3 ms·
> from India to Mesopotamia to Greece surely nobody thinks that zero spread from aryabhata 1500 years ago to the mesopotamians† 2700 years ago, and classical a
by kragen 2y ago
> from India to Mesopotamia to Greece
surely nobody thinks that zero spread from aryabhata 1500 years ago to the mesopotamians† 2700 years ago, and classical and hellenistic greece didn't even have a numeral for zero, much less the idea that zero was a number. (obviously the greeks have been using a numeral for zero for several hundred years now)
the hypothetico-deductive method that defines what we call 'mathematics' today does seem to have originated in the hellenistic period, although probably in alexandria rather than in greece proper. but menon and the timaios show that the pythagoreans already had the rudiments of it in classical greece, and there's no evidence that anything similar existed during the thousand-plus preceding years of mesopotamian mathematics. i think that's what you're saying
on the other hand, the majority of greek mathematics during the classical and hellenistic period was still mostly 'a tool, a method for business and construction [planners] to [derive] certain quantities', even if the calculations were being done on sand-tables instead of counting-boards. systems of axioms don't make an appearance in the surviving written record until roughly euclid; aristotle, plato, and pythagoras evidently weren't yet familiar with what we call 'mathematics' and in particular 'proof', although the later mathematicians, especially in the hellenistic period, did build on their work
so i think it's a mistake to talk about 'the greeks' as if they were a single person, like in a game of civ; all the greeks alive in plato's time were already dead by euclid's time, euclid didn't even live in greece, all the greeks alive in euclid's time were already dead by ptolemy's time, there are still greeks today, and in any time period, different greek people knew different things
______
† https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jAMRTGv82Zo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jAMRTGv82Zo