3 ms·
> we can halt global warming any time we wish with about $5-10b worth of high altitude sulphur injections. Sulfur compounds are just one of several atmospheric
by Aurornis 2y ago
> we can halt global warming any time we wish with about $5-10b worth of high altitude sulphur injections.
Sulfur compounds are just one of several atmospheric aerosols considered, but it's not as simple as this comment would suggest.
For one, the confidence about the ability of atmospheric aerosols (sulfur or otherwise) to halt global warming isn't very high. There are a lot of unknowns and the research is still in the early phases. It's a lot harder to get the aerosols in the right sizes and in the right place in the atmosphere for them to live long enough to do something.
Second, there are downstream effects that need to be understood. Sulfur aerosols can deplete the ozone layer, for example. So maybe we get some short-term wins, but how much of that is offset by ozone layer depletion? Altering the solar dynamics of the upper atmosphere could also dramatically change the way air circulates up there, leading potentially to even more second order effects we don't understand.
It's an interesting topic, but it's not a simple question of coming up with a few billion dollars to halt climate change.
There are no simple solutions, unfortunately. Research should continue, but don't be misled into thinking that the only obstacle is coming up with an amount equivalent to a fraction of a percent of the US budget.
- dr_dshiv 2y agoThere are lots of optimizations, I agree, but we know the mechanisms work because of all the natural experiments (volcanos). We definitely need the research—but no one thinks we don’t do this research because it is too expensive. It’s a third rail—and major litmus test. But it is a bit like the greens being antinuclear. If you really want to preserve biodiversity and prevent massive climate shifts, why make your mechanism of action human morality? “If we can merely engineer our way out of global warming, then humans won’t get what’s surely due.” Something like that, if you know what I mean.