4 ms·
WebContainers: Dev environments. In your web app
- kristopolous 2y agoso I'm looking at the demo at https://stackblitz.com/edit/stackblitz-webcontainer-api-starter-qx8gmp?file=README.md https://stackblitz.com/edit/stackblitz-webcontainer-api-star... Alright, looks like a lot of work went into this. What's the unique use case here? Help me out. I don't really understand why people would want to write code like this.
- 0x1ceb00da 2y agoCreating online playgrounds that execute in the users browser.
- kristopolous 2y agook, that's a busy and crowded field with at least a dozen entrenched players: gitpod, codeanywhere, codepen, replit, jsfiddle, coder, jsbin, playcode, aws cloud9, codeenvy, github codespaces, and just plain old jupyter notebooks, just to name the ones I can think of. Is this really just a metoo product?
- DANmode 2y agoWhy do different technical subcultures choose each of these almost as often as the others? 1. Network effects are stronger than we realize, due to being in the networks 2. UX detail matters more than most of us here give credit.
- kristopolous 2y agoOr maybe it's not too hard to create a web ide and relatively cheap to run. I'd imagine if you took a deep dive into web-assembly, lots of pieces are already there. It's really probably around 3-4 big pieces to try to piece together. Sounds like a pretty rewarding payoff.
- rezonant 2y ago> gitpod, coder, AWS cloud9, codenvy, codespaces These run your code on a cloud server > codeanywhere This runs your coding interview on a cloud server > codepen, replit, jsfiddle, jsbin, playcode, jupyter These aren't really IDEs, they run some limited html and css on the client or in some cases some code in other languages on a cloud server. They are intended for small shareable snippets that demonstrate something. They generally don't have a full filesystem view, and thus are a specialized flavor of coding environment. > web containers This runs your frontend and backend code (yes, http servers) in a local browser backed filesystem that's fully local with no cloud servers which has a full terminal and process system as well as WASM adapted (and environment tweaked) versions of your development tools. There is no competitor that does quite this, to my knowledge. It might seem like these are all the same, but they are not if you look closer. It's pretty crazy tech, and really genius.
- ryandv 2y ago> This runs your frontend and backend code (yes, http servers) in a local browser backed filesystem This runs your development environment in the browser. Why not just run natively on the operating system, which already gives you filesystem access, terminals, and processes?
- fragmede 2y agobecause of all the problems with that, especially at scale. obviously that works, since that's how we've done it since the before times, but the shortcomings of that are what has lead to the rise of SaaS.
- kristopolous 2y agoWhat problems get fixed by this approach and how does it become less wall time to fully address it? I'm phrasing it carefully because sometimes solutions are really just the original problem redecorated in some new paradigm of dealing with it and doesn't actually reduce the responsibility, time, skills or cognitive requirements to surmount it. For instance, many automation tools replaced writing shell scripts with YAML or Ruby DSL. You gotta solve the same exact problems in the end, but now you do it in YAML. What used to take 3 hours, now only takes 3 hours. So, what problems are actually being fixed here? Alternatively it may just bring you more joy to with with it, which is what a lot of these tools actually do. That's fine as well.
- lolinder 2y agoThe demo's use of Stackblitz is actually really confusing here, because it makes it seem like their IDE is what's being demoed when it's not. WebContainers is a (proprietary) library for anyone to use to build playgrounds that execute client and server code on the frontend alone. It sounds like it was extracted from Stackblitz's implementation for separate use. WebContainers is not competing in that crowded field (though Stackblitz is) because as far as I know no one else offers a library to build your own. This is partly because it's a pretty niche offering—developers of server-side or full-stack frameworks are the most obvious target users.
- nsonha 2y agoplayground is a minor usecase, to me the big one is giving you a new option for scaling: shifting compute to client devices. They are powerful these days, and offline-first beyond data syncing is also desirable.
- rezonant 2y agoIt's far beyond that. Web containers in Stackblitz is an entirely local in-browser IDE, complete with frontend and backend support, NPM, git, a full VS Code based IDE experience and end to end debugging (step right from your frontend right into your backend code). It runs (well, simulates?) HTTP and WebSockets right within the environment.
