4 ms·
The military has a better model of security. They protect things at different security levels. I've spent time in the classified world. Security can be obtaine
by Animats 2y ago
The military has a better model of security. They protect things at different security levels.
I've spent time in the classified world. Security can be obtained, but costs are high. At the aerospace company, we estimated for bid purposes that running a project at SECRET doubled the cost. Running at levels above that became even more expensive, and much slower. You have to partition things, so that only the really critical stuff gets the most expensive protection. It's common to have a project where the project is mostly unclassified, many things are SECRET, and a very few things are at higher levels.
The military views security as time-limited. When and where the attack will start is highly classified until the attack is underway. After that, there is no secret. New weapons systems eventually get used or cancelled, after which they're less secret. The intelligence community wants to protect info forever, though.
The credit card services get this. The CVV is required to have a higher level of protection than credit card numbers or names and addresses. Banks understand separation of functions and mutual mistrust. Most computer security work doesn't think this way.
- LilBytes 2y agoInteresting that your experience was a double increase in costs from going up in security level. My experience was it was an order of magnitude (10x) at each level . E.g., OFFICIAL let's say is $1,000,000 PRIVATE becomes $10,000,000 SECRET becomes $100,000,000 What we did experience was the cost in time to deliver a service doubled however. E.g., OFFICIAL was 3 years, PRIVATE was 6 years and so on. I expect it varies significantly between types of system, ours was a SaaS platform that read telemetry from embedded systems on assets in the field, so I'd assume that would be one of the drivers for my differing experience than yours.
- WalterBright 2y ago> Most computer security work doesn't think this way. The computer industry is determined to relearn the well-known lessons the hard way. For example, we still have a single password breach brings down the entire system. It's like building a battleship that would sink if a 2 inch hole in the hull happened. The way to make systems secure is not to devise a perfect password system. The way is to make the system secure in spite of password breaches. It's a completely different mindset. To return to the battleship analogy, it isn't about preventing holes in the hull. It's about surviving holes in the hull.
- fsflover 2y agoThis is exactly how Qubes OS approaches it with security through compartmentalization: You run everything in VMs, and any compromised VM will not lead to a compromise of the whole system.
- jtwaleson 2y agoI agree with the solution, but what do you mean with "better" in the first sentence? Spelling out the complete approach wasn't suitable for the article, but the ISO 27001 framework spells out roughly what you describe. At each "security classification level" you have a different risk appetite, and will apply different controls.
- Animats 2y agoIt's the partitioning that's the hard part in commercial organizations. In military and intel, different people, offices, and equipment handle different security levels and compartments. This has an enormous influence on the structure of the organization. It's the main cause of higher costs. All this is about security, not integrity. Security is keeping info from getting out. Integrity is about keeping attackers from breaking things. Integrity used to be mostly a wartime problem, but now there's so much anonymity online that it's a problem all the time, a bigger one than security. Hence ransomware.
- JohnFen 2y ago> The military views security as time-limited. In my time as a computer security specialist, this has been the most difficult thing to get other computer people to understand. Especially when it comes to cryptography. No cryptographic system can, or is intended to, keep something secret indefinitely. The whole point is to keep the secret for long enough that by the time it's cracked, the information itself is out of date and therefore disclosure is no longer harmful (or, at least, is much less harmful). All security, computer or otherwise, is like a fire door. No fire door will hold back a fire forever. They are all rated in terms of the number of hours they'll be effective in a fire. Security must be thought of in similar terms. But I understand. People want perfect security and wishful thinking is seductive. People also want security "for free" -- meaning something they can install or configure and then not have to worry about it anymore. But that's impossible, in large part because actual security doesn't have a technological solution. Security is a process that depends on proper human behavior. Technology can and does act as a "force multiplier" here, but a security approach that is 100% technological is a security approach that will be subverted sooner or later.