4 ms·
Judge dismisses classified documents case against Donald Trump
- peacechance 2y ago[flagged]
- dang 2y agoYou can't post like this here. Please don't do it again. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- ceejayoz 2y ago> In a ruling Monday, Cannon said the appointment of special counsel Jack Smith violated the Constitution. Taking Justice Thomas's bait from the Trump v. US opinions (https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/23pdf/23-939_e2pg.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/23pdf/23-939_e2pg.pdf, page 52), it would appear.
- tomohawk 2y agoTo summarize. An officer cannot be appointed by the executive (president or his disignates) unless congress passes a law authorizing the position(s). Congress passed no such law to allow this special prosecutor to be appointed. Absent that, the only other way to appoint someone is to get senate confirmation via the appointments clause. The president didn't seek this confirmation for the special prosecutor. This is a very important check on the president's power. The current president basically hired a private attorney without authorization and sic'd him on his political enemy. EDIT: Those of you downvoting - why are you against the rule of law? The law on this is very clear, and this issue about this special prosecutor has been known for years.
- bediger4000 2y agoAre you kidding?
- ceejayoz 2y agoNo one seemed to have an issue with it a couple years ago. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Durham_special_counsel_investigation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Durham_special_counsel_investi... There's a reason Thomas's concurrence is separate from the majority opinion; even the other five conservative justices didn't support the theory.
- tomohawk 2y agoI think if you look more deeply at the history of special counsels, you will see that this issue has been raised before and dealt with differently in different cases. Besides which, a litigant would need to raise this issue in court for it to be litigated. If this particular issue does come before SCOTUS, then we'll see how the justices rule.
- ceejayoz 2y ago> If this particular issue does come before SCOTUS, then we'll see how the justices rule. We got a pretty decent preview. Thomas's concurrence pretty clearly indicates he tried to get them to sign on to the concept during deliberation; its separate existence also indicates he was unsuccessful at convincing them. I don't see much in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_counsel#Current_regulations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special_counsel#Current_regula... that supports your claim that this has been adjudicated any time recently. Care to highlight a case?
- raincom 2y agoFive conservative justices were being 'conservative' in not joining Thomas' concurrence, as that issue was not before the court. The moment this issue comes before SCOTUS, you can expect more concurrences from these five conservative justices.
- skissane 2y ago> There's a reason Thomas's concurrence is separate from the majority opinion; even the other five conservative justices didn't support the theory. You wrongly assume the only reason they didn’t concur with Thomas’ arguments is because they think they are incorrect. There is another possible explanation: whatever they may think of Thomas’ arguments, they may have thought it better to leave discussion of that issue out of the majority opinion, given it wasn’t part of the questions presented for them to decide in the immediate case, and it wasn’t fully ventilated in the briefs and arguments and the record below. It isn’t impossible, despite not joining him in his concurrence, some or all of them might end up agreeing with him if they were presented with a case directly on that topic (which may indeed now happen)
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> why are you against the rule of law? Does the AG need Congressional approval every time he hires a secretary? There are two sets of principles of the rule of law in conflict [1]. On one hand, you are correct in Cannon’s argument being supported by “consistency (no contradictory laws)” and the “protection of individual rights.” But in throwing out precedent she discards “consistency (no contradictory laws)” and “certainty (certainty of application for a given situation).” Where the balance tips for me is in her violating the most core tenet of the rule of law, that no man is above the law, something she has been dinged for in the past [2]. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rule_of_law https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rule_of_law [2] https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/23323385/trump-ca11-2022-12-01.pdf https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/23323385/trump-ca11-2...
- tomohawk 2y agoOf course not - congress has passed a law creating the DoJ, etc. That is not what is going on here. An attorney has been appointed with extraordinary powers to a position that is not created as part of the DoJ. It hasn't been authorized by any law.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> attorney has been appointed with extraordinary powers to a position that is not created as part of the DoJ What powers does a Special Counsel have that any DoJ prosecutor doesn’t that injure the defendant? The defining characteristic of a special prosecutor is they can’t be fired—that injures the President and AG.