- curtisblaine 2y agoThin clients. Your workstation only needs to run a browser, all the tooling is already provided. Allows you to access your environment from anywhere.
- fragmede 2y agoIn this case, the environment is running locally, so while the code may be backed by cloud storage, the resources being used are the local machine.
- firtoz 2y agoI have a version of Anthropic Artifacts working in my project here. Claude generates the code (backend or frontend), I wrap it into a little package, boom, instant deployment.
- bluelightning2k 2y agoI've always been very impressed with StackBlitz. What they've done not only here but Sandpack also. Absolutely next level. And they do all this work then open source it instead of keeping it as a technical advantage. Strongly recommend their blog. Not affiliated just a fan.
- QuiiBz 2y agoSandpack is made by CodeSandbox, not StackBlitz: https://github.com/codesandbox/sandpack https://github.com/codesandbox/sandpack
- bluelightning2k 2y agoThanks for pointing out my error there. Pretty big misattribution.
- bberenberg 2y agoIs this open source somewhere? I haven’t found it.
- jFriedensreich 2y agoits NOT open source. the github package just loads stuff from their servers and does not contain the actual web container code
- meiraleal 2y agoI had to check again if they made it opensource or if it is still just fake marketing misleading but yeah, still the same bullshit. You didn't even take the effort to validate if your "support" is really valid.
- moffkalast 2y agoDev environments? In my web app? It's more likely than you think!
- curtisblaine 2y agoThere ought to be an open source version of this. Wondering if it's "just" compiling the respective binaries needed by the tool chain (node, esbuild, who knows what else) to WebAssembly and providing proxied network access (for the registry). Alternatively, wondering if this could work with the various linux-on-a-webpage demos that were recently posted here.
- fragmede 2y agoThat demo is really impressive. It's click, scroll, click to get to it though. I'd make it a big button on the main page with marketing copy around it. Bonus points for also buying https://webcontainer.io/ https://webcontainer.io/ (no s) and pointing it at the right place. Also, this is like the better funded, more productized cousin of https://webvm.io/ https://webvm.io/
- nickstinemates 2y agoWhere/what is the demo you're referencing? I'd like to watch it.
- fragmede 2y agoNot a video demo, the demo of their product, at https://webcontainer.new/ https://webcontainer.new/
- meiraleal 2y agoWhy impressive? Looks like every other modern code playground.
- lolinder 2y agoThe code playground is hosting the WebContainer, it's not the WebContainer. The demo is what's running in the Preview pane. That took a while for me to figure out, too. I think from the marketing materials Stackblitz uses WebContainers internally as well? This is one of the reasons I prefer open-source, when the marketing is confusing I can just look at the implementation.
- ericmsimons 2y agoThanks for this feedback- we’ll definitely make it easier to land on the webcontainer.new demo from the homepage. I think our main concern initially was that without docs context it might be too confusing what’s going on, but I think we could find ways to ease that in that experience itself
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jappgar 2y agoYour scientists were so preoccupied with whether they could that they never stopped to think if they should.
- ramesh31 2y agoThere's a special kind of hell awaiting anyone silly enough to build anything on this.
- speed_spread 2y agoWe've said the same thing the day Node.js was invented and look where we are now. Whatever you build based on these bad ideas _is_ that special hell.
- pjmlp 2y agoKeyboard doesn't echo on Android Chrome, only after return is pressed.
- crowdyriver 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tcper 2y agoGood tech, but only good fit for StackBlitz. Don't know who will need this product to run a node.js enviroment in browser.
- seveibar 2y agoWe used this to build an interactive cli in the browser for Seam, and I’m currently working on using it to host a local typescript language server for tscircuit so that the playground has autocomplete. Imo a very useful technology
- tcper 2y agoYou can use xterm.js to implement interactive cli in browsers, and you can use backend language server to implement autocomplete. xterm.js is just not so fashion.
