5 ms·
Leaving aside the concerns about the tech not working well, I'm really not a fan of this pre-crime stuff. This feels very Big Brother, where someone (or some sy
by stavros 2y ago
Leaving aside the concerns about the tech not working well, I'm really not a fan of this pre-crime stuff. This feels very Big Brother, where someone (or some system) is watching over you so you don't break any laws.
Things like this lead to cultural ossification and are a nightmare scenario for me.
- umvi 2y agoOne possible future includes one or more of: - AI guns that won't shoot at other people, only authorized in-season animals. - AI keyboards that won't let you type "hate speech" - AI browsers that only let you visit approved, legal sites. - AI smartphones that contact the police if you are breaking curfew, trespassing, recording unauthorized (copyrighted) public or audio, etc.
- stavros 2y agoYou don't need AI for the browser thing, stuff is already blocked at the DNS level.
- novagameco 2y ago> - AI guns that won't shoot at other people, only authorized in-season animals. That sounds like a legitimately good idea, why would you need a gun that shoots people
- its_ethan 2y ago> why would you need a gun that shoots people Resisting the urge to be snarky, self defense is a legitimate answer. You may not live somewhere where it's common (or you may not frequently feel unsafe) but wanting the ability to have a weapon to defend yourself (or more commonly to show that you have the ability to defend yourself) from any assailant is a very real thing for people both in the US and around the world. There are plenty of women with restraining orders against men who would do them harm who would very much suffer consequences, and be made much more afraid for their safety, if it weren't for "guns that shoot people".
- novagameco 2y agoI believe there should be stricter gun control, but that people should be allowed to carry other forms of self defense such as pepper spray or tasers (I understand these are illegal in some countries). If we invented a gun which allowed hunters to hunt but somehow didn't let people should other people, I can only see that as a positive
- lolinder 2y agoThis is all assuming that the control mechanism is impossible to disable, which you know full well is impossible to implement. If the control mechanism can be disabled then we're back to "if you outlaw guns then only outlaws will have guns".
- Vicinity9635 2y agoBecause bad people exist and there are imminent dangers? There are legitimately good uses of people shooting people all the time. Hostage situations being the painfully obvious example. What even is this question?
- novagameco 2y agoWell obviously the police would have access to other kinds of guns, but if civilian guns were only capable of shooting deer then that would be a definite plus
- Vicinity9635 2y ago[dead]
- novagameco 2y agoBut on the highway they are watching over you so you don't break any laws. They have police officers who patrol the highways and traffic cameras. If this had any implications on people's basic human rights, I might agree but driving is a privilege, not a right.
- stavros 2y agoIt's very different to watch 1% of drivers, 1% of the time, and to watch 100% of drivers, 100% of the time. There's no room for change if law enforcement is absolute. Imagine if gay people could never sex, because a microchip zapped their brain whenever they got a sexual thought about a member of the same sex. Homosexuality would still be illegal.
- novagameco 2y agoPutting a microchip in people's brains is a completely different thing than putting a microchip in people's cars. People have a right to bodily autonomy; they don't have a right to drive a car. The first would violate human rights on principle alone, the second has no implication on human rights
- kerkeslager 2y agoI think that very much depends on what the chip in the car does. If it effectively broadcasts your movements to the government, I very much think that does have human rights implications (on the right to privacy). However, if the chip just limits your car's speed, I have trouble imagining what rights that would violate. Your right to speed? C'mon.
- Boltgolt 2y agoIs it "pre-crime" if it activates once you are speeding? Surely we can agree that is a crime
- stavros 2y agoNot if it makes it so you can't speed.
- its_ethan 2y agoIs it a crime where "100% enforcement" is worth surrendering (even more) individual privacy?
- kerkeslager 2y agoSorry, what individual privacy is being surrendered here? Note that observing the driver is in no way necessary to implement a speed limiter.
