4 ms·
Deconstructing the Role-Playing Video Game
- lovegrenoble 2y agoThat's an interesting read, thank you, btw I also contributed to RPG games by making this generator a couple of years ago: https://tabletopy.com https://tabletopy.com
- Nav_Panel 2y agoReally liked this post, thanks for sharing all the references. I actually did a similar project recently of playing a lot of classic JRPGs, but my research only culminated in a blogpost (https://snav.substack.com/p/26-analysis-rainbow-silkroad https://snav.substack.com/p/26-analysis-rainbow-silkroad) rather than any sort of actual project -- the filesystem RPG is a very cool idea!! Would be fun to get some autogenerated fs dungeons :)
- msla 2y agoThe "mercantile RPG" genre sounds a bit like "Drug Wars" or "Taipan!" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drug_Wars_%28video_game%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drug_Wars_%28video_game%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taipan%21 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taipan%21
- zer0tonin 2y agoThat's funny, I remember playing a little bit of a Silkroad themed (MMO)RPG as a teenager (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silkroad_Online https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silkroad_Online). I wonder if this game inspired it somehow.
- moritonal 2y agoFantastic game. Only thing free my friend and I could play so we'd play nonstop for a summer or two. Learning basic business sense running a shop outside the safe towns was one of those cool things MMOs can really offer. Support harp class was OP as all hell.
- AdmiralAsshat 2y ago> Over in Japan, the Enyx designers combined the dungeon crawling from Wizardry and the over-world exploration of Ultima, adjusting them to the limitations of the Famicom/NES console—and to the tastes of the local public. With a linear story, streamlined systems focused on battles, and a more forgiving difficulty level, Dragon Quest became the blueprint of what would become the Japanese RPG genre. "Enix", I assume? Also, while Enix was the publisher behind Dragon Quest (and pretty much made the series the core of the company's identity), the original DQ was actually developed by ChunSoft.
- drewcoo 2y agoTo further correct that article snippet . . . Dragon Quest did not have Wizardry-like dungeon crawling. It had Ultima-like dungeon crawling. Ultima III had top-down tiled dungeons in '83.
- smcameron 2y ago> Ultima III had top-down tiled dungeons in '83. That's not what I remember, Ultima III had crude 3D dungeons similar to Wizardry's dungeons. The maps of the dungeon levels were 2D and tiled. Google image search for "ultima iii dungeon" confirms my memory.
- CamperBob2 2y agoIn fact, all of the Ultimas through V had first-person dungeon views. Wizardry's wireframe dungeon renderer was a bit more advanced, though, in the sense that it supported empty space and disjoint 'islands' in the map, while Ultima I and II could only display corridors. IIRC that limitation was fixed by III, but it may have been IV. It was definitely fixed by V.
- tmtvl 2y agoI dunno about Ultima III, but QotA had 'battle screen' sections of dungeon, which basically means a top-down section. I believe the altars are in such sections? I do know there's a three-way split in the Stygian Abyss, because I accidentally went around in a circle last time I played. QotA is really awesome, I should play it again some time.
- markus_zhang 2y agoJust to comment on the choice to go text instead of graphics. I actually think it's pretty easy to program a graphic based 2d game. SDL2 is very easy to use and can blit graphics easily. I do agree it increases the complexity though.
- HideousKojima 2y agoOr even simpler, you could do a roguelike with a custom graphical font
- markus_zhang 2y agoYeah, I remember using bearlibterminal library to make a simple roguelike, which contains a set of graphical font.
- spondylosaurus 2y agoThere are a bunch of GUI-based 2D games tools, too. RPGMaker is probably the most famous.
- xeonmc 2y agoOr not even that: https://www.decisionproblem.com/paperclips/ https://www.decisionproblem.com/paperclips/
- chrisweekly 2y agoTangent: the novel "Tomorrow, Tomorrow, and Tomorrow" by Gabrielle Zevin is a well-written book about a fictional video game studio. I'm not a game designer but it went into a fair amount of detail and seemed pretty authentic. Curious if others here have read it and can comment.
- jhbadger 2y agoAnother similar novel which I liked is Austin Grossman's You (bad title, I know), also about a fictional game studio in the 1980s and 1990s.
- chrisweekly 2y agoCool, thanks, will check it out.
