6 ms·
Sparrows may be 'canary in the coal mine' for lead poisoning in children: study
- vcxbx 2y ago[flagged]
- cjs_ac 2y agoLead poisoning in Australian mining towns is a surprisingly contentious issue. Town mayors usually try to cover up and deny any evidence of lead poisoning, because without the mines, there is no town. The broken hill that the town of Broken Hill is named after no longer exists. The mullock heap pictured in the article is all that remains: the entire hill was dug away when the original mine was active. As you can see on OpenStreetMap[0], the slag heap sits right in the middle of the town, with lead-laden dust blowing down into the streets and backyards every time the wind picks up. The other town mentioned in the article is Mount Isa[1]. Mount Isa has both a mine and a smelter, both located immediately to the west of the town. The prevailing winds are westerlies, so again the toxic dust falls on the town. [0] https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=14/-31.9653/141.4597 https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=14/-31.9653/141.4597 [1] https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=14/-20.7339/139.4831 https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=14/-20.7339/139.4831
- ClumsyPilot 2y ago> Town mayors usually try to cover up and deny any evidence of lead poisoning After moving to the West from a developing country was surprised to discover that things our politicians do for a big bribe western politicians sometimes do for free.
- soulofmischief 2y agoThe money just flows through different channels, but that's a funny observation.
- gwervc 2y agoExactly, corruption is more sophisticated, but it exists and is huge nonetheless. The big difference is that the starting GDP is higher, which allows for a little more to reach normal citizens after corruption is taken into account.
- cmrdporcupine 2y agoAn old friend of mine who was originally from Iran told me something a family member of his said to him, which was basically: "In the west you may not have bribery, but the ability to influence decisions is mostly out of your reach. At least here little people can have some small control over their environment through small bribes." I had never heard bribery pitched that way before, and it's obviously... a garbage... way to run a society. But. In Roman times, decision making, power, etc was in large part done through systems of explicit patronage. We now -- in public at least -- consider patronage to be a corrupt and awful thing, but then having a powerful patron was a sign of virtue and goodness. Having a wealthy famous patron literally made you a better person, "not-guilty" in various crimes, etc. I am not convinced that that ethic has ever really gone away. Just maybe more hidden.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> but the ability to influence decisions is mostly out of your reach. At least here little people can have some small control over their environment through small bribes This is mostly comforting nonsense. The average American has more say, potential and actual, in their government than the average Iranian. (And the average Iranian more than the Saudis.) What in a bribe economy one pays for with cash in a civil society takes effort. The tragedy in American civics is far too many are too poor, tired and/or uneducated to fully engage. And one of these states is preferable to the other. My Indian family used to speak similarly. Yet when they have the chance, they vote against corruption. To the degree India has become less corrupt over the last decade, it's been celebrated by them out of both pride and personal interest.
- 2y ago
- cmrdporcupine 2y agoThat's because the seat of power in the west is not with governments at all, but with business. The gov't ends up being there to keep them happy and avoid conflicts between them. They've mostly stripped themselves of the ability to do anything they could be bribed over.
- FredPret 2y agoI don't know man. The US government spends in a couple of months what the biggest companies are worth in total. According to this [0] Uncle Sam is obligated to spend 6.3T this year. That's 500B per month. Compare to the market cap of mammoth companies [1]. ExxonMobil, UnitedHealth, and Mastercard are all in the top 20 US companies and worth around one month of government spending. How can a whale be beholden to a flea? [0]: https://www.usaspending.gov/explorer/budget_function https://www.usaspending.gov/explorer/budget_function [1]: https://companiesmarketcap.com/ https://companiesmarketcap.com/
- cmrdporcupine 2y agoHow much of that is defense? How much is security & policing? A bulk of that spending is to keep the market going, and to protect business interests.
- tehjoker 2y agoThe government is designed for rich people from its foundation, it's a cozy revolving door for the elites and functions to repress popular movements. Officials identify with business and owners and can pick up do-nothing or interesting jobs after their government services. US elections are some of the most expensive in the world and politicians rely on donations to win their campaigns. The connections between business and government are a spider web. Business also isn't a set of individual companies, they in fact cooperate on public policy through think tanks such as the chamber of commerce and the business round table. Furthermore, since business controls the commodities and processes that sustain life, business holds a veto over economic policy with "capital strikes". Government could seize these properties, but our left wing is very weak. Think about it another way, why do you assume that elected officials have any obligation to the public when there is essentially no recourse except through elections and elections generally require oodles of money to win?
