks doing the routing for you. Which might be perfectly fine for your use cases. I've done even less reading but is Cloudflare's WARP client the same thing for their own network?
- iudqnolq 2y agoIt's a proprietary network but not proprietary agents (except the bits specific to proprietary platforms). One handy feature this enabled is that you can include their open source go library in your program and avoid needing to install anything besides your own binary.
- silverquiet 2y agoIsn't there even an open implementation of the network/coordination layer (Headscale)? But regardless, the best term I've heard for these types of networks is overlays. You can add "zero trust" or whatever to make it seem more fashionable, or VPN if you're old school. I remember using Hamachi for this type of use back in maybe the early aughts.
- kayodelycaon 2y agoOne of the major issues was that a VPN client requires additional configuration and software. Connectivity is the least of the problems they are trying to solve.
- acmecorps 2y agoSorry, I'm new to Tailscale, but I do setup and use WireGuard. What does Tailscale offers that WireGuard doesn't if I might ask?
- DolphinAsa 2y agoI've come down to the same conclusion and automating with fabric and paramiko
- deng 2y agoThat's nice and all, but as TFA already mentions, ssh has a large attack surface. The most critical one though is that you usually grant people access to a shell, so if an account gets breached, you need to worry about local root exploits, which are actually pretty common. Also, believe it or not, setting up key-based authentication is quite the challenge for a lot of people, especially if you demand encryption of the private key and setting up an agent. However, you cannot enforce private key encryption server-side, so you can't even guarantee some kind of 2FA is in place. Yes, ssh does nowadays support FIDO, but that's even more complicated for users...
- pxc 2y ago> However, you cannot enforce private key encryption server-side If you could do this, how would it work? If you could use the -sk key types or something similar with devices that are built into most computers (like TPM or the Secure Enclave) that would be nice. > you can't even guarantee some kind of 2FA is in place. Yes, ssh does nowadays support FIDO, but that's even more complicated for users... Can't you limit the allowable keytypes to those FIDO ones (currently ecdsa-sk and ed25519-sk)? There's also the old ChallengeResponseAuthentication stuff.
- pjs_ 2y agoDrives me nuts that somewhere along the devops journey people decided that SSHing into a private server used for internal tools is an antiquated and outrageous thing to expect. People for some reason are actually excited about the prospect -- "we're gonna make it so you never have to SSH!". Little do they know that I like SSH. A lot more than I like clicking on the AWS console. And then somehow we're expected to debug the bastard using logz.io or similar -- unconscionable to me but maybe I'm old
- bluejekyll 2y agoI think the use of IDEs really made this practice less simple. Terminal mode emacs and vi/m are simple with SSH, VSCode and other things start getting more complex. I think the extensions to VSCode and others to run remotely with a browser are starting to bring some of this back into fashion.
- graemep 2y agoonly if you are developing on a remote server which I never do. I do use GUI text editors, file browsers and other tools that work over SSH.
- rad_gruchalski 2y agosome of us have the misfortune of having to use wsl…
- aidos 2y agoUnless something has changed, VSCode runs in a server / client model with the FE on your local machine and the code / language servers running remotely (I don't use it, I stick to neovim).
- wongarsu 2y agoConnecting over SSH with VSCode is the most convenient SSH experience I've ever had: VSCode runs locally, connects via SSH and makes it feel like I'm working locally. I can edit files, open terminals, run software, etc. It's like running vim, a couple terminals and a scp file manager, but with the convenience of a desktop application Technically you need an extension (Remote - SSH) but I think that's installed by default. It runs some remote code on the server to make it more seamless, but that has never gotten in the way.
- sargun 2y agoI wish that SSH would be disaggregated further. SSH has become the suite du jour for file transfer, remote access, and a handful of other things. Unfortunately, simultaneously, innovations have been made in transport protocols and elsewhere in the stack that we're unable to take advantage of. SFTP is a great example of a protocol which has a discrete server (look! There's sftp-server on your computer. Nothing prevents it from running over TLS, or a web socket). I wish that this was the way the entire suite worked. I wish the multiplexing, and underlying shell implementation was transport agnostic (perhaps relying on SOCK_STREAM, or SOCK_SEQPACKET semantics), and the authentication, encryption, etc was its own thing.