- ericmsimons 2y agoWe originally thought the same but a few years back started seeing increasing demand outside of stackblitz itself. Surprisingly a very large and growing number of use cases across interactive edu tools, AI code execution (https://webcontainers.io/ai https://webcontainers.io/ai), SaaS dev envs for end users to write code, amongst others
- jrvarela56 2y agoYour application and development environment (editor + 'server') are in the same runtime. This seems important for iterating JS/TS programs ala Smalltalk.
- libming_ 2y agoStackBlitz has always struck me as a solution in search of a problem. Buyer beware: WebContainers is closed-source and there are hundreds of open issues from users. Most of them are ignored for weeks and months at a time as the company pivots from one thing to the next: https://github.com/stackblitz/webcontainer-core/issues https://github.com/stackblitz/webcontainer-core/issues
- paulgb 2y ago“It’s a solution in search of a problem and also has hundreds of issues from users” is kind of a funny juxtaposition, in the same sense that “nobody goes there, it’s too crowded” is.
- lolinder 2y agoStackBlitz != WebContainers. StackBlitz is another code playground. WebContainers is a library that they've extracted from their codebase and are selling that allows other people to build full-stack code playgrounds on their sites.
- ericmsimons 2y agostackblitz ceo here, just to clarify: we haven’t ever pivoted from webcontainers, not sure what you’re talking about there. it’s been our main thing since forever :) stackblitz itself is a product suite built on top of webcontainers. note that many issues in the repo you linked are not for webcontainers specifically, but instead mostly for stackblitz specific functionality. we have about 3m devs/mo using us for free on stackblitz.com, so we do the best we can for free public issue triage but do prioritize our paying customers (we are a business after all :)
- koolala 2y agoI wish you could make WebContainers actually an open source standard library for local sandboxed client / server coding one day. I know CORS screws everything up... You already have the customers / platform...
- ericmsimons 2y agoHi HN! Cofounder of StackBlitz/WebContainers here, cool to wake up and see this on the front page unexpectedly :) Happy to answer any questions! Btw one emergent use case we've seen growing rapidly has been code execution for AI agents. Would love thoughts/questions/feedback if you’re working on things in that space: https://webcontainers.io/ai https://webcontainers.io/ai
- spankalee 2y agoWhat's the patent you mention on the site? Are any other web-based terminal, shell, or Node emulators at risk of violating it? Is it for a specific implementation technique? It's kind of scary to see in the docs, to be honest.
- ericmsimons 2y agoGood question, here's the link to it: https://patents.google.com/patent/US20220417315A1/en?q=(stackblitz)&oq=stackblitz https://patents.google.com/patent/US20220417315A1/en?q=(stac... It's somewhat specific to our use case as you'll see when you read through. A motivation for securing this was that we've had issues (one instance in particular) where we caught a direct competitor directly copy+pasting code from our compiled builds into their own competing product. Asking them nicely to stop didn't do anything, nor getting emails from our lawyers. The main lever a startup has to solve this is to keep innovating and being the best product in the market, which is what we have done & continue to do. But having a patent is a useful lever for general deterrence from bad actors like this. (Also want to say thanks and give credit to Vinay Hiremath, cofounder of Loom, who went through similar in the early days of Loom and helped point us down the path of securing a patent)
- nojvek 2y agoWhat does webcontainers exactly mean? Browsers don't allow me to call arbitrary other urls since the called server needs to allow with cross domain request headers. What happens if I close browser tab? does that make the webcontainer go poof? What about memory and CPU requirements? The idea sounds like a great hack, but the whole point of cloud IDEs is that it uses someone else's resources. I could get a 64 CPU with a bunch of H100s to dev on, run some script in background, and shut it when I'm done.
- spankalee 2y agoWebContainers is pretty awesome, and at this point if I were a server runtime (especially Deno and Bun), I would try to maintain a first-party web platform version for exactly the type of linkable, ephemeral, no-install, sandboxed, local dev environments of your that WebContainers provides. I do wish this were open source, and the mention of a patent scares me - I feel like lots of people have tried this over the years, are they running afoul of some patent not fully linked to from the WebContainers site? - but I understand the investment that StackBlitz has made and the need to make money.
- johnny22 2y agoi don't seem to remember you being able to run these without a net connection. It not being open makes it a no go.
- T3RMINATED 2y ago[dead]