4 ms·
> When the sexagesimal Mesopotamian number system began to be used positionally, a symbol for "zero" had to be added the sexagesimal mesopotamian number system
by kragen 2y ago
> When the sexagesimal Mesopotamian number system began to be used positionally, a symbol for "zero" had to be added
the sexagesimal mesopotamian number system was used positionally from the beginning (that's what was sexagesimal about it) and, as the article explains, did not have a symbol for zero in common use, or evidently at all for millennia. the early zero symbol mentioned in the article is from a tablet from 0700 bce or later, which is only 2700 years ago. at that point positional sexagesimal mesopotamian numerals were already about 1000–2000 years old. what popova doesn't explain is that they often used an empty space for zero instead
- srean 2y agoHaving a symbol (for zero) is half the solution. It takes another leap to treat zero as number that participates in the usual arithmetic operations. From what I understand, there were a variety of non-standardized symbols or place holders used by the Mesopotamians (space being one). Zero was not treated as a number, but as a special case in their evaluator.
- kragen 2y agoi agree and have elaborated a bit more on the theme in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40918326 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40918326
- jacobolus 2y ago> sexagesimal mesopotamian number system was used positionally from the beginning This is oversimplified. The sexagesimal place-value system developed gradually over centuries+ from various inconsistent unit systems for length, weight, fluid volume, counting, ..., which were eventually (partially) standardized. This long development took place in tandem with the development of cuneiform writing, both ultimately originating in a record-keeping system involving clay tokens sealed in clay envelopes. For a detailed version, Eleanor Robson's book Mathematics in Ancient Iraq is excellent.
- kragen 2y agothat's true, but to the extent that at any given time it was purely sexagesimal, it was also positional, wasn't it? the book recommendation is greatly appreciated
- jacobolus 2y agoI think it's fuzzier than that, both as a historical process (stretching across more than a millennium of development), and as a tool at any particular point in time. Here's some quotation from Robson: The very earliest literate accounts – from late fourth-millenium Uruk – used commodity-specific metrologies with a variety of different numerical relationships between the units. Those original metrologies continued in use throughout the third milennium and beyond, whether essentially unchanged (for instance areas), or undergoing periodical reform (for instance capacities). They continued to be written with compound signs, which bundled both quantity and unit into a single grapheme, just as the preliterate accounting tokens must have done. Gradually, over the course of the later third millennium, scribes began to write those compound metrological numerals with a cuneiform stylus, rather than impressing a round stylus into the clay in imitation of accounting tokens. Throughout the Sargonic period, and even into the early Ur I period, impressed and incised number notations apear side by side on the same tablets – a phenomenon that has not yet been systematically documented or explained. [...] But not every new metrological unit was sexagesimally structured. The smaller length measures, first attested in the Early Dynastic IIIb period, divide the rod into 2 reeds or 12 cubits, and the cubit into 30 fingers. None of these newly invented units of measure was recorded with compound metrological numerals, but always written as numbers recorded according to the discrete notation system followed by a separate sign for the metrological unit. This has implications for our understanding of the material culture of early Mesopotamian calculation, as well as for the shifting conceptualisation of number. [...] At some point early in the Ur III period, the generalised sexagesimal fraction and the generalised unit fraction were productively combined to create a new cognitive tool: the sexagesimal place value system. This calculating device took quantities expressed in traditional metrologies and reconfigured them as sexagesimal multiples or fractions of a base unit, often at convenient meeting point between metrological systems. [...] The SPVS temporarily changed the status of numbers from properties of real-world objects to independent entities that could be manipulated without regard to absolute value or metrological system. Calculations could thus transform numbers from lengths into areas, or from capacity units of grain into discretely counted recipients of rations, without concern for the objects to which they pertained. Once the calculation was done, the result was expressed in the most appropriate metrological units and thus re-entered the natural world as a concrete quantity.