3 ms·
Sweden, France, California, Washington state and NYC have discovered once again that taxing the heck out of rich people causes them to leave. And when they lea
by WalterBright 2y ago
Sweden, France, California, Washington state and NYC have discovered once again that taxing the heck out of rich people causes them to leave.
And when they leave, they take their spend/invest/hire money with them.
- FrustratedMonky 2y agoSure. If you can move to another state to live cheaper, why wouldn't people. That is the argument for a more nationally consistent tax code, so the 'rich' can't just game the system by moving to the one cheap state where they bought off the politicians. And same goes internationally, if all countries would enact laws against money laundering, or at least enforce it, then the rich wouldn't so easily move their money around. Just because they can avoid taxes doesn't mean it is the governments fault for having taxes.
- kjksf 2y agoOr maybe it's an argument for allowing states to try different economic strategies and compete for business based on outcomes of those strategies. If California taxes people and businesses at insane levels, maybe we shouldn't replicate insane level of taxation everywhere else in U.S., on the off chance that it is not, in fact, an optimal level for generating wealth for the people. Maybe Texas and Florida should be allowed to enact competing taxation schemes so that we can see which one is better. And maybe Americans should have a freedom of movement within U.S. without having their private property confiscated by the state when they try to leave. The justification for taxation based on residency is that you use commons like roads and school and police that the government funds so you need to contribute to funding those things. What exactly is justifications for hitting people with more taxes when they try to leave the state?
- arrosenberg 2y ago> If California taxes people and businesses at insane levels, maybe we shouldn't replicate insane level of taxation everywhere else in U.S., on the off chance that it is not, in fact, an optimal level for generating wealth for the people. This is nonsense. California is the strongest state in the union economically, with one of the highest quality of life and income per capita. We have an affordability crisis that is related to the topic at hand - billionaires hoarding wealth and driving up the cost of living - but that's a national problem that California can't solve on it's own. Our taxes pay for the things that enable our success - roads, power, dams, parks, libraries, and all that other good stuff. Meanwhile Floridians can't use their beaches due to red tide and dumping tires in the water. The people of Houston JUST got their power back yesterday a week after a mere Category 1 hurricane. Maybe they should raise some taxes and do something about that so their cities stop losing economic productivity multiple times a year...
- WalterBright 2y agohttps://www.statsamerica.org/sip/rank_list.aspx?rank_label=pcpi1 https://www.statsamerica.org/sip/rank_list.aspx?rank_label=p...
- arrosenberg 2y agoCalifornia is the 4th highest state in income per capita, which supports my statement. Thanks :)
- WalterBright 2y agoIts tax collections are going down despite increasing taxes. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/QTAXTOTALQTAXCAT3CANO https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/QTAXTOTALQTAXCAT3CANO
- arrosenberg 2y agoThat line is trending upward. Collections are down because the economy cooled after Q2 2022 due to the end of zero-percent interest rates. Again, something beyond the control of the state government.
- throwaway7ahgb 2y agoAnother view: 1) California is so popular because it has beautiful weather and natural resources. A group of monkeys could govern the state into prosperity. 2) California has also had the highest number of power outages amongst all states.
- arrosenberg 2y agoWe can stay #1 is conclusively false - we let Ronald Reagan and Pete Wilson run the state and we still haven't fully recovered from the damage. A competent group of monkeys would still need similar tax revenues to what we currently collect to be prosperous.
- FrustratedMonky 2y agoI missed it, I don't see anywhere in this thread where people are being taxed on 'exit' from a state. Nothing is being confiscated. What is happening is that a state increases taxes on the current population, and the rich leave to a cheaper states so they don't have to pay the higher tax. So there is freedom of movement. But this does open a loop whole where they can use up resources, then split. To your argument. I guess it depends on 'fairness'. Sure, the deep south can 'Choose' to lower taxes and have really bad schools so that their un-educated population will be unaware, and un-questioning, of any risks when they to go work for the local chemical company or paper mill. This is a valid choice, lets make our people cannon fodder to lure large chemical companies to our state, (and bonus get some kick backs). But, the kids didn't choose this, they were born into it. (which maybe is why they are also anti-abortion, we can't loose our workforce). There should be some national standards to keep some states from a race to the bottom.
