3 ms·
Oh man, the tired "Elon cannot sell his stock all at once without crashing the price, hence he does not actually have $200 billion" argument. If he wanted he c
by paulpauper 2y ago
Oh man, the tired "Elon cannot sell his stock all at once without crashing the price, hence he does not actually have $200 billion" argument.
If he wanted he could sell his holdings to an investment bank, maybe at an agreed-upon discount, which would hedge-out the risk and give him close to $200 billion, all without the shares hitting the open market. This is like how a buyout works. It's not like when a founder sells his company does the shares hit the market, but rather it's like changing entries in a database of ownership.
Also ,markets are very liquid, especially for the largest of tech stocks, and can absorb tens of billions of dollars of selling. Bezos sold billions of Amazon and you cannot tell looking at the chart where he sold.
For practical matters, someone who has a billion dollars, unless that wealth is tired up in Rembrandts or something, has much more useable wealth than someone who has $100k.
- ggm 2y agoAside from the wealth, they can leverage the Rembrandt. That working capital freedom they gain, from using the non-cash asset, thats huge.
- mjburgess 2y agoThe issue with market caps is that they assume a demand which is unevidenced by the market. Selling one apple for $5 does not thereby mean you can make $500 if you have a hundred. There is no investment bank with $200bn lying around to give to elon. In order to claim the naive "asset-price/unit * num-units" calculation of net wealth, you have to make often wild and unevidenced assumptions. It's a metic made to inflate the egos to whom it applies, and to justify ragebait headlines, little else.
- ben_w 2y agoI agree with your final paragraph. But how much Musk can make selling off his shares can be much higher or much lower than $200 billion, given that number is based on the, I think the term is "marginal price"? If enthusiastic traders associate that price with Musk's own leadership skills (and his gaffes crashing Tesla's stock price suggests this is a factor), then the companies become much less valuable simply by having forced him to sell. The reverse is true for people who think SpaceX and Tesla would do much better without him. And if Musk is as sincere about Mars and Optimus as I think he is (I think he's wrong, but sincerely so) then he should value each of Tesla and SpaceX in the trillions and believe that the stock market is just undervaluing them.
- hindsightbias 2y agoIf we’d taxed Elon 90% the day he first became a billionaire, where would that money be today? Tesla wouldn’t be worth $400B or whatever. He would not have kept voting control. They have to give him $50B just to keep the stock propped up. So you tax every billionaire $900M and all that stock ends up in some hedge fund that says “your battery factory will cost $5B!? NOPE!” “You want to build a rocket that lands itself? You’re NUTS!” “You want to operate an online retailer that never shows a profit?” That world leads to whatever progress GM, Sears and Boeing choose to give to us.