4 ms·
Ask HN: Do you or does anyone you know produce trash?
I see intentionally created trash (pandering art, throwaway ad bait websites, etc.) everyday that seems to make money, and I wonder: "Who does this stuff?"
To clarify my tone: I do not look down on this necessarily. Creating things that serve no purpose other than to help you or others make a living is a completely reasonable, although certainly not ideal, thing to do.
But creating this stuff can take real creativity and ability. In fact, some of the "trash" I'm referring to takes a lot of one or the other. So who's doing it?
- dholowiski 14y agoI've created what you call "trash" in the past, although I suspect we have different definitions of trash. Simply, it's a good way to make money.
- tomasien 14y agoI didn't put any judgement in my post except to call it trash, which is what it is. Trash collectors are certainly honorable, but they collect trash
- jeffool 14y agoWhile not exactly what you're talking about, I did some contract SEO work recently that left me feeling like I'd done something even worse. A friend there got me the interview and spoke well of me. We'd worked together in local TV journalism, where I worked for years after he left. (I'm aware, many would consider local TV news trash in its right right. ;) ) I'll always appreciate his looking out for me like he did, but I'm one of those crazy people who thinks advertising in general is just... Grating. And doing it for something I don't care about? I thought I could stomach it and go forward, but I felt horrible. Now, I still did the work, and I don't think I did a poorer job, I just felt really dissatisfied about it, and the work took me far longer to do it than I should've. I ended up ending the contract myself after a couple of months. I mean, there were a couple of good jobs in the contract... It's just, I can see how someone could do well in that field helping elevate bad or mediocre companies/people get more attention that they deserve. And that's horrible to me. I want to do some work I can believe in. Like you said, it can take real creativity and ability, and I still have the utmost respect for my friend who works at the marketing company. I personally just felt so weird writing and doing that work behind the scenes for that reason, after years of working in journalism and enjoying that I felt I was contributing, even to some degree, to the public good.
- debacle 14y agoI created astroturfing marketing websites for a multinational company for two years. It was soul-sucking, and I'm glad I'm done with it.