2 ms·
"My dream", says Dave Arney, a researcher on the project, "is that a hospital will eventually be able to print out an infusion pump using a rapid prototyping ma
by HeyLaughingBoy 14y ago
"My dream", says Dave Arney, a researcher on the project, "is that a hospital will eventually be able to print out an infusion pump using a rapid prototyping machine, download open-source software to it and have a device running within hours."
What can I say; dare to dream. Because that's what this is - a dream.
Print out a pump? OK. Was the 3D printer's performance to all relevant specs validated? Were the materials it uses approved and inspected along with their certificates to be sure the pump was being made from the material the designer specified? Was the material stored properly before use and was the pump it printed tested to ensure that it met all its requirements?
The software is probably easier to handle, surprisingly. The FDA probably wouldn't care that it was open source, but would the OSS developers be willing to follow a validated process, document that they are following the process, submit to random audits of that process being followed?
Who handles customer complaints? FDA requires that a Medical Device manufacturer have a procedure to record and respond to customer complaints and comments in a timely fashion. If a physician notices that every morning at 8:00AM the pump puts out an additional 5%, who will log that concern and investigate it. If it requires a recall, how do you even recall something you can't track since people are just printing the pumps out as they need them.
The Medical Device industry is screaming for innovation and I hate to be a party pooper, but this is a dream. And unfortunately, it will remain a dream for very good, common sense reasons.
- ktizo 14y agoI cannot think of a single objection you have raised that is to do with 3d printing rather than to do with quality control and process tracking, and quality control can be made far easier with 3d printing as you can change production as soon as a fault is discovered, so you don't end up with a warehouse full of a million faulty pumps. And tracking could be achieved by embedding rfids mid-print without a problem.
- HeyLaughingBoy 14y agoThe problem isn't with the 3D printing itself, it's with an end user (the hospital) that doesn't have manufacturing skill and 21CFR knowledge printing off a medical device. It's a nice idea, but the FDA would have a change a huge amount before something like this has a ghost of a chance.
- ktizo 14y agoThere is always the rest of the world, and given they are already using it for bone replacement - http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-16907104 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-16907104 - I don't see what the issue is for pumps. [edit] Also, remember that the end users at this stage are medical geeks of a level of educational qualification that would put the vast amount of people working in software to shame. Some of these people are already making organ printers. I'm sure they can work out medical good practices for in-house manufactured parts and get it approved in most of the world, especially when the full benefits of custom parts as fast as possible becomes apparent.