3 ms·
No one seemed to have an issue with it a couple years ago. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Durham_special_counsel_investigation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dur
by ceejayoz 2y ago
No one seemed to have an issue with it a couple years ago.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Durham_special_counsel_investigation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Durham_special_counsel_investi...
There's a reason Thomas's concurrence is separate from the majority opinion; even the other five conservative justices didn't support the theory.
- tomohawk 2y agoI think if you look more deeply at the history of special counsels, you will see that this issue has been raised before and dealt with differently in different cases. Besides which, a litigant would need to raise this issue in court for it to be litigated. If this particular issue does come before SCOTUS, then we'll see how the justices rule.
- ceejayoz 2y ago> If this particular issue does come before SCOTUS, then we'll see how the justices rule. We got a pretty decent preview. Thomas's concurrence pretty clearly indicates he tried to get them to sign on to the concept during deliberation; its separate existence also indicates he was unsuccessful at convincing them. I don't see much in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_counsel#Current_regulations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_counsel#Current_regula... that supports your claim that this has been adjudicated any time recently. Care to highlight a case?
- raincom 2y agoFive conservative justices were being 'conservative' in not joining Thomas' concurrence, as that issue was not before the court. The moment this issue comes before SCOTUS, you can expect more concurrences from these five conservative justices.
- skissane 2y ago> There's a reason Thomas's concurrence is separate from the majority opinion; even the other five conservative justices didn't support the theory. You wrongly assume the only reason they didn’t concur with Thomas’ arguments is because they think they are incorrect. There is another possible explanation: whatever they may think of Thomas’ arguments, they may have thought it better to leave discussion of that issue out of the majority opinion, given it wasn’t part of the questions presented for them to decide in the immediate case, and it wasn’t fully ventilated in the briefs and arguments and the record below. It isn’t impossible, despite not joining him in his concurrence, some or all of them might end up agreeing with him if they were presented with a case directly on that topic (which may indeed now happen)