3 ms·
> But the machine remains useful for extracting confessions. [...] Despite a growing body of evidence, including hundreds of exonerations based on DNA evidence,
by Terr_ 2y ago
> But the machine remains useful for extracting confessions. [...] Despite a growing body of evidence, including hundreds of exonerations based on DNA evidence, most people don’t believe in false confessions.
Arguably the bigger/worse false belief right there.
> First the exam makes you doubt or forget your memories. Then, by forcing you to re-access them again and again under stress, it literally rewrites them.
To some extent this happens naturally, so if the questioner really wants accuracy, you won't force people to re-access the memory for no good reason.
- Netcob 2y agoThere is an entire little ecosystem/subculture around "repressed memories" doing a lot of harm to vulnerable people. Basically you go to a "therapist", they do some sort of hypnosis/interview session where they ask you a lot of very leading questions, and then you leave having been convinced that your family or a satanic cult abused you as a kid (or in some cases that you have been abducted by aliens). The person performing this interview might not even be aware they are doing anything wrong, to them those leading questions ("Do you see anyone else in the room with you? Look closer, are you sure?") may just be how you get to the truth.
- denton-scratch 2y ago> (or in some cases that you have been abducted by aliens) Really? There are therapists who will try to convince you that you were abducted by aliens?
- nemomarx 2y agoI don't think anymore, but in the last century there were several cases of therapists using hypnosis to unlock "repressed memories" of alien abductions. They usually wrote up books about it for profit.
- RIMR 2y agoNot specifically, but they will follow the absurd path of asking you leading questions until you convince yourself that you were abducted by aliens, and then being quacks will decide that their methodology couldn't be wrong, and so they validate your own invented beliefs no matter how stupid. If it keeps you coming back for another session, they'll keep doing it, even if they know the whole process is bullshit.
- ttyprintk 2y agoThis is thoroughly studied by psychologists. I feel obligated to tell you that multiple therapists have used access to repressed memories to control their patients. A large, highly organized religious movement overtly claims that its alien teachings are supported by repressed memories.