7 ms·
I'm done making desktop applications (2009)
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 2y ago[flagged]
- worthless-trash 2y agoWe just moved the responsibility of security off the desktop, to the web. We abstracted the problem as an industry, hooray.
- spockz 2y agoWell we did more. By moving the compute and core to the other side of the fence within control of the seller it becomes hard(er) to pirate. Whereas as soon as you provide a working binary it is only a matter of time somebody has pirated it.
- worthless-trash 2y agoMind blown, this is a side-effect that I had not even really considered. I had just thought it was to sidestep the complexity of local installations.
- thejosh 2y agoI would argue webapps killed them. Most applications now adays are just electron wrappers. WebApps also allow a much more flexible update schedule, and other benefits. Downside: apps now need gigabytes of memory for simple apps. Upside: Linux is now a lot more easier to use as a lot of things are web based. :-)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- chadcmulligan 2y agoYou could perhaps imagine web apps as a form of 2FA, half the app is on the client, and the other half is on the server and continually authenticating each other by communicating with each other. There's no reason you can't do this with desktop apps, put a chunk of the functionality on the server and obtain security that way. The trouble with web apps is compute and storage performance, for a web app you're limited by the browser - not so much for a desktop. Its not really an issue for a bingo card creator, it is if you're making blender or autocad.
- groestl 2y ago> half the app is on the client, and the other half is on the server and continually authenticating each other This is not what 2FA is.
- asdff 2y agoWhat did you have in mind with the browser being a limiting factor? It seems to me you can run stuff in the browser that makes use of all your local resources and can save things as well, considering tools like jupyter notebooks.
- qsort 2y ago> Its not really an issue for a bingo card creator, it is if you're making blender or autocad. This is obviously valid, but considering how powerful even low-end computers are these days, I'd say that most of the stuff we do on a computer is more like bingo card creator than blender or autocad. Software that is slow in spite of this is generally slow because it does a thousand network requests in the background. A 2009-era argument could have been that desktop apps are more respectful of your privacy, but that ship has long sailed due to pervasive telemetry, and it wasn't really ever true for mobile anyway.
- BuildTheWorld 2y agoNow that websites can use the File System Access API to load and save files, the Desktop is "solved" for me. Everybody can use my software simply by opening the url in their browser. The new challenge is phones. Mobile browsers do not support the File System Access API. What is a solution to this? Is there a reputable service that converts a web page into an Android/iOS app so that it can load and save files?
- jpnc 2y agoOne thing I'm missing is pkcs11 API in browsers. This seems to not make sense to US devs from what I could see but if you're in EU you can probably commiserate.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- devwastaken 2y agoFile system access API is a chromium feature.
- JoshStrobl 2y agoFile System API is a baseline feature supported across all major vendors. https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/File_System_API https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/File_System...
- outofpaper 2y agoYa, it's odd to say it's not on other browsers when they all have it just to variable degrees... it's almost as if there are comment bots here that are trained on outdated data ;)
- devwastaken 2y agoNot a comment bot. File system API features are not universal. It's why you can have folder access on chromium and not on Firefox.
- wiseowise 2y agoGiven that the tool they made is still alive and well more than 10 years down the road - they made a right call.
- zogrodea 2y agoAs someone trying to carve out a (non-commercial, for me personally) space for desktop apps, the author raises very good points and I believe they are right. (Although I still prefer working on non-web tech when I can.)
- whartung 2y agoEvery time I take a stab at a web gui app, I’m daunted. The toolkits, the apparently billions of dependencies, the vastly complicated build processes. I tried again recently. HTML file and a separate JS file. Some SVG elements with a click handler. I had mouse in and mouse out logic, and that worked great. But for some reason the click handler did not. I tried it in Safari, Chrome, and Firefox. It worked in Firefox. It did not work in Safari, it did not work in Chrome. Turns out in Safari, my Ad Blocker was hijacking my click handler. Chrome, still not sure what’s happening there. But I projected what happened in Safari out to the wild. “Can’t get your app to work.” Except instead of a 50 line experiment, it’s a gazillion lines of God knows what 87 levels removed from whatever code I actually wrote. Cross browser Hell. It’s supposed to be a sandbox only to find out the cat got there first. And I give up. Again. It’s not my livelihood. It’s a hobby. I encountered these quickly enough to thwart me before I’ve actually invested any real time. Like starting out on a vacation and you have a flat tire and the drain plug pops out before you get out of town. Maybe there’s a cosmic message here. And I feel stupid. Obviously folks manage, but I keep getting knocked down and kicked. The idea of pain free distribution via a PWA is really alluring. I’d like it to work. But it seems every time I get back up, the lights go out again and the corners of the cabinets seek my head. But then I think back to my rock climbing days, a friend used to climb in shorts. And I asked didn’t it hurt when he used his knees? He answered “it’s not supposed to hurt?” Is it supposed to hurt?
