3 ms·
The original arrangement was that the seperate and independant States|Colonies were seperate and independant States|Colonies working together in a collective Un
by defrost 2y ago
The original arrangement was that the seperate and independant States|Colonies were seperate and independant States|Colonies working together in a collective Union that wouldn't overrule or take away from the seperate and individual State|Colony part.
Like a neighbourhood action group, or twelve distinct farming families working together on an agricultural Bulk Harvesting collective, etc.
The decisions of the collective were to be made (hey, check the paperwork, it's still around) on a weighted vote per State basis .. it was never the case that if one member bred exponentially and had way more kids than all the others put together then that member State would get all the decision making power.
Clearly time has marched on and people now think of The United States of America as a single country .. it's not, nor is the European Union.
But maybe it is time to update the paperwork and common rules?
- krapp 2y agoThe paperwork and common rules were updated after the dissolution of the Continental Congress in 1789. But it seems a few people still haven't gotten the memo.
- mrguyorama 2y ago>The original arrangement was ... The original arrangement was the articles of confederation, and explicitly weak federal government which was made as a loose federation of fairly powerful states, each allowed to mostly do their own thing, with a federal government that did as little as possible. It didn't even make it ten years before it would have died. The Constitution of the United States was written entirely to give the Federal government actual power and control and teeth. It was very clear that signing up to the United States meant individual states significantly giving away their power. That's why the constitution had so many extreme compromises, especially to slave states. The US constitution entirely exists to codify the US being one nation.
- frugalmail 2y agoThat's false, the US constitution exists to very explicitly protect peoples rights, states rights and prevent the country degenerating into a tyranny.
- frugalmail 2y agoSo you think something like New York and Los Angeles should make all the decisions? Essentially, all new government spending benefits them, at the expense of even cities in that state, not to mention other states?
- defrost 2y agoYour first question asks something that I haven't thought or expressed. Your second questions appears to be more of a statement with a question mark at the end.