- jaaron 2y agoGame developer here. Read Zevin's book. As expected, some parts are spot on, some are wildly off, but within the industry there is also a wide range of experiences. If you want to learn more about actual game development stories, I recommend Blood, Sweat, and Pixels: https://www.harpercollins.com/products/blood-sweat-and-pixels-jason-schreier?variant=32122042744866 https://www.harpercollins.com/products/blood-sweat-and-pixel...
- chrisweekly 2y agoThanks! Added to reading list.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nox101 2y agoI always find these categories frustrating. A Link to the Past and Chrono Trigger do not belong in the same category. In the first, you have action fights that require quick hand-eye coordination and skilled reflexes. In the 2nd you just choose actions from menus, no hand-eye coordination nor reflexes required. To me, an RPG, has always meant the latter (choose [attack, magic, item] from a menu). Wizardry, Bard's Tale (Apple II), FF7 are RPGs. A Link to the Past, Link's Adventure, Breath of the Wild, are not. I know the letters RPG stand for "Role Playing Game" but if we're going to go down that route, Flight Sim is an RPG. You play the role of an airplane pilot. Mario Tennis, would also be an RPG. you play the role of a cartoon tennis players. GTA5 is an RPG. You play the role of a member of a street gang. Since we know that's not what people mean when they say RPG, we're still left making sure were discussing comparable games. IMO, Zelda games (nearly all action games) are not comparable to Final Fantasy or other J-RPG games (nearly all select from a menu games). Their similarity is at most, they are set in a middle-earth tolken-esk setting where you fight monsters with swords. But that's clearly not a useful distinction as it would leave out Earthbound or any other RPG not set in a wizards & dragons type of setting.
- bityard 2y agoYou are not wrong. Legend of Zelda is categorized as an adventure game. Or sometimes, action-adventure to emphasize the sword-swinging aspect. This is the kind of thing that people will argue about, but to me, a role-playing video game is characterized by a controlling party (usually) of characters with stats that can change based on the player's actions and/or progress, and turn-based combat.
- PradeetPatel 2y agoI often draw the line between adventure/action-rpg (Zelda, Diablo, etc.) with traditional RPG based on the reliance of in-game character skills vs player skills. In a traditional RPG, a character with sufficient stats are bound to succeed more often, whereas in an action game it really depends on the skill of the player.
- 2y ago
- PhasmaFelis 2y ago> I’ve played JRPGs long enough that I don’t pay much attention to the characters or the plot anymore > I don’t particularly enjoy strategizing, I just default to punch with warriors and spell with wizards, with the occasional healing potion in between That doesn't seem to leave a whole lot...
- johnnyanmac 2y agoSeems like this kind of mentality boils down to "I like the art direction and broad story tropes but not much else". It always baffles me as a JRPG player that grew up with stuff like Final Fantasy 7, Wild Arms, and Tales of Symphonia how people would play these 40+ hour adventures made up of 10+ hours of cutscenes but also not care about the characters (you know, the ones you take the role of) and the story. Even if we are sticking to the Japanese art style, you have games like Devil May Cry or Bayonetta for a "turn your plot brain off" action game, a myriad of fighting games that is 95+% gameplay, and platformers like Mario that has set dressing at best for a plot.
- kibwen 2y agoIf the author is reading this, I highly recommend you look into the history of text adventures and MUDs (multi-user dungeons), as the post completely omits them despite the fact that they are almost literally "RPGs with command-line interfaces". While old-school text adventures remained fairly primitive in the RPG aspect (and new-school text adventures have trended away from the RPG genre and into interactive fiction), MUDs represent the logical conclusion of the thought process here. For reference, check out DiscworldMUD (http://discworld.starturtle.net/lpc/ http://discworld.starturtle.net/lpc/), which is still actively developed and can be played in your browser: discworld.starturtle.net/lpc/decafmud/web_client.html
- pjc50 2y ago> I’ve played JRPGs long enough that I don’t pay much attention to the characters or the plot anymore; I like the pretty pixels, yes, but most importantly I’m drawn to its underlying systems. This person needs the https://code.tutsplus.com/bartles-taxonomy-of-player-types-and-why-it-doesnt-apply-to-everything--gamedev-4173a https://code.tutsplus.com/bartles-taxonomy-of-player-types-a... Bartle EASK MUD player taxonomy. They would also benefit from discovering the Inform programming language.