- its_ethan 2y agoYea I've noted that there doesn't have to be a camera pointed at the driver... there does, however, have to be either a GPS and/or camera pointing outwards (that could be used to ID location) in order to know what the current speed limit is for the drivers given location. So the individual privacy at risk is the privacy of not having your location at any given time being knowable to a car manufacturer/ government agency.
- kerkeslager 2y ago> [T]here does, however, have to be either a GPS and/or camera pointing outwards (that could be used to ID location) in order to know what the current speed limit is for the drivers given location. Used by whom? The mechanic who services my car? I see the problem if the location data is being broadcast to some central server... so don't do that. But that's not necessary for implementation. The ideal implementation in my mind would be to have speed limit signs broadcast speeds on some short-distance frequency and have cars read that passively: much more reliable than cameras, no violation of privacy. Incidentally, cars broadcasting location to a central server is already a problem--they don't need speed limiting to do that. OnStar has been doing this for decades. It seems like a lot of HN users who likely happily broadcast their location to Google Maps are suddenly worried about location privacy when it's used to prevent them from speeding. Minor convenience? Sure! Take my privacy! Can't put other people's lives at risk to get to my destination a few seconds faster? How dare you! Privacy is a human right!
- tech_ken 2y ago> This feels very Big Brother, where someone (or some system) is watching over you so you don't break any laws Is having a speed-limit in the first place 'pre-crime prevention'? Regulating technology that can have public health implications is standard for governments, so to me it seems normal that they might site this regulation in the vehicle itself, rather than at usage-time. Is requiring cars to have like an ABS system preventing users from committing the crime of vehicular manslaughter? Or is it protecting the pedestrian from being killed by a negligent driver?
- stavros 2y agoThere's no downside to ABS. There's plenty of downside to a system that blanket bans speeding, even when the operator knows better than the system and is taking a calculated risk.
- tech_ken 2y agoThat's a subtle change of framing; I'm talking about this idea of the thing as a 'pre-crime' tool. I agree that the implementation you describe (ex. a hard cap on speed based on ex. GPS speed limit data) is a 'bad idea', but I don't agree that it's like a 'big brother bad idea', just that it's a bad implementation of an otherwise normal idea. There's plenty of ways one can imagine a gentle system of pushback against speed limits (ex. a warning bell, haptic feedback, mechanical governor impeding the engine from exceeding a certain RPM) that would not have the risks you're using to differentiate this from ABS.
- stavros 2y agoI agree, if it's just a reminder, it's not as bad, it's just a step in the wrong direction. If they then change it to prevent you from breaking the limit, that will really be a nightmare scenario.
- tech_ken 2y ago> If they then change it to prevent you from breaking the limit But your ability to break the limit is fully predicted on the capabilities of the car? It's not like it's some kind of natural right you have to go 80 in a 65, you need someone to make and sell you a vehicle which will do that for you, and regulatory bodies limit the capabilities of consumer goods all the time (ex. radio transmitter devices). Again say they required a mechanical governor in the car which capped the limit at say 60mph for all vehicles sold, it's going to prevent you from accelerating faster than that always (so no 'braking' at any point, but at 60mph your engine will no longer by able to apply acceleration). Is this also a nightmare scenario? Or is it specifically the telemetry required to localize that to the roadway speed limit?
- nunez 2y agoWell if so many folks didn't speed all the damn time, and if speeding wasn't one of the top cause of vehicular accidents (in the US), then we wouldn't need this
- stavros 2y ago"One of the top" is a nice weasel phrase. Lightning strike is one of the top causes of death in the US too, for a large enough number of causes. Not wearing a seat belt caused more deaths than speeding, yet cars don't refuse to start without a seat belt.
- nunez 2y agoNot a weasel phrase. 10-20k deaths/year are caused by speeding. #2 cause of passenger accidents in the US according to The Zebra. https://www.thezebra.com/resources/driving/causes-of-fatal-car-accidents/ https://www.thezebra.com/resources/driving/causes-of-fatal-c...