4 ms·
It's not that complicated: If you are collecting donations from people (i.e. they give you something for nothing), then you must not make a profile. If you are
by ars 18y ago
It's not that complicated: If you are collecting donations from people (i.e. they give you something for nothing), then you must not make a profile.
If you are getting your money in other ways, then go for it.
- nirmal 18y agoThey're aren't giving you something for nothing. They are giving you something so you can help the people that the charity benefits. That's the service he (Pallotta) provides.
- ars 18y agoMissed the point. Obviously they want you to use the money that way, but that's the only thing you should use it for, you should not use to get more money. But if you provided a service (not something for nothing), then it's like any other business.
- jd 18y agoIt's not that obvious where to draw the line. Executives of charities need to get paid. And because charities deal with large amounts of money, mismanagement can be very costly. By increasing the salary of the executives you can get more qualified people. As a result, the charity becomes more efficient and effective and everybody's happy. Often charities have billions (?) of capital. If they hire a local private bank to look after the money they will have to pay for it, and the bankers will be driving porches. But if they manage the capital in house they suddenly can't compensate people for it similarly, because they're still a charity? Charity. Raise money: OK Spend money: OK Save money, use part of savings as bonus: Evil? I haven't really thought this through, so my logic could be flawed. Still, I think that most charities should become more business-like. (Good) Businesses are, after all, all about creating value.
- ars 18y agoNo, they are paying people to make more money with investments or whatever - that's fine, do what you want - the money comes from the investment income, it doesn't matter if it's inhouse or out. But if you pay people from donations directly then it's not OK to pay a lot. Are you paying people to get more donations (no good), or are you paying people to make more money in some other way - including by saving you money (...more efficient and effective....), then it's fine. Basically if by paying people you will end up needing to collect less donations - or you use those more effectively, then I'm fine with it. But if you pay people to work on methods of getting more donations in the first place, then I'm not OK with it (if it's excessive, more then a few %) - even if it means you have more money in total.
- shader 18y ago>But if you pay people from donations directly then it's not OK to pay a lot. Unless the donator is aware of the fact that you are paying your employees with the donations, and choose to give anyway. In fact, most large charities have employees who get paid, usually out of donations :). But you don't make your decision based on their management process, but based on the service they provide you; namely aiding some cause on your behalf. You don't decide whether or not to buy a burger at McDonald's based on what percentage of your dollar goes to the CEO, but based on the quality of the service they may provide. Same with charities. If a charity can get away with paying exorbitant amounts to their CEO and still be the best value per dollar, people will donate, and it won't be wrong. Maybe the reason they do so well is that they were able to hire great high level management. However, to convince people that you were going to spend their money one way and then actually spend it another is fraud. If you paid McDonald's for your burger, and they didn't give it to you, you would be within your rights to sue. At the very least you wouldn't go back. So it is with charities. It is perfectly fine if you feel that a particular charity spends too much on management, and therefore decide not to donate your money to them. I realize that you may have been stating your personal opinion as to how you decide which charities you donate to, and that's fine. But to then claim in newspapers or other places that because they don't match your standards they are objectively evil and should be shut down/boycotted is a completely different thing. I think that is more what the article is about.
- ars 18y agoBut I do actually make my decisions based on their management process. Personally if they spend more than 5-10% of the money on administrative expenses I don't donate. And BTW that cuts out the vast majority of the charities, I think (wild guess) that most spend around 50%, and some as high as 75% (police fraternities for example (again, wild guess)). The newspaper example, I think, was more a case of the person not being upfront about it. Also, I personally think that if the charity money did not go to him, it would go somewhere else. So by him consuming 50% of the donations for his own pocket he is reducing the amount of charity money in the world. Others might disagree and say that if he didn't get the donation, no one would. So you might as well allow him to exist. If that's your opinion fine. But I feel that even if the second case is the real one I still am not OK with it (but I think the first one is what actually happens).