- throwaway7ahgb 2y agoThe 'State' here is confounded. The State also refers to USA. If you give up citizenship and leave the US, they will tax you on exit. It's ridiculous. I should be able to give up citizenship or move to another country and pay a cent to the US government.
- danaris 2y agoIs it a valid choice? It's a choice being made to limit someone else's access to resources and information, after all, including the kind of information that would give them the tools they need to understand how much you're screwing them over.
- pseudocomposer 2y agoWould this not be easily solved with a one-time 50-90% wealth tax when they exfiltrate their money from the place where others earned it for them, rather than the ~1% annual wealth tax they want to leave over?
- dexterdog 2y agoBecause most will leave as soon as the law is announced before it becomes law in that case.
- ryandrake 2y agoOK, so make it retroactive on the day the law was passed. Laws are words written on paper, it's not like dark wizardry. These kinds of objections always come up. "But, rich people are oh so clever, and they will exploit loopholes in any law that gets written!" Well, write stronger laws. Don't include exceptions. Lawmakers need to think more than 5 minutes about what kinds of options/resources are available to people, and how those people might game their way into getting around the spirit of the law.
- WalterBright 2y ago> OK, so make it retroactive on the day the law was passed Ex post facto laws are illegal. Even so, you might get the taxes once, before they leave. That's not a plan for a future.
- ryandrake 2y agoFirst up, ex post facto clauses have been interpreted as applying to criminal laws only. AFAIK there exists no constitutional bar to retroactive tax legislation. The same may be true for states. And, It's not like they're all going to leave. Sure, a few grumpy ideologues like Musk will Go Galt and move away, but it's not like everyone subject to the tax is going to suddenly leave. People have been predicting the demise of California, New York, and so on forever, yet somehow, they have not all moved to Texas yet, and we still have plenty of high-earning taxpayers here. Maybe they like clean air and a functioning power grid, I don't know.
- infinitezest 2y agoThere is also the upside of them taking their lobbying dollars with them.
- WalterBright 2y agoThe USSR did not have lobbyists nor wealthy people. Didn't work out too well for the commoners.
- rvrs 2y agoAh yes California, Washington, NYC — places where rich people famously do not live
- WalterBright 2y agoAll have seen an exodus of rich people, mostly leaving for Texas and Florida, which are booming. Musk famously decamped from California to Texas. Bezos from Washington to Florida.
- jmward01 2y agoA statement like this probably needs a source or two to first show it is true (wealth taxes actually are causing rich people to flee) second, show that they actually do take their spend/invest/hire money with them and finally that it is harmful that that happens. Leaving creates a vacuum and if the rich really are leaving then it would be a big vacuum that clearly can't be filled with someone else that is rich since they are all leaving. Without someone big there to fill the vacuum it that implies it is being filled with a lot of smaller companies. This actually sounds like a good thing to me to tell you the truth. Can we emphasize this effect?
- WalterBright 2y agoJeff Bezos famously left the state just before the Washington's new cap gains tax targeted at him was set to go into effect. I know other people with 8 figure fortunes who left, too. I didn't know it was controversial that spending a lot of money in a local economy makes it more prosperous, and when a big spender leaves, the local economy goes down. The Rust Belt is an example of the latter.
- shakow 2y ago> spending a lot of money in a local economy makes it more prosperous Do these people really spend a lot of money in the local economy? Realistically, even assuming they pay a couple dozen people $100k/year for service and indulge daily in 3 $500 meals, what will be the actual influence on the local economy? > The Rust Belt is an example of the latter. The Rust Belt is an example of what happens when the state allows companies to leave, build their gadgets for a tenth of the price across the Pacific, then sell them back home without serious tariffs; not an example of what happens when Mr. Studebaker or Mrs. Bethlehem Steel leave for Florida.
- WalterBright 2y agoZillionaire Paul Allen was famous for spending billions in the local economy. He transformed Seattle. He's passed away, and his projects are being sold off and closed down. > the state allows companies to leave If you have to build a wall around your state to keep people from fleeing, you have failed.
