4 ms·
> but I can guarantee that google's systems read and aggregated data inside your private docs ages ago That is how search works, yes. But if you’re trying to
by Aurornis 2y ago
> but I can guarantee that google's systems read and aggregated data inside your private docs ages ago
That is how search works, yes.
But if you’re trying to imply that everyone’s private data was scraped and loaded into their LLM, then no, that’s obviously a conspiracy theory.
It’s incredible to me that people think Google has convinced tens of thousands of engineers to quietly keep secret an epic conspiracy theory about abusing everyone’s private data.
- psychoslave 2y ago> that’s obviously a conspiracy theory. Well, while some of our fellow humans are far too quick to jump on concluding that everything and the rest comes from some conspiracy, it shouldn't void the existence of any conspiracy as an extreme opposite. In that case, whether these actors do it or not is almost irrelevant: they have the means and incentives to do so. What safeguard civil society is putting in place to avoid it to happen is a far more interesting matter.
- zarathustreal 2y agoTo riff on the famous Upton Sinclair quote: “It is difficult to get an engineer to see something, when his salary depends on his not seeing it.”
- fifteen1506 2y ago> It’s incredible to me that people think Google has convinced tens of thousands of engineers to quietly keep secret an epic conspiracy theory about abusing everyone’s private data. With NDA being all over the place, it does strike me as doable. NDAs should have a time limit. Additionally, no-one in their right mind will be a whistleblower nowadays.
- digitalsushi 2y agoisn't that it's supposed to work? we just need >0 people to blow a whistle if a whistle needs blowing. we don't need to rely on the people fearing for their jobs so long as >0 people are willing to sacrifice their careers/lives when there's some injustice so great it's worth dying for
- fifteen1506 2y agoYa, no. Sludge in a hole in your shop's backyard? Not worth it. High level of chemicals in the air which may cause stillborns? Not worth it. Scanning private files for an AI training? Not worth it. Genocide? Not worth it. There is absolutely nothing nowadays worth being banished from your livelihood. Snowden and Assange are heroes. And insane. Threw away $$$ for their morals. Stanislav Petrov threw his career away instead of passing it up and let it be somebody's else problem.
- dmvdoug 2y agoI dunno, bro, software engineers have repeatedly shown total lack of wider judgment in these contexts over the years. Not to say there is, in fact, some kind of “epic conspiracy,” just that SWEs appear not to take much time to consider just what it is their code ends up being used for. Incidentally, that would be one way to start to get out of the mess we’ve found ourselves in: start holding SWEs accountable for their work. You work on privacy-destroying projects that society pushes back against, it’s fair game to put you under the microscope. Perhaps not legally, but we as a society shouldn’t hold back from directed criticism and social accountability for the individual engineers who enable this kind of shit. That will not be a popular take here. Perhaps it will be some solace to know I advocated the same kind of accountability for lawyers who enabled torture and other governmental malfeasance in the GWoT years. I was also looked at askance by other lawyers for daring to suggest such a thing. In that way, SWEs remind me of lawyers in how they view their own work. “What, I’m not personally responsible for what my client chooses to use my services for.” Yeah, you are, actually.
- f6v 2y agoI was hanging out around startup incubators, and, by extension, many wantrepreneurs. When asked about business model, the knee jerk reaction was usually “we’re going to sell data!” regardless of product. I was appalled by how hard it is to keep founders from abusing the data when I worked at startups. GDPR and the likes are seen as an annoyance and they make every effort to find a loophole.
- hulitu 2y ago> that’s obviously a conspiracy theory. Of course. Google (and Apple, Microsoft not so much - but it is for your own good) will deny that they store your encryption keys.