4 ms·
Effective altruism is stumbling. Can "moral ambition" replace it?
- recursivedoubts 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- VoodooJuJu 2y agoTo answer this question and many more, I would recommend abandoning modern religions and returning to traditional ones. You'll find ancient wisdom has answers to a lot of modern problems and questions, like the topic in the linked article. It's just really inefficient to slowly rediscover the answers to these age-old questions when there are already a lot of very good answers that very wise men suffered for a very long time ago. I realize many moderns harbor dogmas that may prohibit them from engaging with anything that isn't completely secular, but all I can say is: try to be a bit more open-minded and re-engage with traditional wisdom. There's a reason it's survived the test of time, thousands of years. I'm biased toward Greek Orthodox.
- JohnFen 2y agoThat isn't very helpful with religions that expect you to believe their dogma, though. Religions tend to expect you to at least pretend to believe in their more supernatural aspects. In this respect, religions are exclusive rather than inclusive. Talking about philosophies rather than religious belief would allow more people to engage.
- LiquidSky 2y ago>I realize many moderns harbor dogmas that may prohibit them from engaging with anything that isn't completely secular, but all I can say is: try to be a bit more open-minded The irony of these statements being employed in a post arguing FOR religion is beyond, well, belief.
- itishappy 2y agoUnitarian Universalist offers an alternative for those who prefer a less orthodox belief system. Less "God says do this" more "let's discuss ethics and morality." I'm not a member, but I've had a chance to attend a few events and services. I tend to be quite critical of organized religion, but it was quite refreshing! https://www.uua.org/beliefs/what-we-believe/principles https://www.uua.org/beliefs/what-we-believe/principles
- hindsightbias 2y agoWhat era do you pick for the wisdom? Early Christians would be called commies today.
- gizmo 2y agoHumanity evolved 300,000 years ago 290,000 of which we spent in dirt huts. Then we built supercomputers, went to space, and split the atom. It all happened in the blink of an eye. Zero growth is what we've seen for most of humanity. Our present growth means we're doing a lot right. The main problem, as I see it, is that the slow grind forward can be more than offset by disastrous setbacks. Wars. Famines. Dark ages. Collapses of democracy or civil rights. It's not "moral courage" or lack of forward progress we should be worried about. I'm confident the upside will take care of itself. Humanity will continue to invent and innovate because it's in our nature. As long as we don't blow up the civilizations we've built we're going to be just fine. This might require courage, but not the kind of moral exceptionalism Bregman is thinking of.
- jameskilton 2y agoEffective altruism never had solid footing to begin with. It was nothing more than a ploy to let rich people feel good about being rich (or at least, to convince them that they don't have to feel guilty about everyone they've stepped on over the years). If these people were actually altruistic, they would be giving away their wealth today.
- itishappy 2y agoDon't they? I thought a huge part of the EA racket was selecting the most efficient way to give away wealth. Many have even given away organs.
- itsdrewmiller 2y agoEffective altruism generally encourages donating 10%+ of income, which is quite a bit more than the average American. It’s hard for me to see how it isn’t doing more good than harm, even with all the buying castles nonsense.