6 ms·
Give people something to link to
- verdverm 2y agoAnother great post by Simon. I literally built this concept into my new project last night, because I wanted to add evidence to the story about the Google Gemini App moderating yt-dlp, by showing that the Gemini API does not. Also to enable a funnel to the project and the other business-y reasons Simon outlines. https://topicalsource.dev/chat/84a0d6dd-f66f-4f12-af17-5e99ca682a0c https://topicalsource.dev/chat/84a0d6dd-f66f-4f12-af17-5e99c... The other thing I did was use localStorage to keep a list of public chats you've visited, so that when you come back you can see the other chats you have read. Also easier lookup than trying to find wherever you may have gotten the original link from. (like scrolling back in text history)
- verdverm 2y ago(btw, don't go to the example YouTube link, Gemini pulled a common troll meme)
- MaxBarraclough 2y ago> Hyperlinks are the best thing about the web Indeed. Well, hyperlinks and URLs. URLs are the cornerstone of the web. A precise, universal (hopefully), long-lasting (hopefully) way of referencing articles and other resources. It's always frustrating to see people fail to appreciate their brilliance, e.g. search this on YouTube rather than just pasting a link into a message. Giving a write-up a permanent home on the web can certainly help give it visibility, and help the author avoid writing up the same ideas again. Related classic essay: Cool URIs don't change. [0][1] [0] https://www.w3.org/Provider/Style/URI https://www.w3.org/Provider/Style/URI [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23865484 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23865484
- cxr 2y agoTwo under-utilized properties of URLs are also that: - there's a near-infinite supply of them - they support forward declaration Together the practical upshot is that if you're having a conversation with someone or responding during the Q&A of a talk or whatever and you want to be able to say, "Yeah, we thought about that, and we have some information about it on our site—just visit acmeinitiative.example.com/skub," except that you haven't already written the /skub article yet, that doesn't preclude you from being able to say in the moment (i.e. live) that /skub is effective immediately now the designated handle for such an article, it's where the article will appear once you do write it, and it's how any interested party should retrieve it once it does appear—whenever that is. (The same goes for articles published by other people/organizations and other third-party resources that you want to reference—just mint a URL from your namespace on-the-fly and then whenever you get a chance, set up a redirect to whatever it is you wanted to link to.) There are so many recordings (podcasts episodes, etc.) that I've listened to involving smart, technical people who definitely control their own domains but don't think to take advantage of this. Usually they sort of mumble some description that you might be able to use to find whatever they're talking about, or they manage to only get half the words in the title wrong when they're trying to recall it for the host, and then you and every other interested listener has to individually squander time and attention if you want to track it down. It results in a huge waste of collective energy.
- DelightOne 2y agoThe UX is not good enough yet. We would have to 1) show that it is reserved to people going on the link and 2) offer good/enough ways to be notified once the link becomes online and 3) need to know the likelihood of the link to actually work in the future based on prior commitment. AND I probably forgot a couple of issues.
- kevindamm 2y ago...and URLs being forever cuts both ways. Want to reorganize your domain's structure? Better set up 301s to forward the old address, forever, and hope (or avoid) any overlap between the old schema and the new. Transfer of ownership? Well, all those hyperlinks from other sites don't know.
- csh0 2y agoI think the idea is that if you were recording a podcast it wouldn’t be live (I know the parent used the word live but I think they meant “live” during recording or in conversation while the episode is being created), so you are free to make references to soon to be declared URLs. You just have to make sure you have populated the content at the location you are referencing before you upload or publish your episode for your listeners.
- cxr 2y ago> You just have to make sure you have populated the content at the location you are referencing before you upload You don't even have to do that, though. It suffices to say, "I'll wire these things up on Monday."
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoThis is not a criticism of URLs per se, but I find it troubling that the mere act of visiting one is something that we have to warn people away from. It's like: > Don't eat moldy food, else you'll get sick (unless it's bleu cheese, yum) Ok, that sounds like good advice, and easy do follow. > Don't look in the direction of modly food, else you'll get sick That's unreasonable. What kind of madman wrote the rules for this universe?! When I try to imagine a better way, it usually disallows the referents of a URL-equivalent from changing after they're created--that way trust bestowed once can be reused without prompting the user a second time for the "same" thing. For that reason, I'm not a fan of placeholder URL's like you're describing. The instability of URLs to me feels like more bug than feature.