- nkrisc 2y agoBecause there lying and cheating for bribes are how politicians make money. Here, lying and cheating are how they keep the job that allows them to make money in other dishonest ways.
- recombined 2y agoAlways a pleasure to see we're in a good company. I've had the misfortune of being raised in this place: https://maps.app.goo.gl/aXkHEfX42aNp2yxV9 https://maps.app.goo.gl/aXkHEfX42aNp2yxV9 Combine a large lead smelting plant with one of the world's largest producers of (unenriched) uranium, and a dozen other metals like copper and zinc. Add zero effective environmental regulation on top, and you get us. According to government data, lead concentrations in the top soil are measured in hundreds to several thousands of milligrams per kilogram, depending on location. The norm is low dozens, if I am not mistaken. No blood level studies have been done since the end of the 1980s. Thanks to this link, I at least have a reference point from a relatively transparent and accountable society. All I can say, back when I was in middle to high school, it felt like every other kid was diagnosed with anemia (yours truly included), and skin conditions like atopic dermatitis or recurring abscesses covering half the body were very common. Personally I have never felt like having a sharp mind, but it's difficult to say how much impact lead may have had on this. This is how it typically looks on the ground, if you're interested: https://imgur.com/a/HyT1B5p https://imgur.com/a/HyT1B5p Don't know why I'm writing all this, I guess to let it be known that there are far worse places out there than a couple of small Australian towns (with what to me looks like very clean air).
- yessenzhar 2y agoI grew up in this town too in the 90s. It was very common to see everyone outside suddenly start coughing because of sulfur dioxide emissions from the plant.
- grecy 2y ago> I guess to let it be known that there are far worse places out there than a couple of small Australian towns (with what to me looks like very clean air). It sounds like the situation in your town was very bad. That neither diminishes nor invalidates a bad situation elsewhere. We should all be striving for better, no matter where we start from.
- oska 2y agoJust looking at that location on the map, it struck me how 'continental' it was, i.e. how inland it was. Turns out it's actually pretty near Eurasia's "Pole of inaccessibility", which is basically on the border between Kazakhstan and China [1]. As an Australian, I find our vast hinterland somewhat intimidating and haven't spent much time there. Like most Australians I live on its coastline. I also feel somewhat intimidated by Eurasia's vast inner continent, but also curious about it too. Would love to visit Kazakhstan sometime, but maybe not your hometown. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pole_of_inaccessibility#Eurasia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pole_of_inaccessibility#Eurasi...
- jeffbee 2y ago"Giant toxic slag heap in the middle of town" is probably pretty common. Was definitely a thing in El Paso, Texas, where I lived in the 1980s. https://www.nrdc.org/stories/flint-east-chicago-there-was-smeltertown https://www.nrdc.org/stories/flint-east-chicago-there-was-sm...
- teruakohatu 2y agoYou weren't kidding, that one mine has polluted a significant percentage of the entire earths surface [1]: > "The idea that Amundsen and Scott were traveling over snow that clearly was contaminated by lead from smelting and mining in Australia, and that lead pollution at that time was nearly as high as any time ever since, is surprising to say the least." > The similar timing and magnitude of changes in lead deposition across Antarctica, as well as the characteristic isotopic signature of Broken Hill lead found throughout the continent, suggest that this single emission source in southern Australia was responsible for the introduction of lead pollution into Antarctica at the end of the 19th century and remains a significant source today, the authors report. [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20140808070623/http://www.nasa.gov/content/goddard/lead-pollution-beat-explorers-to-south-pole-persists-today/#.U96NN_ldX2f https://web.archive.org/web/20140808070623/http://www.nasa.g...
- Reason077 2y agoSeems crazy that you’d build a town so close to the mine (or a smelter so close to a town). It’s not as if Australia is short on space for building things! Perhaps it should be a condition of operating a lucrative mining site that you build/subsidise worker’s accommodation at a reasonable enough distance to be free from contamination.
- ern 2y agoAs I understand it, much mining is done in Australia through FIFO (fly-in-fly-out) nowadays. It greatly reduces the need for infrastructure, boom-bust towns and issues like these.
- zug_zug 2y agoIt's really scary how a tiny amount of a mineral can permanently damage the human mind. I have to admit there's a part of me that almost wants to be skeptical, that mg of a rock could overcome the wonderous self-aware human mind. Every so often I have to remind that skeptical piece of me that it's an idiot and that every human alive is wildly fragile to any number of elements and chemicals. ------ Onto the article, if I ran a production software system, I'd be collecting data on the health of all my servers. If I ran a country, I'd collect health data on all my towns (perhaps blood tests of 1% of the population each year). Of course in malfunctioning environments, measurement is scary to leaders because it can give evidence that they aren't doing their job.
