3 ms·
Spain actually had better fiscal discipline than Germany during the boom, with lower government deficits and lower public debt, so "discpline/indiscipline" is d
by _delirium 14y ago
Spain actually had better fiscal discipline than Germany during the boom, with lower government deficits and lower public debt, so "discpline/indiscipline" is definitely not the whole story.
- o1iver 14y agoWhat I meant with discipline is the general attitude towards spending. Germany has spent a lot of money, but they spent it smartly, building up to becoming one of the most powerful industrial nations in the world, whilst the southern countries built houses that now stand empty in the spanish ghost towns.
- excuse-me 14y agoThat still made more sense than Ireland. For the last 40 years if you built property in Spain people from Germany/UK would buy it. How did Irish banks expect to sell more new houses than they had people?
- mafribe 14y agoBut Spain had an absolutely massive private debt, that's now crashing down. Moreover this building bubble has been extremely obvious to anyone who's ever been to Spain in the last few years. A responsible government should have been stepped in a few years ago. What matters in terms of financial responsibility is not public debt alone, or private debt, but both.
- dimitar 14y agoIt did try to regulate building, but there was too much money coming in from abroad as loans. It couldn't stopped its inflow because it is against EU treaties.
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoThe central government was. But historically as now the relatively weak central government wasn't the problem - the regional governments ran up (and some continue to run up) exorbitant deficits. This is in exclusion of private Spanish debts, which are very large.
- _delirium 14y agoI believe it's still true even if you add in regional debts. From what I can find, before the current crisis, outstanding central government debt hovered around 30-35% of GDP, while regional debt added up to around 10% of GDP, for a total of 40-45% of GDP, one of the lower debt totals among large economies in Europe. Lately it's been ballooning due to a mixture of: 1) interest-rate rises producing a self-fulfilling prophecy; 2) recession reducing tax revenue and increasing safety-net expenses; and 3) recession causing the GDP denominator to get smaller. The main difference I can see is just that the German economy is much stronger than the Spanish economy, not any difference in fiscal discipline. Germany can afford to carry bigger deficits and bigger debts because it has a comparatively strong economy; same reason the U.S. can maintain much higher deficits than Spain without borrowing costs increasing.