5 ms·
The struggle to understand why earthquakes happen in America's heartland
- s5300 2y ago[dead]
- jmward01 2y agoWhat does it take to convince people to take risks like this seriously? The challenge is that hypothetical risks 'sometime in the next 50+ years' don't convince people to do things, at least in the US. The pacific northwest is at a much higher risk from an array of faults (not just the cascadia subduction zone) and volcanic hazards but even there, where the risks are very well understood, getting a large region to take it seriously looks to be a near impossible task. Most people I have talked to don't even know that there is a risk in the PNW much less the magnitude of it or how to prepare. What are steps that actually work to actually educate and convince people?
- com2kid 2y agoBuilding codes require earthquake strapping and take landslide risk into account. What more do you want people to do? Seattle has had large earthquakes in its short history as a large American city and honestly even mid 20th century construction held up ok. This isn't like parts of Japan where large earthquakes will happen on regular intervals. Engineers have to weigh costs vs risks.
- blincoln 2y ago> Building codes require earthquake strapping and take landslide risk into account. "In Tennessee, jurisdictions can decide whether to opt in to building codes with earthquake provisions, while other states — like Missouri — don’t have state-wide building codes at all, though there are efforts to change that."
- com2kid 2y agoGP comment is talking about the Pacific NW, and WA state at least most certainly does require earthquake provisions.
- coding123 2y agoMost people don't want to live afraid of everything. I learned that lesson in the past 3 years.
- antonvs 2y agoYou've erased a lot of nuance there between two very different situations.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoI would add that everyone dies eventually. Attempts to entirely de-risk life are a futile effort, and reasonable people can disagree on what level of safety is appropriate.
- doe_eyes 2y agoWhat is the outcome you're hoping for, though? It's not useful for people to live with vague anxiety. Are there specific solutions we want them to pursue, and that aren't being handled by the government?
- shiroiushi 2y agoHe's probably hoping for emergency preparedness, like any sensible person. That would include stronger building codes, evacuation plans and facilities, emergency supplies, etc. Here in Japan, we have all that stuff, and we don't live with "vague anxiety" (certainly nothing like the high anxiety that most Americans live with these days). Big earthquakes are rare, but smaller ones are very common, but everything in society is engineered to handle it well so it rarely causes problems.
- throwup238 2y ago> everything in society is engineered to handle it well Except nuclear reactor backup systems </tongue in cheek>
- lupusreal 2y agoIf the matter rarely being a problem is the bar to meet, then Japan and Seattle have both met that bar. Seattle is less prepared but the quakes of note are also more rare, so both meet the "rarely causes problems" standard. It wouldn't make sense for every place to prepare as much as Japan for things that are less likely there than in Japan. Does Japan have as many tornado shelters as Kansas? Probably not.
- rprospero 2y agoHonest question: how often do you do Tornado drills in Japan? A quick look look at the wiki[1] indicates that you do get them, but fairly rarely. I honestly don't know your cultural perspective on them. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_tornadoes_and_tornado_outbreaks_in_Asia#Japan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_tornadoes_and_tornado_... I grew up on the edges of the New Madrid fault area and, while earthquakes were never discussed, we did tornado drills about every two months while in school. After I entered the workforce, that got closer to once a year, but you were still expected to have a plan and supplies. It was basic emergency preparedness, like any sensible person. Granted, big F5 tornados are rare, but small ones were common enough to not even be noteworthy. Having left that region as an adult, it was a small culture shock meeting people who never had this kind of training. After all, the places I've visited all experience tornados, though not as often as my old home town. Still, the usual attitude I encounter is "I've never seen a tornado - they don't happen here". It's true that tornados don't happen often, just like my birthplace hasn't seen a serious earthquake in my lifetime, but they do happen. I guess that's why I'm curious about your experiences. I've never been to Japan and I've read enviable reports of your disaster preparedness, but I honestly have no idea how your schools and culture handle tornados.
- lenerdenator 2y agoIt's like everything else: it comes down to money. People who don't have much of it (which is to say, most of the area in the New Madrid seismic zone) don't want to spend it on something that might happen at some completely unpredictable time in the future. They don't want the government telling them to do it, either, because in their minds, that's the government telling them to spend money they don't have. More money == more interest in long-term preservation.
- throwaway173738 2y agoSo you can see how a living wage and parity for tipped professions is actually in the national interest.
- lenerdenator 2y agoExactly. The problem is, you will have to take money from some parts of the country to subsidize places like the Missouri Bootheel if you wish to see these sorts of improvements made, at least for a few decades. The engine for economic growth simply isn't there. Kansas City and St. Louis make up somewhere between 75-90% of the state gross product. Springfield and Columbia make up a little bit of the difference. The entire rest of the state by land area makes up less than 10%.
- jajko 2y ago... and thats communism in eyes of many, I'd say most americans (better redistribution of wealth instead of winners take it all and screw the rest, they didn't try hard enough). Healthcare is the same topic. So is public education.
