2 ms·
If it helps to understand the comment, change the word "breach" to "unintended redistribution of data". The comment is about the risk created by transferring d
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 2y ago
If it helps to understand the comment, change the word "breach" to "unintended redistribution of data".
The comment is about the risk created by transferring data to a third party for online storage.
It is not about the specific details of how data is obtained by unauthorised recipients from the third party.
The act of storing data with third parties who keep it online 24/7 creates risk.
Obviously, the third parties will claim there is no risk as long as ["security"] is followed
If we have a historical record that shows there will always be some deficiency in following ["security"], for whatever reasons,^1 then we can conclude that using the third parties inherently creates risk.
1. HN commenters who focus on the reasons are missing the point of the comment or trying to change the subject.
If customer X gives data to party A because A needs the data to perform what customer has contracted A to do, and then party A gives the data to party B, now customer X needs to worry about both A _and_ B following ["security"]. X should only need to trust A but now X needs to trust B, too. If the data is further transferred to third parties C and D, then there is even more risk. Only A needs the data to perform its obligation to customer X. B, C and D have no obligations to X. To be sure, X may not even know that B, C and D have X's data.
A good analogy is a non-disclosure agreement. If it allows the recipient to share the information with third parties, then the disclosing party needs to be concerned about whether the recipient has a suitable NDA with each third party and will enforce it. Maybe the disclosing party prohibits such sharing or requires that the recipient obtain permission before it can disclose to other parties.^2 If the recipient allows the information to be shared with unknown third parties, then that creates more risk.
2. Would AT&T customers have consented to their call records being shared with Snowflake. The people behind so-called "tech" companies like Snowflake know that AT&T customers have no say in the matter.