2 ms·
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_geodesy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_geodesy says aristotle: off by a factor of almost 2 eratosthenes: of
by kragen 2y ago
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_geodesy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_geodesy says
aristotle: off by a factor of almost 2
eratosthenes: off by -2.4–+0.8%, or maybe up to 15%, because we aren't sure how big his stadia were
ptolemy: at first accepting eratosthenes' figure, he later switched to a figure that was about 30% low
aryabhata: probably off by about 0.8%, though again it's unclear how big his yojana were
caliph al-ma'amun: probably off by about 0.45%, and in this case the source of error is not the unit of measurement but the different accounts of how many of them they measured in a degree
the fact that 1500 years ago aryabhata bothered to give the earth's diameter as 1581 1⁄24 yojanas strongly suggests that he believed the size of a yojana to be defined to within less than 26 parts per million; remember that he had to do all his calculations mentally or by hand, so extra significant figures were extra significant labor
however, all of these measurements postdate the monuments of rameses from 3200 years ago, which contain multiple precisely measured statues constructed all over egypt (though i don't have references on what the tolerances were on the statues)