4 ms·
> DRM is always broken, given enough time This actually applies a lot less to Youtube than it does to any other service. On other video streaming platforms, t
by miki123211 2y ago
> DRM is always broken, given enough time
This actually applies a lot less to Youtube than it does to any other service.
On other video streaming platforms, think Netflix, Max, Disney Plus etc, you have a fairly limited number of shows, each with a fairly large number of views. This means that if you break DRM, you can share your tool with a few trusted co-conspirators and only release the videos you rip, but not the tools themselves. This protects you from the platforms discovering and breaking your method.
Youtube doesn't really work like that, a lot of people who use yt-dlp and other such tools care about videos with relatively fewer views, which are unlikely to be available anywhere else. This would require any potential DRM-breakers to share their method publicly, which would make them extremely short-lived.
Good DRM algorithms nowadays aren't just some obfuscated code in a binary that you have to reverse engineer, they rely heavily on some content being decrypted in hardware. Even if you understand every single instruction in the binary, re-create a perfect open source version of it and have full read/write privileges to any part of the memory that your OS kernel can access, it's still not enough.
- ChildOfChaos 2y agoIsin't it a problem for youtube though for the amount of devices it has to work on? If they suddenly changed all of there DRM, then a lot of things would break including various smarttv's etc.