- giantrobot 2y agoI hate the "search on <whatever>" statements. 1. It triggers my "AOL Keyword" yuck response immediately. 2. It completely ignores the concept of search bubbles. The results you and I get when searching the same term can be wildly different. 3. URLs and hyperlinks are right there. Instead of trying to make me do extra work you can just link me directly to a thing. That way I can see your exact reference instead of wading through a bunch of reaction videos to the video you wanted me to see.
- lobsterthief 2y agoFWIW I’ve heard ad spots on NPR where a brand says “search for “my financial adviser” and click on Some Brand”. Obviously trying to bump up their rankings by increasing CTR for that term in Google Search. They don’t even need to say “Google it” because they know most people already will.
- zimpenfish 2y ago> Instead of trying to make me do extra work you can just link me directly to a thing. The flaw there is that, equally, malicious actors can do the same and, often with today's obfuscated URLs, you have no idea which is which. Quick - which of these is the video about puppies and which is a shock video? 1. https://video.site/watch?v=SDKiaA3r8Ol https://video.site/watch?v=SDKiaA3r8Ol 2. https://video.site/watch?v=ilsAQIp091j https://video.site/watch?v=ilsAQIp091j
- MaxBarraclough 2y agoCybersecurity is a big topic, and issues of trust aren't exclusive to URLs. Search engines are often manipulated into showing malicious pages high in their listings. If you're communicating with someone you trust, it's better if they send you the URL directly.
- veqq 2y agoThe walled gardens increasingly block URLs - FB blocks many sites for sharing copywrited content (even random blogs) - reddit blocks all dot ru, may archival sites, telegram links etc. etc. - twitter blocked some blogging platforms - also many smaller sites block discord (which is justified) Hopefully this will motivate people to leave them.
- simonw 2y agoYeah, this is so frustrating. The contortions people have to go through on Instagram, TikTok, LinkedIn and now increasingly Twitter to work around the "algorithm" punishing or forbidding links is infuriating. "Link in bio" culture is the reason companies like Linktree even exist! And good for them, they're providing a sadly necessary service.
- nerdponx 2y agoLikewise it's difficult to link to content within those platforms. But the reason they don't like external links is that If they can't easily follow, external links, they are more likely to shrug and keep scrolling, instead of doing something else. That means marginally more ad impressions shown.
- cxr 2y agoLink-in-bio services would be a lot more useful if they accepted a link from the reader—the link of the item that referred them there because the platform it was on didn't allow direct-linking to off-site pages—and then returned the link that the author intended to convey there but was prevented from posting.
- fragmede 2y agoIt's easy enough to tell someone to click on https://youtu.be/dQw4w9WgXcQ https://youtu.be/dQw4w9WgXcQ, but how do you transfer that URL verbally, over a phone call or some other voice-only medium like podcasts with out resorting to an equally hard to memorize url shortener?
- emporas 2y agoIn BTC, they have devised a way to transform the private key, to twelve words. I don't know how that technique is called or where on github it is, but there is for sure a way to for a YT url to be made into words.
- fragmede 2y agoseed phrases are a thing, sure, but how is that more memorable than searching for what the podcast was talking about?
- emporas 2y agoWell, twelve words can certainly be transferred verbally, even though the generated words are not that memorable. Encoding a link to a much better memorable scheme could be done through a url service which parses a web page through an LLM, generates some tags, and creates custom routing using the tags. Rails or a more modern tool like Actix-web can do that easily. For example i asked Llama-8B to suggest tags for this HN thread using the title and the first 2 comments, and it suggested: web, URLs, hyperlinks, online-identity, permanence, flexibility, referencing, resource-management, web-architecture. The user can select which tags better represent the link, and create custom routing as such: https://yourlinkservice.com/hn/hyperlinks/referencing/ https://yourlinkservice.com/hn/hyperlinks/referencing/
- codetrotter 2y agoAnd then the web service that routes the links with those memorable words goes down and now all your links are dead all at once
- nonrandomstring 2y ago> help the author avoid writing up the same ideas again. Oh, how I wish! Except that many sites and services are hostile to this because it encroaches on their "attention territory". If as an author you link to an idea you already carefully expressed elsewhere as a blog post or book, the comment gets put down or censored for "promoting". More often on HN now, to avoid punishment, I just copy/paste my original writing rather than give the reader a link to explore more deeply. There's clearly a gap between what we preach as good "academic" ways of spreading information and ideas, and the reality/practice in systems that control expression.