- sqeaky 2y agoThis shouldn't be downvoted. Many right-wingers will say anything is "communism" and act like that ends the discussion, because it certainly ends their involvement with the serious part of the discussion. "Communism" and "Socialism" are invoked like magical bogeyman that will destroy everything. To have any discussion on social welfare this needs to be somehow bypassed in discussions.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 2y ago> What does it take to convince people to take risks like this seriously? What risks should a human in the 21st century take seriously? Like, if there is a 1-in-50,000 chance of death or lasting injury, is that something that should have me hiding in the closet? I'd take a 1-in-100 chance very seriously of course, I run into 1-in-100 events many times in any given year. If I am supposed to take a particular risk seriously, how much am I expected to pay to mitigate it? You're slandering their ability to be rational without even taking into the account that they have evaluated it and judged the probability too low to act on without bothering to check if they quantify that correctly. They don't have the wrong numbers, they just set the threshold higher than you do. For me personally, anything below about 1-in-5000 warrants very minor attention, anything in the 1-in-100,000 area isn't even worth thinking about. Covid was scary as shit, early on in some regions it seemed to rise above 1-in-2000 chance of death.
- jmward01 2y agoProbabilities are very hard to think about so I personally relate back to driving. We do it every day but admit it is dangerous and take precautions like requiring testing and licensing, regulate the manufacture of vehicles and inspections and set standards for roads and provide emergency support. Anything more dangerous than driving is of high concern to me and probably requires many additional precautions. Anything less and I try to not get that worked up about it. With the above in mind, my comment basically can be summed up as 'It is easier to see the issues in the PNW and the PNW isn't doing what is needed to avoid them so how can we expect better preparation elsewhere?'. Pointing out issues in the PNW is like shooting fish in a barrel. Everyone in Ocean Shores is going to die and that is the tip of the iceberg. Estimates vary but a 1 in 4 chance in the next 50 years of a cascadia event is not a ridiculous estimate. With the preparation in place it is not unlikely that tens of thousands will die in the first few hours, if not even worse than that. The emergency response won't be able to help because the region impacted is massive and the first responders will be part of that region so even they will need to be rescued. The scale of this dwarfs any natural disaster the US has ever faced and reaches a point that it could hurt the country for years after. Bottom line, Cascadia alone deserves a bit more respect than we give it so I doubt I was 'slandering their ability to be rational' when I said we don't take these things seriously.
- oooyay 2y agoCome to Portland. We're due for a massive earthquake and you won't find much in the way of earthquake proofing. My house has straps and when it was renovated some adjustments were made to the structure. Around here, not everyone has that kind of money and our taxes are already incredibly high.
- sqeaky 2y ago> What does it take to convince people to take risks like this seriously? For it to be a bigger risk than other risks actively being worked on. Even a group of millions can only work on so many things at once. The Lower Midwest and the Dixie region of this country have: Gun violence, Racist violence, Tornadoes, some have hurricanes, military service as a key means of social uplift, systemic poverty, low health care rates, lower life expectancy, dubious educational outcomes. All of those kill people every year. When was the last earthquake fatality in the Nidwest? Killer bees kill something like a person per decade, far more than earthquakes (in the discussed regions), and no one thinks those are serious problem.
- b112 2y agoThere are earthquakes on the Canadian shield, and the reasoning is that it is due to Earth deformation recovery. Essentially, the ice age's massive glaciers deformed the ground, and it is slowly rebounding over 1000s of years. The result is minor tremors, sometimes larger quakes. I am in southern Quebec, and there is a LOT of water here. Personally, I suspect there are glaciers underground which are still thawing, which would also cause additional land movement. Some supporting thoughts... * one year, after a lot of snow (record snowfall, where some people's 1st story windows were covered entirely), it took until July for all the snow to melt. This was in areas around my house, and in my forest, where sun didn't shine. * if you look into how we used to store ice for the summer, we'd cut it out of lakes in massive blocks (eg, Lake Ontario or some such), and then store it in warehouses covered with sawdust. Such ice was even used residentially, delivered every once in a while, and used in a refrigerator like 'ice box'. This ice would last the whole summer, it takes time for that much mass to melt, especially with some insulation. Which is what underground glaciers have... they're insulated. Even a decade ago, we'd see -40C regularly here in Jan and Feb, which would counter 40C in the summer I suspect. Anyhow, this could all be simple post-ice age land reformation.
- mjhay 2y agoThere's not underground glaciers. Glaciers are always on the surface, and flow due to gravity. You're thinking of permafrost (which can form wedges and lenses of pure ice). Deeper permafrost responds slowly, but on the flip side of that, there never would have been deep permafrost in S. Quebec during the last glacial maximum. The permafrost situation also wouldn't affect isostatic rebound much, because the amount of water in the ground wouldn't change appreciably. A rule of thumb is that only the first two meters of ground responds appreciably to annual variability, which also means that only the very near surface temperatures have the possibility of affecting snowmelt. Thus, any remaining deep permafrost would have almost no effect. It's too much of an insulating overcoat to allow for meaningful heat flux on those timescales.
