3 ms·
Chevron reversal is a high impact ruling that has slipped under the radar for most. Previously, the courts were to defer to the federal agency rules, unless the
by verdverm 2y ago
Chevron reversal is a high impact ruling that has slipped under the radar for most. Previously, the courts were to defer to the federal agency rules, unless they were egregious. Now, any rule can be challenged and the value set by a judge.
Legal experts expect an influx of cases, the consequences unknown but likely significant. Those with money can hire "expert witnesses" and pick favorable courts
- skhunted 2y agoGiven where this court is heading it’s clear that they will require a level of specificity in the writing of laws granting regulatory authority to agencies that is impractical. This impracticality in part comes from the fact that Republican legislators are opposed to any regulations that might harm corporate profits.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rqtwteye 2y agoWe are reaching the libertarian dream. Polluters shall celebrate.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoIt's going to backfire on the libertarian's massively. Environmentalists are going to weaponize Chevron and bring polluters into court in massive numbers. Judges now get to interpret Congress's vague rules instead of the agencies. Some judges will interpret in favor of the company, others in favor of the environmentalists. So companies will not have a clear idea what the actual regulations are. Uncertainty will reign, and uncertainty is bad for business, even worse than harsh but clear rules.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 2y agoExcept no this won't happen. They may try to bring polluters to courts, but the court system will be backlogged so they could pollute for years without consequences. And when they do get to court many many years from now, politically appointed judges will rule politically, not legally. That seems to be the standard now.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoThe politically appointed judges in many states are appointed by Democrats. Also a case that is bogged down in the courts is in some ways worse because it is yet another source of uncertainty.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 2y ago> The politically appointed judges in many states are appointed by Democrats. And in many states they are appointed by republicans. Companies already venue shop to cases to get the judge they want. Why won't this continue to happen? > a case that is bogged down in the courts is in some ways worse because it is yet another source of uncertainty. It's not for the companies because while its bogged down, its business-as-usual. The longer they can delay, the better for them.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoIt'll be the environmental orgs bringing the cases that will be doing the venue shopping, not the corps. > while its bogged down, its business-as-usual. Uncertainty is bad for business.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 2y ago> Uncertainty is bad for business. Only some kinds, while other kinds are great for business. For example, the tabacco industry very deliberately created uncertainty about the links between smoking and lung cancer for years and years because it meant in the meantime they could continue business as usual.
- JackFr 2y agoYou know Chevron won Chevron v. NRDC, right?
- falcolas 2y agoThe judiciary agreeing with the regulatory agency once decades ago does not set a useful precedent. Well, it did, but that precedent was just revoked.
- marcuskane2 2y agoFar from it. I'm a libertarian and an environmentalist. Pollution is harming other people just as clearly and directly as assault, rape or murder and so regulations against that harm still fit naturally and comfortably within even fairly extreme or hardline libertarian frameworks. A law that says "You can't spray mace in someone's face" and a law that says "You can't spray <whatever other harmful chemical> in <the air that will eventually hit people's faces>" are ideologically the same. Perhaps you meant it's a fascist, statist or autocratic dream? The people with power (economic, political, social) get to benefit while the people without power get harmed.
- rqtwteye 2y agoThe libertarians I know are against regulation. Instead you are supposed to sue the party that has injured you. Good luck proving that you were injured for example by leaded gas. It's hard enough for a government agency with many lawyers and scientists to prove long term harm done by pollution. As the little guy you have no chance against a company with deep pockets who can buy as many expert witnesses and lawyers as needed.
- vundercind 2y agoOne really shitty part was that they went “oh but this doesn’t invalidate past rulings, don’t worry” in that opinion… But then, in another opinion they knew they were delivering this session when they finalized that, they removed the statute of limitations on challenging federal regulations, so actually it does mean they’re all (well, any that inconveniences a corporation) going to be reviewed without Chevron deference. They basically lied, all back-to-back so it was obvious.
- falcolas 2y agoThis is understated and important. The removal of the statue of limitations means that any new company that's formed can challenge any regulations that they are subject to, no matter when the regulation was formed. Combined with Chevron's reversal and the increased power of the judiciary, well, I think it's going to paradoxically destroy the court system. Imagine the delays when thousands of companies sue to challenge millions of regulations.
- vundercind 2y agoThis session was a big power grab for the courts all around. Even the apparent increase in power for the President—significant de jure, and very broad de facto immunity from the law—is largely an increase in power for the courts, since they may now selectively apply the law to a President. The Supreme Court (ultimately) now decides not whether a President is guilty of, say, murder committed while in office, but whether they may even be tried for it. Though, yeah, it’s gonna gum up the works in a big way. I wonder if they’ll see a budget increase and large increase in the number of (lower) court judges (so, new appointments) if the elections go a certain way in November.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- JackFr 2y agoLet's refresh everyone's memory. Chevron won Chevron v. Natural Resource Defense Council. The case focused on what was meant by a 'source' of pollution as used in the Clean Air Act of 1963. The EPA was on the side of Chevron, and NRDC sued in the hopes that the court would interpret the law as they, rather than the EPA, interpreted it. The court deferred to the EPA. So while you think you might want deference to the agency, sometimes it's nice to have a judge.
- verdverm 2y agoI'm using "Chevron" as short for "Chevron Doctrine" which established the deference to agency, some 40 years ago. With the reversal, who knows what will happen? We can be sure that both congress is unable to legislate effectively, and that the court systems are ill equipped by design, to deal with rapidly changing scientific developments and progress. https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/chevron_deference https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/chevron_deference
- sickofparadox 2y agoParent poster knows what the Chevron Doctrine is, and is commenting on the outcome of the case which established it, which is mentioned by its full name in the second line of the webpage you linked.