- nonrandomstring 2y agoThese are good asks. After xz I worry a little about how many eggs are in the ssh basket.
- fragmede 2y agoxz? regreSSHion should make you lose sleep! https://arstechnica.com/security/2024/07/regresshion-vulnerability-in-openssh-gives-attackers-root-on-linux/ https://arstechnica.com/security/2024/07/regresshion-vulnera...
- nonrandomstring 2y agoGood mention of that one too. The article needed two extra lines, one reminding to use ssh -V and one to remind us to switch off banners.
- syngrog66 2y agoit has been for 20 years IIRC. its designed to be a general purpose way to do remote access and command exec, with auth/auth. like thats its whole ballgame. I think the confusion comes when people assumed it was merely a successor to telnet. but yes this is why its so important for OpenSSL client and server sides to be as bulletproof as they can. its a giant worldwide SPOF and therefore a drool-inducing pinata for hackers.
- clausecker 2y agoSSH is great but rapidly becomes less so once companies decide to put their servers behind some times cascaded SSH gateways, so you need to know which magic invocation of jump hosts to put in to have your connection go through anyway.
- dspillett 2y agoYou can simplify this for hosts you talk to regularly by configuring them in your .ssh/config file(s), as shown in https://wiki.gentoo.org/wiki/SSH_jump_host https://wiki.gentoo.org/wiki/SSH_jump_host A bit of faf for one-off or infrequent connections, but a great time saver for regular interactive use.
- clausecker 2y agoSure, but the setup really sucks for transitive jump hosts. It would be cool if SSH supported bang paths to access a remote host via various jump hosts, like `foo!bar!baz@quux` to access `baz@quux` by jumping through foo and then bar.
- alerighi 2y agoI often find out that SSH is blocked in a lot of networks. This is frustrating, since I usually clone git repositories trough SSH (and I'm considering for this reason switching to HTTPS), since I find stupid having to use a VPN just to work with git. If you really want to have something that gives you access to remote resources in any network the only solution is to use a VPN over TLS on the port 443, to make it impossible to distinguish it from any other normal HTTPS traffic. This is the reason why I run an OpenVPN server at my company, where normally I use Wireguard that is more performant (but it's blocked in a lot of networks). At the end of the day port 443 with TLS traffic on it is the only thing that is guaranteed to not have been blocked (on port 80, 25, etc firewalls may check that you are effectively transferring HTTP traffic, they could not on 443 since the traffic is encrypted, tough a smart firewall can assume from traffic patterns that the connection is unlikely HTTPS, to this day I've jet to se a firewall this smart).
- milkshakes 2y agohttps://github.com/erebe/wstunnel https://github.com/erebe/wstunnel
- bitlad 2y agoPrivilege Access Management platforms do unify external access protocol for SSH, k8s, databases etc. For eg. Cyberark Checkpoint harmony Teleport [https://goteleport.com https://goteleport.com] Strongdm [https://www.strongdm.com/ https://www.strongdm.com/] Adaptive [https://adaptive.dev/ https://adaptive.dev/] and there are many other tools like these.
- snowfield 2y agoSSH (The company behind ssh) even have their own. https://www.ssh.com/products/privileged-access-management-privx https://www.ssh.com/products/privileged-access-management-pr... I've not tested it much, but it seems very good
- glzone1 2y agoI think Amazon does a good job here. Default SSH is with certificates, passwords not used. I like that. Hard to brute force a certificates. In the old flat 10.X.X.X network amazon days - your new hosts were absolutely hammered when being brought up. There must have been folks on the amazon network itself just portscanning like crazy.
- kevincox 2y ago> Hard to brute force a certificates. I see this mentioned a lot. But is it any harder to brute force a 2048 certificate than a 2048 bit password? (Note: A 2048 bit password with base64 character set is 342 characters long) Don't get me wrong, there are many advantages to certificates (server doesn't learn the secret, easier to enforce strong secrets, ability to issue centrally, ...) but there is nothing magically different between a certificate and password when it comes to resistance to brute force. If you generate a high-entropy password you are fine from this point of view.