- tomohawk 2y agoEDIT: since you edited your post after I responded, I'll try to respond to your edit. It is Biden who believes he's above the law. He has consistently bragged about it, for example, in flouting decisions saying he has no authority to forgive student loans. It is Biden who is not following the law here. I'm sure this will be appealed, and maybe in a few years, if we're lucky, the law will be made clearer.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- AnimalMuppet 2y agoHmm. Not much detail there. Is the ruling that special counsels violate the Constitution, or just that this one did? I predict an appeal...
- ksherlock 2y ago"The Appointments Clause sets as a default rule that all “Officers of the United States”—whether “inferior” or “principal”—must be appointed by the President and confirmed by the Senate. Id. It then goes on to direct that “Congress may by Law vest the Appointment of such inferior Officers, as they think proper, in the President alone, in the Courts of Law, or in Heads of Departments.”" It would apply to all special counsels unless confirmed by the Senate (or congress passes a law allowing the Attorney General to appoint special counsel)
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Is the ruling that special counsels violate the Constitution, or just that this one did? The Ethics in Government Act did expire in 1999 [1]. But I’d think that just means Smith reports to Garland and Biden, versus having the autonomy he had before. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethics_in_Government_Act https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethics_in_Government_Act
- bediger4000 2y agoThis is a farce. If you've ever had a clearance you know those documents were improperly removed from some secure facility, stored wrong, and possessed illegally. If you or I had even 1 box like that, we'd be in jail One justice system for the powerful, another harsher system for the rest of us. Couldn't be plainer.
- taylodl 2y agoYep. If you or I had done what Trump has done we'd be busting rocks at Leavenworth. Trump is the Deep State - one set of rules for them, another set for us.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> If you've ever had a clearance you know those documents were improperly removed from some secure facility, stored wrong, and possessed illegally Classification was created by executive order [1]. There is a legitimate question as to whether the President is covered because, at the end of the day, whether something is classified is up to them. (Trump removed the material while still President.) Unfortunately, we never got there. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classified_information_in_the_United_States https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classified_information_in_th...
- rootusrootus 2y agoClassification authority derives from the executive but the president himself does not exercise it directly. But assuming for a moment he could -- did Trump scribble out the classification on these documents, to at least make it seem like he declassified them? Also, when did he transport them to his compound? Was he still president at the time? Former presidents do not have the legal right to declassify anything at all.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> did Trump scribble out the classification on these documents, to at least make it seem like he declassified them? No. But it’s an open question if him thinking it changes their classification. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ > when did he transport them to his compound? Was he still president at the time? He removed them from the White House before Biden was sworn in.
- throw_that_away 2y ago[flagged]
- ricktdotorg 2y agoif you are suggesting that the FBI brought in papers and planted them in the Mar-a-Lago photos, presumably in an attempt to frame Trump, you should provide sources. please point us to the well-documented sources.
- throw_that_away 2y agohttps://www.politico.com/news/2024/05/03/mar-a-lago-trump-classified-documents-00156124 https://www.politico.com/news/2024/05/03/mar-a-lago-trump-cl... >Smith’s team revealed in the filing that FBI agents carried printed “classified cover sheets” during the Aug. 8, 2022, search of Trump’s Mar-a-Lago estate and used them to replace any classified documents they discovered in cardboard Bankers Boxes that littered the former president’s residence.
- ceejayoz 2y agoBecause you don't want a direct photo of a top-secret document laying around, they cover it and document it as such. (There were even so many to cover they had to make extras, which because they were hand-made, didn't get removed as is apparently the norm during processing.) > “The investigative team used classified cover sheets for that purpose, until the FBI ran out because there were so many classified documents, at which point the team began using blank sheets with handwritten notes indicating the classification level of the document(s) seized,” the prosecutors wrote. > “Any handwritten sheets that currently remain in the boxes do not represent additional classified documents — they were just not removed when the classified cover sheets with the index code were added,” Smith’s team wrote. “In many but not all instances, the FBI was able to determine which document with classification markings corresponded to a particular placeholder sheet.” Your article does not assert what you claim.