- noelwelsh 2y ago> In retrospect, looking at tabletop RPGs felt backward because, by using the video games I already knew as models instead, I was benefiting from decades of RPG system simplifications—half the job had already been done. This is quite a narrow view. Computer RPGs have, for the most part, focused on the combat aspect of the game as that is the easiest part to implement on a computer. Table-top RPGs have gone in many other directions. I find games that focus on story telling to be much more interesting than focusing on combat, and there are some interesting game mechanics that have arisen in these systems. One example is https://wildletters.itch.io/move-quietly-and-tend-things https://wildletters.itch.io/move-quietly-and-tend-things
- mmaniac 2y agoThe title of this article threw me for a loop. I was expecting a deconstruction in the literary sense. Still, I didn't leave disappointed.
- TeMPOraL 2y agoCan someone explain "deconstruction in the literary sense" to me in an ELI5 way, or even "explain like I'm a programmer with no classical literature degree and for whom English is a second language" way? Every time it pops up, I end up re-reading the Wikipedia article on deconstruction, and my eyes end up sliding over words as my mind fails to understand what's being talked about.
- mmaniac 2y agoDeconstruction would be using tropes of a genre in a way which challenges their usual narrative function. It's related to subversion, but it also has something to say about the genre's implicit themes in general. Undertale is an RPG where killing every monster you meet for XP is a very bad thing to do in the context of the plot. Perhaps killing everything in your path to succeed is not a good message. That would be a blunt example of how it deconstructs the genre. NieR contains a medieval fantasy setting, a wilful protagonist, a dark mirror antagonist, "the power of friendship", heroic sacrifices, and secret endings. These are all staples of RPGs, but they're used here in ways which are subtly critical of the rest of the genre. I don't have a literature degree either, so I don't know whether this is also the strict definition. But this seems to be how it's used in casual online discussions.
- TeMPOraL 2y agoTangent on the Carmack quote - “Story in a game is like story in a porn movie. It’s expected to be there, but it’s not important.” I never agreed much with it, as the games I got hooked on as a kid I did mostly because of their stories - however, very recently, I started to like games that are almost 100% story and 0% free-form gameplay. Namely, the "choose your own adventure" stories with quick action events, and such. Bear with me :). Two strong titles from that category (both 11/10, will play again, recommend to everyone remotely in the target audience): - Star Trek: Resurgence - IMHO the best Trek game in the past 20 years, and the very one you want if you'd like to feel yourself, if for a moment, living and breathing Starfleet life (not just on the top, but also on the lower decks). - The Invincible - based on Stanisław Lem's 1963 novel of the same title, it's something you want if you're into hard sci-fi, sci-fi meets philosophy, or that sweet atomic era / Soviets-in-space punk. Why I started to like this genre? Both games above I could describe in one phrase: Mass Effect but without all the running around and other bullshit distractors. The games are designed to give you choices (usually time-sensitive) that alter events. There is limited freedom of movement, but it's always obvious where you need to go. The fights, if present, are real, but simplified. The quick action sequences and minigames are designed to mimic context-relevant behavior in the simplest possible way (say "press W" to lift a panel, or "press D + LMB" to push the person to the right away from sudden danger while shooting towards it, etc.). This results in a kind of flow - you have pretty much all the meaningful choices and gameplay of a typical CRPG like Mass Effect (or even more), and zero of the frustration of getting lost, tripping off a ledge, or doing any of the many other immersion-breaking things you would encounter in a typical CRPG on a regular basis. In essence, this is subverting the article's concept: those games are minimum viable story-driven games, distilled and stripped out of all boring gameplay parts :). Or, in Carmack's terms, captivating erotica that lacks explicit depictions, but achieves the same result by being cleverly suggestive at all times.
- cainxinth 2y ago> I never agreed much with it, as the games I got hooked on as a kid I did mostly because of their stories… I have always prioritized gameplay over story, which is why I consider unskippable cutscenes to be a high crime in game design.
- kstenerud 2y agoOne of the things I liked to do in these old RPGs was find a way to level up to max right from the beginning. Usually it would involve putting a clamp on the controller at a particular point in the game. This worked in Ys and Dragon Slayer and FF6, for example. In Genso Suikoden, I discovered a way to get so many water seals that I was effectively invulnerable because I'd regenerate 10x my health every round. Unfortunately, there's a vampire boss who's unkillable and is supposed to defeat you as part of the story. So I couldn't progress any further because it was impossible for either of us to kill the other.