- austin-cheney 2y agoIt looks like earthquakes can occur irrespective of fault lines and still be quite large and that fault lines can occur without earthquakes of concern. https://www.beg.utexas.edu/texnet-cisr/fault-maps https://www.beg.utexas.edu/texnet-cisr/fault-maps
- thomas642daniel 2y ago[dead]
- lenerdenator 2y ago> In Tennessee, jurisdictions can decide whether to opt in to building codes with earthquake provisions, while other states — like Missouri — don’t have state-wide building codes at all, though there are efforts to change that. I live on the other side of the state from New Madrid and can tell you, there's a 0% chance the Missouri state legislature passes a bill requiring earthquake proofing of buildings. You'd have an unending stream of people from outstate explaining how their little country town just can't afford to meet such codes, that it's government overreach, that the next quake could be hundreds of years from now... it'd never end. They're far, far more likely to pass a law saying cities like Kansas City and St. Louis can't force seismic-aware building codes on citizens.
- losvedir 2y agoI lived for a couple years in New Madrid county (pro tip for anyone reading: it's pronounced with the stress on the first syllable with an "a" like apple, btw), and I think this is right. But the people are also not entirely wrong: it's dreadfully poor, so adding extra cost to buildings for something that might happen in the next 50 years is a tough sell. I think people safe and sound and wealthy in California aren't really familiar with the perspective I saw there. It's like, what's the worst that can happen? You die? Tragedy and death are kind of expected and built in. People are generally very religious, a good number of people are in the military or at least have absorbed the idea that it's valorous to die for an ideal, and besides that are poor and don't really have health insurance and are accustomed to the the lingering idea of dying somewhat young. Before we even talk about building code for earthquakes, let's remember that a whole bunch of people are living in trailers or double-wides in a relatively active tornado zone! One of my wife's colleagues died in a tornado while we were there and it was scary and horrible. And there are no basements because the water table is so high, so even moderately sturdier construction like our apartment is still honestly a little dicey. Several times my wife and I were huddled in our bathroom wearing bicycle helmets and a mattress draped over us with the tornado sirens sounding. Nature is scary and ultimately it feels like there's just limits to what poor Southeastern Missouri can afford to do about it.
- vundercind 2y agoIt’s true. Jefferson City’s favorite things are: 1) telling the two cities that are most of the state’s economy that they can’t have nice things, and 2) reversing successful ballot initiatives when the voters try to have nice things.
- pfannkuchen 2y agoThis stereotype of people in “flyover states” as being uneducated and dense really needs to stop. EDIT Reader heads experiencing flyover - read: "The struggle to understand why sunrises happen in America's heartland"
- dylan604 2y agoYeah, there's plenty of under educated folks on either coast too.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> stereotype of people in “flyover states” as being uneducated and dense really needs to stop Was going to point out that this is in Missouri, but it turns out Missouri is smack in the middle of the pack when it comes to educational attainment [1]. T he states and territories with the lowest rate of high-school diplomas are Puerto Rico, California, Texas, Mississippi and Louisiana. (Bachelor's: W. Virginia, Mississippi, Arkansas. Advanced: Puerto Rico, Mississippi, Arkansas.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_and_territories_by_educational_attainment#U.S._territories https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_and_territ...
- sqeaky 2y agoHaving Lived in the Midwest and CA, I strongly suspect this is some kind of artifact of CA doing something better. Either schools in CA are harder as in teaching much more, CA is counting more kids, CA is failing kids who didn't academically succeed, or MO might not be tracking kids from certain areas, MO might be pushing kids along and passing them out when they don't know the material. It could be as simple as when schools lose track of a kid CA might default to "did not graduate" and MO defaults to "don't care not tracking". Live in each place for a week and tell me the average education level in the lower midwest is on par. I know that one person isn't a statistical sample, but it is so easy to reproduce and so many people have done it seeing the same results.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago
- SeanLuke 2y agoFracking is believed to be a major source of (minor) earthquakes. This article didn't even mention it.
- DolphinAsa 2y agouh is it ? Doesn't america have an active super volcano?
- adolph 2y agoDr. Jacob Lowenstern, research geologist and Scientist-in-Charge at the Yellowstone Volcano Observatory, says that Yellowstone is currently a dormant volcano, with low levels of unrest. https://education.nationalgeographic.org/resource/when-sleeping-giant-awakes/ https://education.nationalgeographic.org/resource/when-sleep...
- readthenotes1 2y agoI have relatives in West Tennessee, and they claim their area has "rolling hills"--gentle swells like the earth moved in waves before resettling (unlike the author's claim of "flat as Kansas"--though maybe hen only saw the farms and didn't realize the geoengineering). Old folk there claim they use that metaphor because that's not metaphorical, but actual what happened in 1811/12. The Arkansas side is flatter, but possibly because that's mostly in the Mississippi River's ambit (until you reach Crowley's Ridge. The article shows a picture of the mirror structure on the east side of the Mississippi called Chickasaw Bluffs which is very close to the current course of the river)