- s5300 2y ago[dead]
- jasonjayr 2y agoPublic Health agencies (at least in the US) collecting data about residents is a thing. People just get a little touchy about government programs collecting all this data ...
- KennyBlanken 2y agoWhat? Public health agencies are "goverment programs." Also: corporations lobby against funding / legislation / regulation for public health data collection - and then tell conservative voters it's about "their privacy." Meanwhile, corporate America is selling literally every scrap of data it can to each other, LexisNexis, Palantir... It's not just other corporations buying up that commercially available data; it's intelligence agencies and law enforcement, too.
- jasonjayr 2y agoYes -- I wasn't implying that public health organzations != government. And I know that (at least they're supposed to) government collected data has strict policies on handling + processing it, where as commercially available data is more "loosy-goosey". (Which, government has learned they can also use with little more than a polite word)
- seattle_spring 2y agoSparrow in the lead mine, if it were
- nanomonkey 2y agoAnyone know a simple method of testing for lead in food? Say a wet chemistry method? I live in California, and I've noticed that everything has a CA Proposition 65 warning label. When I look into it it's generally lead that has bioaccumulated in the plant. What I can't find is how much or how widespread it is in the food.
- Cordiali 2y agoThere's test swabs for leaded paint, but I don't know if they'd be sensitive enough for food. At least where I live, they're pretty cheap, so it could be an interesting experiment. I remember seeing an article a while ago, where some local councils here specifically recommended building raised garden beds for veggie gardens. They apparently found, that in cities/towns older than about a hundred years, the risk of soil contamination can be pretty high, the main suspects being lead and arsenic. Raised garden beds is an easy way of eliminating that risk.
- throwup238 2y ago> I remember seeing an article a while ago, where some local councils here specifically recommended building raised garden beds for veggie gardens. They apparently found, that in cities/towns older than about a hundred years, the risk of soil contamination can be pretty high, the main suspects being lead and arsenic. Raised garden beds is an easy way of eliminating that risk. I'd recommend raised beds to anyone who lives in a suburb or city that's even a few decades old. The particulates and oils washing off the street and down roof shingles alone introduces plenty of contamination. Very rainy regions like the Pacific Northwest have to build rain gardens [1] everywhere to filter out baseline levels of suburban pollution, otherwise their water gets really bad. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rain_garden https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rain_garden
- nanomonkey 2y agoYeah, City Slickers in Oakland stopped testing the soil and just told everyone that they should use raised beds. Problem is that there are so many fruit trees and self starting plants that I want to eat (I'm looking at you collards), but I'd like to know what I'm getting into. Also I've read that sunflowers are really good at pulling up heavy metals, and all of the bags that I purchase have warning labels on them. I'm curious if this is a real concern!
- KennyBlanken 2y agoLead poisoning is quite common in suburban and urban areas, when houses / buildings are demolished. There's a huge plume of lead and asbestos dust that is generated, even if the contractor is making some effort to wet the site. If a building or home in your area is being demolished? Don't open your windows, and don't go outside without a well-fitting dust mask. Never attend a building demolition event. Contractors and developers are supposed to take measures and inform local government...if they're stupid enough to inspect for lead / asbestos before construction and declare that they're doing asbestos / lead abatement. Every piece of regulation and law I've found uses a very fascinating phrasing - you're required to do things if conducting abatement. Many states go further and exempt anything under a dozen or two units or commercial buildings. It's an absolute shitshow.
- cybersandwich 2y ago>if they are stupid enough to inspect That's sadly true. There is no requirement to test; there is only a requirement to abate if you know its there. A friend of mine had a contractor say "those look like asbestos tiles, but you havne't tested them right ;) ;) ? If I dont know they are asbestos I can do this job for $X. Otherwise it will be $X + $5K so I can do abatement"
- smeagull 2y agoPeople consider Sparrows pests?
- PlunderBunny 2y agoIt's strange, isn't it? I love them.
- yareally 2y agoThere are many kinds of sparrows, but the one people usually refer to as a pest is the Eurasian House Sparrow. Can be found on 6 continents, reproduces quickly, and are gregarious (most other sparrows don't live in groups). I find their antics to be interesting, but they're aggressive to other birds, especially for nesting sites (and they'll nest anywhere, unlike many of the birds they compete with).