- adastra22 2y agoDevelopers like you and I are a dying breed. We remember writing applications for operating systems that had straightforward APIs, and OS developers that worked hard to ensure any app which used those APIs would not break. Most "full-stack" developers I know that write web apps have literally never written a line of C++ in their life, let alone written a rich text editor using an object oriented desktop GUI API. They don't know it's not supposed to hurt.
- piva00 2y agoBut C++ hurts, a lot. My first foray into C++ was trying to write exactly a GUI app for Win32 back on Windows 98, it hurt, a lot.
- slyfox125 2y agoBrowser-based software and desktop applications share some overlap but as the 15 years since the article have shown, that overlap isn't complete or even overly substantial (and thus desktop applications are as prevalent as ever). Just as a hammer and a nailgun are both tools that allow us to effectively build a structure, they both have their niches, benefits, and drawbacks. To pretend otherwise is simply juvenile and shortsighted.
- tjoff 2y agoI feel like the author generalise too much. His points are valid for one app. I'm not surprised that the web version works better for him, given what kind of app it is, target audience etc. But he writes it as if he is dismissing desktop apps entirely which is way to drastic from this one example. The most surprising thing is that that this was in 2009. Web apps was not common back then. I have one big gripe with this: > Don’t treat your newbies like you treat your power-users. You have a database. It records all their actions since the dawn of time. Use it. I have a couple very simple heuristics for “is probably still getting used to the software” and, if you are, the software treats you with kid gloves. For example, it hides complex, seldom used options by default. First of all, your heuristics are most certainly broken. Hiding options is infuriating, if you are trying to evaluate the software you get the wrong idea of what is possible. If you've used it before but started a new account you suddenly don't feel at home. If you are following a guide or recommendation they suddenly don't work. If you read the documentation I truly hope it is very clear that a feature might be hidden and what to do to enable it. If you even consider the above make it very clear that you are in a simpler mode and make it easy to switch.
- Twisell 2y agoWould be interesting though to repeat this analysis today because the rise of AppStores considerably simplified the shareware model for those who use them (while they have huge drawbacks too). 1. Land on the site by searching 2. Click on the preferred/compatible AppStore link 3. Optional step for tech savy users : Read commitments and review to check if something is dubious 4. Use the app for X weeks of trying period or until a fremium limitation is reached 5. Pay in one click when you choose or when a popup remind you that you must pay to lift some limitations That 4/5 steps instead of the 17 described by the OP, and that's probably the true value of AppStores for Developers. (Are margins fair? that's up for debate! But it's unfair to ignore the added value)
- Dalewyn 2y agoI actually find myself actively avoiding getting anything from application stores without prior outside knowledge. Why? Because given no other context I cannot tell apart the decent from the bullshit, let alone the good. There are no differentiators because the storefront obviously accepts everything including the bull-est of shits, being paid-for or free-beer is hardly a useful measure these days (and $5 is nothing), and basically everything outside of a very small handful comes from no-name developers and publishers (bonus points if Suspicious Chinese(tm) names). Back in ye olde days: I could count on stores since if they put something on their shelves they clearly sold enough volume. I could/can count on word-of-mouth websites with EXE and ZIP downloads. I could/can count on digital storefronts because their userbase could be trusted (eg: Steam, GOG). Application stores? It's all just 300% noise.
- webprofusion 2y agoIt depends :) If your app does something on the users local machine (or a server) and cannot just exist in a browser then there is room for a desktop app. You can run a local web server on a high port and connect to that as the web UI but not that many apps get away with that approach.
- cm2187 2y agoAlso, from a end user point of view, unless you are downloading from a known and reputable software company, you assume the exe contains spyware and viruses by default. That has been the main reason for me to download desktop apps sparingly.
- graemep 2y agoSo you install from app stores.
- eXpl0it3r 2y agoIt's a bit of a one sided view. For someone trying to commercialize their simplistic application, it seems to make perfectly sense. The article is missing the down-sides/limitations of web apps though, especially from a user perspective. Bingo Card users are in luck that the author has kept maintaining the site for 15years, but I'd say 9/10 "web apps" would not last 5 years, where a desktop application, I could at least continuing using, assuming the activation doesn't require external checks. And then in this day and age, you never know when the enshitification of applications sets in. Yes, this can happen to desktop applications as well, but as the author points out, it's much faster to release something "new" on the web. You can A/B test the web app to max profitability, regardless of user experience or user needs. Finally, for more complex applications, the latency on desktop applications has been severely underplayed. With web apps and web apps as desktop apps, people have been pushed into a new expectation of how fast computers can be.
- dep_b 2y agoThe true death of desktop applications were system administrators and their draconian app policies. What do you want to do? Ask the eternally overworked BOFH of duty to go through the month-long approval process of deploying a superior desktop app to the org, or just pay the monthly fees of a SaaS (conveniently below the approval required threshold) and have a mediocre solution right now? The AppStore’s ease and security is what saved native apps on mobile.
- tarsinge 2y agoThis is true but only explains business apps.