- glzone1 2y agoAt least in government there often were weird limits on password length (ie, 8, 40, 72 ) or in tooling around passwords. Certificates seem to force allow things like 2048 bits. Didn't Red Hat have a default at 8 for a while??
- kevincox 2y agoYeah. But if you can afford to store a certificate of that size you can afford to store the password. Also worth noting that for most types of certificate (like RSA where 2048 bit keys are common) there is much less than 2048 bits of entropy. So in practice the numbers probably end up much closer.
- lucasoshiro 2y agoSomething that few people remember is that if you have access to a filesystem through SSH, then you can have a remote Git repository with no configuration! In the remote machine, you only need to create a bare repository: git init --bare And in your "client" machines you use it like any other remotes: git remote add my_remote my_user@my_host:path_to_repo It can be useful if for some reason you don't want to use GitHub/GitLab/Bitbucket/etc or as a glorified scp
- sjmulder 2y agoYes this is exactly how I do my private git hosting! ssh example.com 'git init --bare git/foo.git' git remote add origin example.com:git/foo.git For other services too there are usually simple solutions like this. The low spec VPS never even sweats this way.
- utensil4778 2y agoFor quite a while before I built my homelab, my git server was a flash drive plugged into my OpenWRT router. Honestly I still kind of prefer that to gitlab et al. It's nice to not have to leave my terminal to setup a new repo. It takes so much more effort to log into a website and dismiss a bunch of notifications before I can click even more buttons to create a new repo. I like having all my repos accessible through the website, but I really just want to create new projects through ssh like a civilized person.
- t43562 2y agoIf ssh was less useful it would have less of an attack surface. ..... at least this is my theory. Hence why I rather like it. github uses ssh keys - surely developers can learn to set those up?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pphysch 2y agoOne neat feature of OpenSSH server is the AuthorizedKeysCommand config, which lets you fetch (or generate!) a user's keys from anywhere, e.g. a curl response. With this you can easily set up a centralized SSH keys system without the pitfalls of decentralized systems or running a CA. Have the user register their public key on your website in the typical fashion, and then write a simple secure endpoint and use AuthorizedKeysCommand to instantly integrate all your OpenSSH servers. It also lets you implement more exotic authorization schemes with the full capabilities of your internal backend, which is often a million times more enjoyable than fighting through Linux PAM. If you use SSSD and LDAP and don't like the idea of relying on a curl every login, you can also centrally-manage the keys in LDAP for a similar effects.
- fragmede 2y agoA popular website for that is GitHub.com. My public key is at http://GitHub.com/fragmede.keys http://GitHub.com/fragmede.keys, so anyone wanting to let me on their server can just create me an account, stick that in ~/.ssh/authorized_keys, tell me an IP address and port number, and I'm in.
- willtemperley 2y agoExposing SSH to the world really bothers me. Personally I firewall to my own IP when connecting to EC2 instances, it's a pain but I don't feel comfortable knowing there may be zero days out there, plus I don't want my CPU cycles wasted by script kiddies. It seems like there should be a better solution - something like port-knocking but done properly.
- Gud 2y agoWhy? OpenSSH is probably the most battle test piece of software on the planet. You have to make sure you run it on a similarly hardened operating system though.
- TacticalCoder 2y agoOpenSSH has seen one hole recently (and the failed xz attempt) and somehow SSH is less safe than a VPN? How the VPN configured? What is the client OS people are using to connect to the VPN? What's the track record security wise of the various VPN offering? The "SSH has a wide attack surface as seen by RCE ..." is a bit dishonest IMO. How s any VPN more secure? If you want configure SSH to be pubkey only and hand over Yubikey to your users. I wonder: in all the recent data leaks leaking billions of users data where attackers were inside company's networks (and not just on online facing servers), was it through SSH holes that these attack too place? Or are we talking about a corporate culture of Windows+VPN?