- MaxBarraclough 2y agoPoint taken, but even in the context of Hacker News, if your write-up exists as a blog post with its own URL it can be submitted for discussion in a thread of its own, linking to the blog post. From the point of view of a Hacker News reader, it's easier if you copy+paste the relevant text from your blog post directly into your comment. None of us are in the habit of following every link. Even if you do have to copy+paste in this way, at least the text you're copying from has a permanent home. The taboo against 'promoting' is also there for a reason. Sometimes people really are motivated by bumping the hit-count on their page, rather than by contributing to the discussion. Things are certainly worse on the major 'silo' websites that are engineered to try to prevent people navigating away from their domain or equivalent mobile app.
- nonrandomstring 2y ago> Point taken, but even in the context of Hacker News, if your write-up exists as blog post with its own URL it can be submitted for discussion in a thread of its own, linking to the blog post. That's a bit like being in the thrall of an intense and interesting conversation and saying "sorry I have to go mail you the documents". It breaks the flow and defeats the purpose of a technology that was designed to overcome exactly that pitfall. > From the point of view of a Hacker News reader, it's easier if you copy+paste relevant text from your blog post directly into your comment. True. And I do that often enough as well. In addition I want to give the reader a genuinely interesting link (which itself contains further well researched links to explore the topic. Again, that's what we built this technology for. > The taboo against 'promoting' is also there for a reason. Sometimes people really are motivated by bumping the hit-count on their page, rather than by contribution to the discussion. Understood. And sometimes people aren't motivated to by hits. Crucially there's no mechanism for distinguishing the two and so conversation is stifled out of fear. > Things are certainly worse on the major 'silo' websites that are engineered to t to prevent people navigating away from their domain or equivalent mobile app. They certainly are, but do we want to emulate that and let HN become the same?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- randometc 2y agoAlong these lines, Square’s incident response meme lives on as https://outage.party/ https://outage.party/
- swyx 2y agocontext for those of us who werent there?
- ibash 2y agoDead links are the worst. Can someone make a browser extension that uses gpt to hallucinate websites for dead links?
- breck 2y agoYou might find this interesting: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40948221 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40948221
- jdougan 2y agoThere are extensions that talk to the Wayback Machine
- euroderf 2y agoWould it be so difficult to ping all links in a page being loaded, and clearly mark the dead ones ? Sure it would eat some bandwidth, but so do prefetch schemes and other stuff intended to speed up page renders.
- 6510 2y agoYou could probably do some fun compression scheme where you provide just enough information for a fixed llm version to generate a page that satisfies its authors goals. Your idea seems fun if people can one by one describe what the page use to look like and/or crawl the web for clues. We can have our under reconstruction banners back.
- GaggiX 2y agoI don't think there is a browser extension but there is a site called websim AI that creates fake pages in real-time using LLMs and it honestly works surprisingly well.
- sva_ 2y agohttps://websim.ai/ https://websim.ai/
- xyst 2y agoWe used to call this “imagination”. I guess in the digital age this is something that is lost :3
- remoquete 2y agoYou'd think that OpenAI, by now, had technical writers on payroll. Well, according to LinkedIn, they don't. It's not that surprising, then, that their documentation is in such a sorry state. Why they haven't hired specialized roles for documentation is beyond me; they either think they're irrelevant, or they ruthlessly prioritize growth over docs. Whatever the reason, they're hurting themselves.
- gryfft 2y agoHiring technical writers would be admitting to human supremacy in the technical writing space. Better optics to use GPT-generated docs regardless of impact to engineers and users.
- smnrchrds 2y agoLike Google and customer support?
- sadeshmukh 2y agoTheir docs aren't GPT-generated though - at least, that's what I think
- simonw 2y agoOpenAI's documentation is improving a bit now, but they're currently being left in the dust by Anthropic. The Anthropic prompting guide is genuinely the best I've seen anywhere: https://docs.anthropic.com/en/docs/build-with-claude/prompt-engineering/overview https://docs.anthropic.com/en/docs/build-with-claude/prompt-...
