3 ms·
> rings true to me The problem with complex macroeconomics and popular politics summarized in one phrase.
by guelo 14y ago
> rings true to me
The problem with complex macroeconomics and popular politics summarized in one phrase.
- jlgreco 14y agoI wonder if we are best served by a democracy when, with perhaps the most important political issue there is, common sense and anecdotes provide little value and a higher education in a particular field is required to make an informed decision.
- guelo 14y agoWell, that was the reason for the creation of the Fed in the first place, the idea that you could have technocrats setting macroeconomics policy without political influence. But then Allan Greenspan happened, an ideologue disciple of Ayn Rand. When the federal budget was running a surplus in 2000 he told congress that budget surpluses were dangerous, then he pushed for Bush's tax cuts and then he helped inflate real estate and ignored everybody that was saying it was an out of control bubble. So no, unelected elites aren't going to save us either.
- rubashov 14y agoThe Fed was founded because in fly-over country the financial system was rickety. Off the coasts, banks were regularly going bust and taking people's savings with them. This almost always happened during harvest season when demand for currency was high. In the urban centers the banking system was working fine. The problem to solve was a ridiculously inefficient and inept banking sector in large swathes of the country. As soon as the idea of some sort of federal level reform got going the House Of Morgan and friends seized control and the Fed became a tool of the major banks, which were already working fine, to increase their profits and control. Almost from the start it was the case the Federal Reserve Bank of New York really ran the system, which was entirely not the original idea. The idea of the Fed originated from a temporary problem unique to a particular period of American history, but was immediately usurped by clever power and money hungry people.
- aggronn 14y agoThat was, in an antiquated sense, the premise behind the US being born a republic. Not macroeconomics in particular, but insofar as it is a compromise between technocracy and majority rule and self determination. Philosophers and political theorist have been struggling with this since before Plato's Republic. Its a very very real question, though the consensus that democracy is the best thing we've got has been building for centuries.
- rubashov 14y agoFor calling the last three recessions surveys did better than economists' forecasts. You see similar results for forecasting and reporting current price inflation. I don't really buy that the common American man is an idiot. "Elites" have pushed most idiotic economic and foreign policy initiatives against the popular will. Americans have generally had to be tricked by lies and expensive PR campaigns into supporting wars, for example. Their initial judgments were sound.