- kwhitefoot 2y agoThey are only a pest outside their home range. In the UK they are in decline. "Conservation of the house sparrow Data suggests the UK's house sparrow population declined by 66% between 1977 and 2015, with urban populations faring worse than rural ones." https://www.nhm.ac.uk/discover/house-sparrow-passer-domesticus.html https://www.nhm.ac.uk/discover/house-sparrow-passer-domestic...
- yareally 2y agoFunny enough, so are European Pigeons and Starlings. We have too many here in the States, but on the decline in Europe. I'm guessing part of it is due to our sanitary habits here. Lots of food is trashed in a way that makes it easy for them to forge for it.
- stubish 2y agoIn Australia, they are an invasive species. They are now endemic, out competing native species across the continent.
- nineteen999 2y agoTangentially, a bunch of movies have been filmed in and around Broken Hill[1], including Mad Max 2 and 4, Mission Impossible 2, Priscilla: Queen of the Desert, Wake in Fright, and my personal favourite cheesy Australian B-Movie, Razorback. The landscape typically lends itself to that kind of dry post-apocalyptic look, however shooting for Mad Max: Fury Road was relocated to Namibia[2] as heavy rains had caused the area to break out into bloom. [1] https://www.brokenhill.nsw.gov.au/Services/Filming-in-Broken-Hill/Filmed-In-Broken-Hill https://www.brokenhill.nsw.gov.au/Services/Filming-in-Broken... [2] https://www.nfsa.gov.au/collection/curated/asset/99353-mad-max-fury-road-nsw-filming-announcement https://www.nfsa.gov.au/collection/curated/asset/99353-mad-m...
- mattpallissard 2y agoGenuine question. Wouldn't it be more efficient to check the levels of lead in the people periodically? If a sparrow has high levels of lead then you still need to check the people. It seems like it would be fewer steps, fewer tests, and less messing around by making testing more available to the people.
- notjulianjaynes 2y agoThis is neat, but why can't they just test the children's blood directly? In Massachusetts 70% of all children aged 9 months to 4 years old had their blood tested for lead in 2022. I'm not sure what the national average is. https://www.mass.gov/doc/2022-annual-childhood-lead-poisoning-surveillance-report-0/download https://www.mass.gov/doc/2022-annual-childhood-lead-poisonin... [PDF]
- stubish 2y agoBecause you can test the sparrows without having to raise an infant on the site. If you can demonstrate areas that are unsafe or illegal to raise children in, then perhaps people won't raise children there (or not, given we already know these mining towns are toxic and children raised in them will be victims of lead poisoning to various degrees). The reason they are testing children in the article is to confirm that the sparrow test is a valid proxy, and we will be able to test on a wider scale around the country.
- notjulianjaynes 2y agoAh, makes sense given the population density in parts of Australia.
- kwhitefoot 2y agoInstead of testing sparrows to infer blood lead in children why not just test the children?
- defrost 2y agoIn the specific case of this study they tested both (and looked back at historic records) and now know that sparrows make a very good proxy for human results. This is useful because: The Macquarie University environmental scientist and PhD candidate said collecting blood samples from people, especially children, can be difficult to conduct, and can raise significant logistical and ethical issues. As a result, data on children's blood lead levels is unavailable in many parts of Australia where communities intersect with mining and smelting operations. ~ Linked article, towards the end. It's also not just Australia where human proxies are useful.
- kwhitefoot 2y ago> collecting blood samples from people, especially children, can be difficult to conduct, and can raise significant logistical and ethical issues. Really? Children visit family doctors relatively often in my experience and taking a blood sample is a trivial and routine task for the nurse at my GP's surgery. What ethical issue is there?
- defrost 2y ago> in my experience Well, that's all that counts then I guess, never mind the stated opinion of medical researchers in the field with broader experience. Christian Scientists and Jehovah’s Witnesses oppose blood transfusions and small town groups (which can be quite large in specific towns and non existant in others) can oppose blood samples also. Various indiginous groups within Australia and elsewhere can be opposed to medical tests .. for fear of being guinea pigs in experiments again. Some people just don't like giving samples.
- kwhitefoot 2y ago
- usrbinbash 2y agoBird may be another Bird.
- _glass 2y agoI once moved to a home in Hamburg, and coming from Southern Germany, I didn't even know that it could be possible, but then in the mail came a letter, warning that we have been drinking water with 16x the amount of allowed lead, because the home was from before the 50s and had all lead pipes. We lived there just for a few months, but my daughter drank the water (me, too, but I am not that worried).