2 ms·
"Gestapo drones" Welp. This thread was godwinned rather quickly. Have any argument that isn't based in hyperbole and other logical fallacies?
by Karunamon 14y ago
"Gestapo drones"
Welp. This thread was godwinned rather quickly. Have any argument that isn't based in hyperbole and other logical fallacies?
- koglerjs 14y agoI'm trying to balance my obeisance to Godwin's Law with my very strong criticism/fear of drones in US airspace. It's hard. I _really_ think the potential for UAV abuse is high. But it's a Law of the Internet, I guess. You win this round.
- mindcrime 14y ago"Godwin's Law" is nothing but another stupid Internet meme. It's about as useful as Natalie Portman covered in hot grits in Soviet Russia while welcoming our new Overlords by emailing South Korean people using Plan Nine From Outer Space. With Frickin' lasers.
- Karunamon 14y ago>I _really_ think the potential for UAV abuse is high. I agree, however there's no legal standing to challenge it on. I'd rather spend my energy, instead of trying to fight something that is going to pass, to instead fight the abuses and make sure that the tool can't be misused too badly. Denying the tool outright is just silly, especially with our current understanding of privacy.
- mindcrime 14y agoThis thread was godwinned rather quickly. Fuck "Godwin's Law", as far as I'm concerned. It doesn't mean what 98% of people who invoke it think it means, and even if it did, who cares... it's just some off-hand observation by one random dude. But if it will make you feel better, I can edit my post and change it to reference the KGB or the Stasi or something, instead of the Gestapo. Have any argument that isn't based in hyperbole and other logical fallacies? Nope; I'm not here to argue.
- Karunamon 14y agoOh, so you're just posting content-free hyperbole then. Okay.
- mindcrime 14y agoHyperbole is just a tool, like anything else. If you can't look beyond the technique and see the underlying point, that's as much a failing of your insight as my writing. Nobody else here seems to have gotten hung up on that aspect, FWIW.
- Karunamon 14y ago>If you can't look beyond the technique and see the underlying point It's a weak technique usually employed by those who have nothing of substance to say. Why resort to a cheap appeal to emotion right out the gate? What's the point? What is your point?
- mindcrime 14y agoWhy resort to a cheap appeal to emotion right out the gate? First, I reject the premise of this question, therefore no real answer is possible. There's nothing "cheap" about emotion. And aren't we getting way too caught up in debating style over substance here? I think my point was pretty clear, personally, and that you're just being intentionally argumentative for the sake of being argumentative. But since you asked, the point is that our government(s) are far too large, bureaucratic, corrupt and evil as it is, and that the continued militarization of local police is an unhealthy step towards more State power... a trend which I've observed growing over my lifetime (38 years so far) and which seems to be continuing unabated, if not gaining steam. Now, go ahead and accuse me of a "slippery slope fallacy," if you want. But I believe that if the bad guys (and I do consider governments to be the bad guys) have these UAVs flying around spying on (and, more than likely, eventually attacking) us, then we should at least have the capability to respond in kind. Whether or not it's actually time to start doing that is an open question, but we should resist letting the balance of power shift further and further. None of this, if course, argues against a simultaneous strategy of working to reduce State power by educating people, using the electoral process, etc. But I'd rather hedge my bets...