- 2y ago
- cheese_van 2y agoI'm ok with this decision. In my 3 decades experience of being responsible for handling and storing classified, including comsec material, no one goes to jail for mishandling classified. The only exceptions to this case might be personnel who fall under UCMJ as the military does things differently - and I have seen that. All others? Civilians? Might lose their job, might be censured, might lose a promotion opportunity - but no one goes to jail. In fact, the only time jail is threatened, is when the incident is IN ADDITION to other charges, often related to espionage. Frankly, the cases of people accidentally mishandling classified, accidentally taking it home, improper storage etc. are very, very, common and are simply dismissed with minor (or major) implications but never imprisonment. The violation's charges are so subject to selective (and subjective use) that I would be uncomfortable with selectively employing it in cases so fraught with partisan politics.
- ceejayoz 2y agohttps://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2022/12/22/trump-classified-prosecutions-mar-a-lago/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2022/12/22/... > In Kansas City, a former FBI analyst pleaded guilty in October to taking home more than 300 classified files or documents, including highly sensitive material about al-Qaeda and an associate of Osama bin Laden. She faces up to 10 years in prison. In Massachusetts, a defense contractor pleaded guilty in 2019 to removing classified national defense information from his office and storing it at home. He got 18 months. > And in Maryland, Harold Martin, a former government contractor, took home a huge number of hard and digital copies of classified materials — the equivalent of 500 million pages — though he never shared it with anyone. He is midway through a nine-year prison sentence. "Frankly, the cases of people accidentally mishandling classified, accidentally taking it home, improper storage etc. are very, very, common and are simply dismissed with minor (or major) implications but never imprisonment." It's alleged that Trump knowingly kept and concealed them despite repeated demands to return them. From Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_prosecution_of_Donald_Trump_(classified_documents_case) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_prosecution_of_Donald_...): > Trump certified that he was returning all the remaining documents on June 3, 2022, but the FBI later obtained evidence that he had intentionally moved documents to hide them from his lawyers and the FBI and thus had not fulfilled the subpoena.
- rootusrootus 2y agoI am not sure this is a win politically. It takes a lot of the wind out of the persecution argument he has been making. I am also not sure this is a win legally. Dismissed on a technicality, not on the merits, is the weakest way to win a case. More than likely it is a delay, not a resolution.
- skissane 2y agoIf the argument that there is a flaw in the special prosecutor's appointment ultimately ends up being upheld on appeal–and there's no guarantee it will be–there is a solution that may save the case: appoint a new special prosecutor, using a different procedure that answers the constitutional infirmities of the previous appointment. That said, it is unclear whether a new special prosecutor would be allowed to resume the case at the same point, or be forced to re-run earlier parts of it – but I suspect judicial economy would favour resumption over repetition. Also, if it becomes necessary to seek Congressional approval for a new appointment, the current partisan division in Congress may make such approval difficult to achieve. If it is an appointment requiring Senate confirmation, it may be possible for Democrats to push it through on party lines even without any Republican cooperation – but that assumes no conservative Democrats (such as Manchin) defect. But if it also requires appropriations, it may be much harder to get the needed appropriations through the Republican-controlled House. And of course, whichever way the appeal goes, there is the very real risk this delays the case until after the November election, and if he wins, it may lead to the case being suspended on constitutional grounds, and likely eventually dismissed There's also some debate about whether this decision, if upheld on appeal, might also lead to the overturn of Hunter Biden's convictions – https://www.newsweek.com/aileen-cannon-trump-case-dismissal-hunter-biden-1925373 https://www.newsweek.com/aileen-cannon-trump-case-dismissal-... – however, it appears possibly not, since the special counsel in the Biden case is concurrently serving as a Senate-confirmed US attorney; whereas, although Jack Smith never actually held such a role; at the time of his appointment, he did not hold any Senate-confirmed position, since he actually had been an employee of the Government of Kosovo (as a war crimes prosecutor) immediately prior to his special counsel appointment; previously, he had been a DOJ attorney, but never held a Senate-confirmed position.
- nashashmi 2y agoReading the actual order, the most pertinent part is on page 3 https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/24807232-judge-dismisses-trump-documents-case https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/24807232-judge-dismi... In summary it says special prosecutor smith should have been approved by congress, plus given a budget by congress because he is an inferior official. And the special prosecutor does not seemingly hold a principal official position that would avoid congressional approval. My take: the court is being incredibly strict on following the formality of the law in this case. And is not skipping the process in the case of a highly sensitive matter like classified documents. This is rule for the rich and famous. And I don’t think this kind of strictness would have been applied on random joes.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]