- feedforward 2y agoThe US had a tax rate of over 90% for the wealthy in the 1950s (although with loopholes they could push it lower, like now). Didn't seem to have much of an effect on the wealthy, and the US working class did very well.
- WalterBright 2y agoVery few paid those rates, because there were a large number of tax shelters available. For example, a lot of your personal expenses could be covered by your business. Reagan, as part of the deal to lower the top rates, traded away those tax shelters. The thing about tax shelter investing, however, is they only make sense as a tax shelter. They are poorly performing investments otherwise. A tax policy that encourages poor investments is not a good policy. Keep in mind that the government in the 50s was far, far smaller than it is today. Funding the vast growth in government is inevitably going to get sucked out of the middle class.
- omnimus 2y ago> Keep in mind that the government in the 50s was far, far smaller than it is today. Funding the vast growth in government is inevitably going to get sucked out of the middle class. And where US gov grew? Army. Where that money goes? To few weapon contractors = to ultra rich. Its not like US put those investments in some other pocket than top 10%
- throwaway7ahgb 2y agoThe old top tax rates are constantly echo'd around and not relevant towards any conversation. The only thing that matters is what the effective rate was. They could create a 100% tax bracket but if nobody paid it, it's just words in a book.
- eigart 2y agoDamned if you do, damned if you don’t. To me it looks like a race to the bottom. We have a very nice society, and most people are happy to pay taxes. We also don’t tax rich people more in relative terms, it’s just that it creates a threshold level of wealth where you can choose to move.
- RhysU 2y ago> most people are happy to pay taxes Source? I hate paying taxes.
- eigart 2y agoNo source, it’s just my impression that most Norwegians feel they get a fair deal.
- immibis 2y agoIf you live in America, Republicans made it as difficult as possible with the intention of you hating it. If you live in any other country, you simply get less money than you would have otherwise.
- danpad 2y agothat is simply not true. Try to solve the scenario of earning 10 USD a month via YouTube monetization with your tax domicile being in the Czech Republic while being full-time employed. "Simply get less money" is a vast overstatement.
- throwaway7ahgb 2y agoI lived in London and left after paying 50%+ income on taxes. I also had to get private healthcare because I couldn't wait weeks to see a doctor. So no, it's not just US Republicans, please stop.
- danaris 2y agoThe Tories are very similar in their outlook and practices in many ways.
- carlob 2y agoThis is patently false for the only case I have data on. The wealth tax in France had quadrupled its collections in a time where the French GDP had doubled, and all this was without an exit tax. Unfortunately Macron got rid of it a few years ago and replaced it with something that only applies to real estate.
- omnimus 2y agoThe thing is lots of the ultra rich moved to Luxemburg so this happened and this is going to keep happening. Its same why every tech company has european HQ in Ireland. If it were EU wide it might work somehow but with so many ultra rich high in politics there is no way this could happen. There is always going to be tax haven countries taking advantage of this situations. New French gov will want to reintroduce these taxes but i think they have to find different ways.
- carlob 2y agoI don't think you even need the ultra rich high in politics, there is a more mundane explanation: countries are competing against one another to attract the HQs. It's a race to the bottom and it's called fiscal dumping.
- throwaway7ahgb 2y agoIt's kind of amazing when people talk about a tax failing as a bad thing. This leads me to believe that most people want taxes on wealth for punishment and no other reason.
- carlob 2y agoI want wealth taxes for redistribution mostly. So yeah.
- piva00 2y agoSweden has a large ratio of billionaires relative to the rest of the population, and they aren't leaving. It's 14th in the world by number of billionaires, 7th per capita [0]. Rich people here pay a flat 30% tax on capital gains so they usually pay less taxes relative to their income than a salaried person earning >45-50k SEK. There's no wealth tax in Sweden. I don't think you know much about Sweden's tax system (or even in general) given this comment. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_number_of_billionaires https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_number_of...
- immibis 2y agoAnd what's wrong with that? Regular people, not having to compete with rich people, might actually be able to afford stuff.