- quectophoton 2y agoThis is something rsync.net (the service) does well. For example, I haven't seen any other service with a "CEO page"[1]. Maybe it's something common and I just haven't noticed in any other service because it was not as discoverable. I don't know if it's really useful since I don't think I've ever needed to forward anything to any CEO, but I'm not even a customer and this page is the first thing that came to mind when reading the article. [1]: https://www.rsync.net/products/ceopage.html https://www.rsync.net/products/ceopage.html
- slyall 2y agoSome conferences have a "Why your employee should attended KimchiBurgerConf" page. This is designed to be forwarded to your manager rather than you personally trying to come up with a professional sounding justification.
- eddythompson80 2y agoI absolutely loathed a lot of Microsoft products for this simple thing. VSTS/VSO/Dev Ops/whateverNameTheyHaveNow, Sharepoint, etc were absolutely atrocious at this. Here is a deep link that’s 700 character long, with a couple of dozen base64 query strings and nonsensical path. “What’s the problem? Can you use a url shortening service? URLs are long nothing we can do about that” fuck me. Back in 2014, my team had an internal tool to view the state of resources in our system. All resources and their states were stored in a SQL database. Yet, the web app they developed was a SPA (before the invention of routers and stuff) and it never updated its url or supported deep linking. Whenever you wanted to send someone an email or an IM about an issue with a specific resource, you had to tell them “go to X tool, search for Y, click on Z -> W -> M -> O -> K, then you’ll see the issue there”. I found that so fucking infuriating. Why can’t I just use an https://X.com/Y/Z/W/M/O/K https://X.com/Y/Z/W/M/O/K link to share that deeply nested state? When I brought it up multiple times i was always told “it’s not a priority and it’s not that big of a deal” One time we were given 2 weeks to work on whatever we thought needed fixing. I decided to build an alternative that supported deep linking. But I also decided that all deep links should accept an `/api/` prefix that just returned the content in JSON format. It was just a hit with everyone in the team/company that the usage of X tool almost diminished over night even though my tool was much more rudimentary and didn’t have all the features that tool had. Nonetheless, turns out most people just wanted an easy way to share links rather than a “really powerful SPA that lets you dig down and investigate things”. A month later the team that worked on that tool X announced that they now support deep links in a huge email to the whole company. Yet they thought the simple feature of returning JSON data on `/api/` prefix is irrelevant. 5 years after, my tool’s UI became obsolete but the actual service was promoted to a “vital internal service” because so many other teams built automation around the `/api/` prefix URLs and that team had to take that code and maintain it.
- weikju 2y agoI've also found that kind of situation.. I've learned that in an office environment people are often content using a tool and following the established procedure and are not considering it could be better -- even if you ask them! Until you show them something better.... Good job :) Hope you at least got some recognition out of your efforts
- calrain 2y agoHe references the site https://boringtechnology.club/ https://boringtechnology.club/ which is a great slide deck on reserving your effort to innovate on your unique solution. And for the rest of the stuff, stay as boring as possible. So many times I see dev teams get innovating the whole way down and end up losing the focus as to how they provide value. I need to burn this slide deck into my world view!
- swyx 2y agono one has pointed this out yet but as a resident simonw fanboy i will point out Simon’s other examples of giving people something to link to as very effective for HN https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=simonwillison.net%20-show%20-ask&sort=byPopularity&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... simon is often the very first person to write up a developing story in ai that most people close to the matter know about, but he can do it fast and link to all the relevant facts quickly and make it accessible for the people further away from the story to discuss.
- vintageplayer 2y agolove Simonw blogs. I've been reading his blogs using the python interpreter since last year September. He mentioned he started doing it on his own to generate whole applications on the go. I'm still not clear not how to do it though. I expected some easy option or button, and didn't find it. I admit I could have spent more effort trying to figure out how to do it, but a handy link/tutorial would have helped me keep doing it instead of pretty much ignoring GPT most of the times.
- caohongyuan 2y ago[dead]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- goyatg 2y agoanother great post, very insightful
- NickFrichette 2y ago[dead]