3 ms·
> Market forces naturally determined this outcome though. Market forces alone didn't work. It's an externality, a cost paid by others not involved in the trans
by Animats 2y ago
> Market forces naturally determined this outcome though.
Market forces alone didn't work. It's an externality, a cost paid by others not involved in the transaction. Market forces don't handle that.
A 1970s Milton Bradley Big Trak and a Radio Shack TRS-80, both popular products in their day, will, if brought near to each other, both crash.
Without fairly strict regulation of unwanted RF emissions, there would be many incompatible devices. There were before the FCC started requiring more testing in the 1970s. A world with a huge number of consumer devices emitting RF noise would have prevented low-power cellular phone and WiFi deployment.
It's not that hard. This is an "unintentional emitter" (it's not trying to send a radio signal). The rules for that are not too bad. Testing costs about $3000 to $5000.
You want to have some ability to pre-test. You might find something. Attaching a wire to something can give it an antenna and make it emit much more RF, so you do need to test. It's not too hard.[1] Actual FCC certification is $3000 to $5000, assuming you pre-tested and fixed any problems before getting a certification run.
From the project's FAQ:
"Given that this will initially be a niche product, the price will be quite high.
I was once taught to ask myself the following question: Who is your rich customer?
The type of person whom I have in mind has a high discretionary budget for personal
electronics and willingness to pay a premium for novel ideas."
[1] https://www.nutsvolts.com/magazine/article/low-cost-emi-pre-compliance-testing https://www.nutsvolts.com/magazine/article/low-cost-emi-pre-...
- bruce511 2y agoThe first rule of knowing if a market exists is to define what you are making and then figure out who it's for. Then pitch to that person the benefits of your product. Alas the FAQ page lacks both of these questions. I'm left with no idea -why- I'd buy this thing. What utility does it have? What is it supposed to replace? I think you can stop worrying about the FCC issues with it. You won't sell any of these (at least not with this FAQ page). Your whole "discussion" is technical and doesn't mention utility once. It sounds to me like you're building this because it's fun to build and scratches an itch. But it's not a product, much less requires you to start building and designing new hardware. So well done on at least skipping that investment. If you want to make a hardware product then early about utility first. If it's useful then other things flow from that. Not the other way around.
- willsmith72 2y ago> The first rule of knowing if a market exists is to define what you are making and then figure out who it's for. Then pitch to that person the benefits of your product. I would switch that order. Figure out your customer before you define what you're making.
- bruce511 2y agoYes, that's even better.
- olalonde 2y agoWhy is it so expensive though? Also, why not fine or ban products that cause problems rather than requiring certification. It seems that would be a lot more efficient.
- KolmogorovComp 2y ago> Also, why not fine or ban products that cause problems rather than requiring certification Because people could get hurt or killed in the meantime. See the 737max for example. Now it is a dramatic example, but think about any device unwillingly emitting too much electromagnetic radiation potentially being harmful to kids or messing with people pacemakers.
- olalonde 2y agoYou could make similar arguments for basically any product, doesn't seem worth it to get every product certified though. Also, didn't the 737max pass certifications?
- pjc50 2y agoAlmost every product is certified in the EU (CE marking), although if you look closely it's self-certification and it's not always clear which sets of certification might be required for a product. (I'm on the fence about this; personally I think there need to be far more small company / small production run exemptions from these requirements, but on the other hand I don't want a loophole for recklessly dangerous products)
- wsc981 2y ago> Almost every product is certified in the EU (CE marking), although if you look closely it's self-certification and it's not always clear which sets of certification might be required for a product. Not to be confused with the Chinese Export marking: https://www.kimuagroup.com/news/differences-between-ce-and-china-export-markings https://www.kimuagroup.com/news/differences-between-ce-and-c...
- debugnik 2y agoAgreed, but I can't find that quote in TFA so I can't entirely tell which point you're rebutting. Did the author remove it? EDIT: Oh, I see you meant to reply to some top-level comment further down.